Rantz: Sen. Patty Murray sold COVID mandates for years, now launches panel to tell Americans whom to trust
Senator Patty Murray wants to rebuild trust in public health. Her COVID record, from failed mandates to vaccine claims, shows why Americans stopped trusting.
Senator Patty Murray announced a working group aimed at rebuilding trust in public health. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch-Pool/Getty Images)
(Photo by Kevin Dietsch-Pool/Getty Images)
Senator Patty Murray wants Americans to trust public health officials again, and she has decided she’s the right person to lead that effort. The problem is she’s the senator who spent the pandemic defending mandates the courts tossed and vaccine claims the CDC itself walked back.
On Wednesday, the Washington Democrat announced the Public Health for America Working Group, a panel of experts charged with drafting a “blueprint” for health policy after President Donald Trump and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. leave office. She plans to launch it with an event at Washington State University in Pullman.
Murray blames Kennedy for Americans tuning out the CDC. Her pandemic record points closer to the reality.
Murray says Kennedy broke the system
Murray announced the group with a statement accusing the administration of downplaying rising measles cases and responding slowly to a cyclosporiasis outbreak that sickened thousands of Americans this year.
“Right now, Trump and RFK Jr. have put our public health system on life support,” Murray said.
She pointed to a Harvard School of Public Health and de Beaumont Foundation poll showing the share of Americans who trust CDC recommendations fell from 77% to 50% during Kennedy’s first year overseeing the agency. Murray and Kennedy have clashed repeatedly, including a May 2025 hearing where he accused her of presiding over the destruction of Americans’ health during her decades in the Senate.
Kennedy did not invent skepticism of the CDC. Murray led the Senate Health Committee through the pandemic, and her record from those years explains plenty.
Murray’s COVID record
In May 2021, Murray opened a Health Committee hearing featuring Anthony Fauci and then-CDC Director Rochelle Walensky by urging Americans to get vaccinated “not just to protect themselves, but to protect those around them and stop this disease from spreading or mutating into new deadly strains,” according to a hearing transcript.
Three months later, Walensky acknowledged that the vaccines did not prevent transmission.
Murray kept making the pitch anyway. In January 2022, the Supreme Court blocked the Biden administration’s vaccine-or-test rule covering 84 million private sector workers, and Murray slammed the decision.
“The Biden Administration’s vaccine or testing safety standard is a common-sense step to protect workers and help stop the spread of COVID-19 in the workplace,” she argued.
She went further, calling the ruling “absurd” for undermining “a common-sense workplace safety measure that would save lives, keep people healthy, and prevent COVID-19 spread.”
Murray was also wrong on masking
Murray also went after Republican governors over classroom masking.
At a Health Committee hearing with Education Secretary Miguel Cardona and then-Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra, she accused GOP state leaders of “threatening school funding, banning mask requirements, and undermining efforts to get people vaccinated.”
The hard questions about who shaped the CDC’s school guidance came from the other side of the dais. Republican Senators Richard Burr and Susan Collins pressed Walensky on how teachers unions gained outsized input into the agency’s school reopening recommendations.
When Burr released an interim report in October 2022 pointing toward a possible lab leak, it bore only his signature; Murray, then the committee chair, said the panel’s bipartisan review would continue, the New York Times reported. Months later, FBI Director Christopher Wray said the pandemic “most likely” came from a potential lab incident in Wuhan, according to Axios.
Murray’s handpicked experts
The working group includes University of Washington professor Helen Chu, one of the 17 vaccine advisers Kennedy removed from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices in June 2025, and Vin Gupta, a UW-affiliated physician and medical analyst for far-left MS NOW.
Murray spokesman Amir Avin insisted the group’s findings “will inform nonpartisan policy proposals.” The panel was assembled by a Democrat and announced weeks before midterm elections that could hand Murray the gavel of the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Murray says public health policy “has to be reliably grounded in science and facts.” Her announcement offers no accounting of the years she spent selling the opposite.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
9 Comments
Anyone with common sense can plainly see that Patty Murray is severly lacking in any common sense.
“has to be reliably grounded in science and facts.” Well Murray, that leaves you out, you wouldn't know a "fact" if it hit between the eyes.
best thing about that picture is ol' horse teeth covering them up