ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Pramila Jayapal’s ‘proof’ for Medicare for All hasn’t been peer reviewed, authored by old Bernie Sanders advisor

Rep. Pramila Jayapal claims a Yale study confirmed Medicare for All. The paper is an unreviewed preprint tied to Bernie Sanders, and she skipped every caveat.

rep. pramila jayapal...

Rep. Pramila Jayapal cited a new Yale study as proof that Medicare for All saves lives and money, but the paper is a preprint that has not been peer reviewed. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

(Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Seattle) posted this week about new research from Yale, claiming it “has confirmed what we’ve said for years: Medicare for All doesn’t just save money, it saves lives.” She put numbers on it, too, claiming that over 114,000 lives a year plus more than a trillion dollars in savings, before declaring, “This study proves we can afford something better.”

The “study” does no such thing. Confirmed and proves are strong words for a paper that has not even been peer reviewed, written by a former advisor to Bernie Sanders who was with the senator when this very issue was being pushed as a policy.

The paper is a preprint, not a finding

The research Jayapal is citing went up on medRxiv on July 24. Preprint servers exist so scientists can circulate work before other scientists check it. Nobody has vetted the model, the assumptions, or the math.

Yale School of Public Health, which employs the lead author, described it in its own press release as a preprint that has not yet been peer reviewed. Scientific American said the same thing in its coverage and called peer review the gold standard quality check for academic research. Becker’s noted it too. Jayapal skipped that disclosure, and one not need wonder why.

You can argue a preprint is worth discussing. You cannot argue it confirmed or proved anything, because those words describe a process the paper has not been through yet.

The lead author advised the bill’s sponsor

Alison Galvani runs Yale’s Center for Infectious Disease Modeling and Analysis. She also served as an informal adviser to Sen. Bernie Sanders’ office while it drafted Medicare for All legislation, a fact her own team disclosed in a 2020 Lancet paper. She testified before the Senate HELP Committee in July 2025 at the invitation of the committee’s ranking member. That ranking member is Sanders, the Senate sponsor of Medicare for All.

ADVERTISEMENT

So, Sanders’ office gets advice from a researcher, that researcher publishes a model of his bill, and Sanders’ office issues a press release announcing that Yale researchers have confirmed the bill works. Jayapal, who leads the House version, amplifies it as independent validation. Nothing to see here, folks.

Nearly half the deaths have nothing to do with Medicare for All

The number Jayapal won’t put in her post is 51,311.

The study’s headline figure is 114,174 deaths averted annually, and 51,311 of those come from reversing coverage rollbacks enacted since 2025. Yale’s summary projects that undoing those policy changes would avert a further 51,311 deaths each year and bring the annual total to 114,174.

Reversing the 2025 health provisions and replacing the entire American insurance system with a single federal payer are two different policies. You can support one and reject the other. The study bundles them, and Jayapal presents the bundled figure as the payoff for her bill because it may help her specious argument.

ADVERTISEMENT

Strip out the rollback reversal and you are around 63,000, which is close to the 68,000 figure Galvani’s team published in The Lancet back in 2020. Six years of rising costs and the underlying single payer mortality claim barely moved at all.

‘We can afford it’ is not what the study says

Jayapal’s most misleading claim is about affordability.

The trillion dollars is a reduction in national health expenditure, meaning all spending by everyone in the country (employers, households, insurers, state governments, and the feds). The researchers estimate total spending falls from roughly $5.2 trillion to roughly $4.2 trillion.

The Congressional Budget Office examined single payer designs and found federal subsidies would rise by $1.5 trillion to $3 trillion in 2030 under every option it looked at. Somebody has to send that money to Washington. The preprint attaches no tax schedule, no state maintenance of effort analysis, and no transition budget as best as I can tell.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jayapal has been asked how she pays for this since she first introduced the House bill and has never produced an answer that can satisfy anyone with a calculator. She still hasn’t. She found a model that reports a lower national total and started calling it proof of affordability, the same reflex she showed when she turned a tax the rich pitch into a $6.2 trillion promise that doesn’t withstand scrutiny.

This is what an advocate does, not what a legislator should

Jayapal is not misreading the study. She is reading it exactly the way she wants Seattle to read it. And she likely knows most media outlets, should they cover her propaganda, will print or broadcast her claims uncritically. I won’t do that.

The Squad member took an unreviewed model, written in part by someone who advised the bill’s Senate sponsor, and told the world that science has confirmed her position. She merged two separate policy questions into one death toll. She converted a reduction in total national spending into a claim about what taxpayers can afford. She skipped every caveat the authors printed themselves. It is the same treatment she gave a Seattle Times report on immigration court and federal wage data before this.

ADVERTISEMENT

We can argue the benefits of Medicare for All, especially since they don’t really exist. It’s an easy argument, which is why even Minority Leader Hakeem Jefferies rejects the idea while actively courting socialists and progressives to the so-called “big tent” of his party. But Jayapal isn’t interest in debate. She’s interested in pushing bumper sticker talking points and a misleading bias “study” because she’s too lazy to win the argument on facts alone.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

3 Comments

S
Shawn m 3 months ago

"Confirmed and proves are strong words for a paper that has not even been peer reviewed..."

Kinda like how Woke conquered the land because "we said so."

S
Sean S 3 months ago

Yeah, Obamacare has worked out so spectacularly, can't wait for Jayapalforall

P
Pablo Abo 3 months ago

No surprise PramiLIAR Jayapal misrepresents the conclusions.