ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: City of Everett gave the Snohomish River Watershed legal rights — what could possibly go wrong? Everything.

The City of Everett’s move to grant the Snohomish River watershed legal rights to “exist, regenerate and flourish” sparks a lawsuit.

The City of Everett granted the Snohomish River legal rights via an initiative. It's a bad idea. (P...

The City of Everett granted the Snohomish River legal rights via an initiative. It's a bad idea. (Photo: Snohomish County Parks and Recreation)

(Photo: Snohomish County Parks and Recreation)

It is absurd to consider that a body of water might have rights in the same way humans do—but that is exactly the world we are being told to accept in Everett. The notion that the Snohomish River watershed might walk into court (flow into court?) and sue developers or polluters makes a mockery of our legal system, no matter how well-intentioned the goal of environmental protection.

Voters in the city of Everett approved Initiative 24-03 on November 5, 2024, which grants the Snohomish River Watershed within city limits the right to “exist, regenerate and flourish,” and gives it legal standing to enforce those rights through lawsuits. The measure passed with about 57 % of the vote.

This entire episode makes a farce of the legal system and the upcoming court hearing is a waste of time and resources.

Here’s how we got to the point where we’re pretending rivers have rights

Under the initiative, “residents, city agencies and organizations” could sue anyone whose actions violate the watershed’s rights. The law states that penalties would fund restoration of the watershed. The idea is part of a growing “rights of nature” movement, already seen in places like Ecuador, New Zealand and a few U.S. jurisdictions.

But almost immediately the backlash began.

Local developers and business groups filed a complaint in the Master Builders Association of King and Snohomish Counties, arguing that the initiative exceeds legal boundaries for local initiatives in Washington and is unconstitutionally vague. The city attorney even sided with the challengers in September 2025, acknowledging that “existing federal and state law … are already in place” to protect the watershed. There is a hearing on Friday in Snohomish County Superior Court. We should be able to predict how this lawsuit will go.

ADVERTISEMENT

A silly and futile debate

The debate is ridiculous.

On one side, we have advocates who say our legal tools to protect rivers, fish, salmon and ecosystems are inadequate, so we must grant nature enforceable rights. On the other side, we have reasonable people who warn that granting rights to rivers undermines the foundations of our legal system and will lead to unpredictable lawsuits, likely by attorneys seeking profit and eco-extremists who want to stand in the way of all development.

In the middle is the City of Everett and local residents who genuinely care about restoring the river, but put themselves in this mess. The watershed has real problems—pollution, habitat loss, salmon decline—a fact no one disputes. The idea of holding polluters accountable is broadly popular. But the legal innovation of treating a river as a rights-bearing entity poses obvious problems.

ADVERTISEMENT

A river isn’t a person and no one can take vast ownership of a river’s ‘feelings’

The concept of legal standing is the biggest issue. Under established law, someone initiating a lawsuit must show they personally have been injured or face imminent injury. Rights of nature attempts to bypass that, by giving standing to non-human entities. But most courts are rightly hostile to the idea that a river itself can be a legal “person.” Anyone speaking on its behalf, unless it owns the river, could hold a completely different view than another person who will also claim to speak for the river and take an opposing viewpoint.

There is also a state pre-emption legislation that says local governments cannot enact laws that conflict with state law or intrude on state regulation. Washington law severely limits local initiative powers when they interfere with state regulatory schemes.

ADVERTISEMENT

The rule of law matters. We defend environmental stewardship, but we also guard against extremist and ideological legal constructs that threaten property rights, due process, and practical governance. How do you allow for any development if nature has rights? Wouldn’t that pile of dirt and weeds object to a duplex being built? What about that patch of grass? Surely it would object to a new condo complex.

You can still care for the environment, while rejecting this kind of extremism

Rejecting this stupid law doesn’t mean we abandon caring for the environment—or stop supporting restoration of the Snohomish watershed.

We can endorse cleanup efforts, habitat protection, enforce pollutant penalties, fish-friendly legislation and smart development. What we should oppose is turning a river into a litigant as if it’s a person. That crosses from sensible conservation into a legal farce.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rivers are not people; Rivers Cuomo is the closest you’ll get. Rivers cannot exercise rights in the way the initiative hopes. The law has established mechanisms for protecting waterways and acting against polluters, through statutes, regulatory agencies, and citizen lawsuits under well-defined standards. What this initiative attempts is something different, something new, and something that will ultimately fail. The court’s time is wasted.

We can and should protect the environment while also rejecting extreme legal theories that make a joke of the rule of law.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

K
Kevin Lee 1 year ago

Nobody comments here yet... wish everybody here was forced to read my above comment.
I've kayaked SO many rivers & seen unimaginable canyons end in lakes... so shallow you could walk on the sediment/rocks...
That sediment WILL go to the ocean one day wether we like it or not...
Once a dam/lake fills, the "flood protection" is gone along w/ millions of folks lives below.

K
Kevin Lee 1 year ago

For the record, I am the media's definition of "far right."
I hate dams, the Culmback Dam plugs the Sultan river & provides water & power for Everett.
This is not a "sustainable" resource.
The plugged river killed salmon species (forever) when built & today destroys maybe the best kayaking river in the world. Thankfully it is "released" at medium flows once a year now for us & I'm thankful...
"Spada Lake" (unnatural & inaccessible) will fill with sediment one day long after we're dead. Future generations will be left deciding how to move centuries of sediment downstream...
There's no good answer... the river will have to flow HUGE likely destroying homes & ecosystems to move centuries of "green energy" aftermath.