ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: A James Beard-nominated chef just fled Seattle, and the people running this city still call the exodus ‘overblown’

Brendan McGill, a James Beard-nominated chef, just closed his last Seattle restaurants for Bainbridge. Mayor Katie Wilson's answer to the exodus? Bye.

A James Beard award...

Chef Brendan McGill, a James Beard semifinalist, closes Café Hitchcock and Oyster Cellar in downtown Seattle's Exchange Building. (Photo by Jeff Schear/Getty Images for James Beard Foundation)

(Photo by Jeff Schear/Getty Images for James Beard Foundation)

James Beard-nominated chef Brendan McGill closed his last two Seattle restaurants after 15 years downtown and is moving his operation back to Bainbridge Island because the numbers no longer work in the city he helped feed. He’s not flaming out. He just ran the financials, looked at the business environment, and it told him to leave.

McGill shuttered Café Hitchcock and Oyster Cellar on May 31, ending a downtown run that also included Bar Taglio, Hitchcock Deli, and Café Hitchcock Express, according to The Puget Sound Business Journal via MyNorthwest. He’ll keep running three restaurants and a new wholesale operation on Bainbridge Island. He stopped pretending downtown Seattle pencils out.

That’s the part Mayor Katie Wilson and Washington Democrats keep refusing to admit. The people walking away from Seattle aren’t bomb-throwing partisans settling scores. They’re chefs, founders, and operators doing fourth-grade arithmetic on rent, foot traffic, and policy.

A James Beard nomination, not a grudge

McGill made a point of not trashing the city on the way out. He sounded almost sad about it.

“When I look back through the last couple of years of what we’ve been through, it feels a little bleak,” he told The Puget Sound Business Journal. “But when I look at the whole arc of it, I feel really pleased with what we put forth.”

McGill said Seattle is no longer a “no-brainer” for doing business and put it in terms anyone can follow.

“I’m not sure that my love for [Seattle] and my long history of being here can justify unsound business decisions at this point,” he stated. “The smarter business move would be to open in a place whose business environment is rolling, like Bellevue or even Tacoma.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Bellevue. Tacoma. He also flagged Spokane, Boise, and Edmonds as better bets. Any city in Washington that isn’t run like Seattle is apparently more attractive than the city Seattle’s leadership keeps insisting is thriving.

The flow changed, and Seattle’s leaders pretend they didn’t change it

McGill, to his credit, doesn’t think Seattle is in full decline. He thinks the energy moved, to a point.

“Some places, like near the waterfront or Seattle Convention Center, are probably better positioned now than before,” he noted. “The old thing of people strolling First Avenue to Pioneer Square when you visit Seattle, that flow has changed. There are winners and losers with the way things got shuffled.”

I will say what McGill won’t directly. Years of soft-on-crime prosecution, open-air drug markets, a decimated police department, and a downtown that was deliberately allowed to rot through the pandemic and never recovered. His old building, the 97-year-old Exchange Building, lost its anchor tenant Slalom in late 2023. The Coleman Building across the street has hemorrhaged retailers over the last six years, with Starbucks, UPS, Quiznos, Fadó Irish Pub, and the Contour nightclub all gone.

ADVERTISEMENT

Katie Wilson said ‘Bye’

While McGill packs up, Mayor Katie Wilson is still running the same routine she ran during the campaign. When a Seattle University audience asked her this spring whether Washington’s new 9.9% income tax on top earners would chase them out, she said the concern was overblown.

“I think the claims that millionaires are going to leave our state are, like, super overblown,” she said. “And if, the ones that leave, like, bye.”

Bye. That’s how the mayor of a major American city talks about the people who hire her constituents.

She’s wrong, by the way. Net migration into Washington dropped 7,500 as Washington Democrats signed the income tax into law. The Association of Washington Businesses has tracked a near-doubling in the number of businesses considering leaving the state since the tax was first floated. Tech founders are decamping to Nevada. Now even a James Beard-nominated chef who grew up loving this city is saying Tacoma looks like the smarter buy.

ADVERTISEMENT

McGill won’t call it decline. He’s a gentleman. But when a James Beard talent is choosing any other city but Seattle, and your mayor’s response to the exodus is “bye,” you don’t have a foot-traffic problem. You have a leadership problem. And the people paying for it are the ones still trying to keep a restaurant open on First Avenue.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

D
Dean Hardwick 6 months ago

Brendan McGill should consider Coeur d'Alene it is a resort town 2000 ft above sea level in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains more sunshine than Puget Sound

C
Cuba Pete 6 months ago

@MandaFactor said ten years in Seattle…It was a good 20-year run.