Rantz: Democrats are counting on you to stop reading before Patty Murray’s TSA shutdown spin falls apart
ason Rantz exposes how Sen. Patty Murray's Senate floor speech on the TSA shutdown is built to hide Democrats' push to defund ICE. It only works if you stop reading.
Sen. Patty Murray listens during a Senate hearing. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
(Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
There is a single organizing principle behind the entire Democratic Party messaging operation right now, and Washington Sen. Patty Murray handed it to you gift-wrapped Monday on the Senate floor. The principle around the a 37-day DHS shutdown is straightforward. If you frame a policy fight with enough emotional urgency, most voters will never stop to ask what the policy fight is actually about. But in order for the strategy to work, you have to be as dumb as they hope you are.
That is not a strategy built on respect for the public. Quite the opposite: it is a strategy built on contempt for it, all while using unpaid TSA workers as pawns.
Murray, vice chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee, took to the floor to attack Republicans over a government funding dispute, specifically their push to tie border security and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) funding to broader agency spending. Her framing was surgical in its dishonesty. She cast the entire debate as Republicans holding TSA workers hostage so they could funnel cash to agencies that, in her telling, are already swimming in money they cannot spend responsibly.
Yet the truth is Murray is accusing Republicans of engaging in the exact behavior the Democrats are responsible for. The Democrats are leveraging pain at our airports to meet their end goal of defunding and abolishing ICE.
The quote from Murray’s Senate floor speech that exposes the whole strategy
Murray said on the Senate floor Monday: “Republicans are saying, We will not let you give TSA or other important agencies a single dollar unless you let us shovel billions of dollars to ICE and Border Patrol, which are already sitting on billions of dollars.”
She then said: “Think about how absurd that is.”
The absurdity, Senator, is the framing itself. The funding dispute exists because Democrats have spent months blocking Republican priorities on immigration enforcement. Tying enforcement funding to a broader spending package is not hostage-taking. It is legislating. The suggestion that Republicans are responsible for TSA workers going without pay, while Democrats refuse to move a bill that could resolve both issues, is the kind of spin that only survives if you stop reading at the headline.
Murray continued on the Senate floor: “Republicans won’t let us give more funding to TSA, which can’t pay its employees right now, unless they can give more money to ICE and Border Patrol, even when Republicans know ICE officers are still getting paychecks, because Republicans know Border Patrol agents are getting paychecks, they know they already shoveled billions of dollars at these agencies in their big ugly bill.”
That is technically true in the narrowest possible construction and deeply misleading in every other respect. Yes, ICE officers are getting paychecks. That is not an argument for underfunding an agency actively carrying out deportations the American public supports by significant margins. It is the equivalent of saying firefighters are receiving their salaries, so there is no reason to buy them water or fire trucks.
Murray demands ICE accountability — the senator who voted for COVID waste and watched Washington defund police
Murray also attacked the administration’s spending on Homeland Security, arguing on the Senate floor that Secretary [Noem] “went out and blew hundreds of million dollars to cut ridiculous ads and plaster her face all over TV.”
Her conclusion, delivered with characteristic moral certainty, was this. Murray said on the Senate floor: “So what ICE and Border Patrol need is not more money.”
She then said on the Senate floor: “What they need is accountability.”
Accountability. From Patty Murray?
This is a senator who voted for COVID stimulus packages that produced some of the most extensively documented waste and fraud in modern American government. She has represented a state where city governments defunded police and watched violent crime rise, and offered nothing but silence. She has helped accumulate a national debt that crossed $36 trillion and consistently called it investment. She now wants to lecture a Cabinet secretary about fiscal discipline. The audacity is genuinely impressive.
The Democratic playbook: use unpaid TSA workers to shield their push against ICE funding
Murray’s floor speech is not an anomaly. It is the template to deflect blame for airport security lines. Find the most sympathetic figure in any policy fight, in this case a TSA worker who hasn’t been paid, build every sentence around that image, and never allow the audience close enough to the actual bill to read what is inside it.
The lazy strategy works when it works because it requires voters to stop exactly one question too early. Democrats need you to hear “TSA workers aren’t getting paid,” feel the appropriate outrage, and move on without asking who is actually blocking resolution, what Democrats are refusing to accept as part of any deal, or why the same party that ignored border chaos for years is suddenly laser-focused on agency accountability.
The entire Democratic messaging operation is a calculated bet that you are exactly as uninformed as they need you to be. Murray’s speech was not an argument for workers. It was an argument against scrutiny. The moment you look past the framing, the bet falls apart. All you have to do is keep reading.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
"Yet the truth is Murray is accusing Republicans of engaging in the exact behavior the Democrats are responsible for." ~ Jason Rantz
Straight from Saul Alinsky's "Rules for Radicals," the Progressive Socialists'/Leftists'/Dimocrats' bible. When obfuscation is the only card you've got...