Rantz: Seattle Times columnist turns convicted Spokane 3 into folk heroes in stunningly disingenuous piece
Seattle Times columnist Naomi Ishisaka recasts the convicted Spokane 3 as civil rights heroes while ignoring the federal jury that found all three guilty.
UW professor Cliff Mass says a Seattle Times Climate Lab story on Skagit River flooding ignored federal flow data. (Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
(Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
Seattle Times social justice columnist Naomi Ishisaka is recasting the Spokane 3 from convicted federal criminals into civil rights martyrs, and she managed it by skipping the part where a jury weighed the evidence and found them guilty. Her column treats a federal conspiracy verdict as a badge of honor, when the facts of the case tell a different story.
The Spokane 3 are Jac Archer, Justice Forral, and Bajun Mavalwalla II, the trio a federal jury convicted in late May of conspiracy to impede or injure ICE agents after an eight-day trial. Each faces up to six years in prison and a $250,000 fine. Their convictions grew out of a June 2025 protest in which demonstrators blocked an ICE transport bus for hours, slashed its tires, threw paint across the windshield, and tossed gas canisters back at officers, according to prosecutors. Six of the nine people originally charged, including former Spokane City Council President Ben Stuckart, took plea deals rather than gamble in front of a jury.
Ishisaka’s column treats none of that as relevant. Her headline frames the convicted defendants as people who are targeted while many still stand up, language that converts a criminal verdict into a profile in courage.
A verdict the column never wrestles with
The jury that convicted these three sat through weeks of evidence about what happened outside the Spokane facility, and the prosecution kept the focus on conduct rather than slogans.
“It’s about violating the law. And no matter what adjective you use to describe the conduct, you are here to look at the conduct and see whether or not the evidence shows the conduct occurred,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Lisa Cartier-Giroux told the jury during closing arguments, according to the Spokesman-Review.
That matters because it dismantles the central claim Ishisaka is dishonestly selling. The Spokane 3, which only like-minded, far-left activists refer to them as, were not punished for holding signs or chanting. They were convicted because a federal jury concluded they agreed to a plan to physically stop federal officers from doing their jobs.
Hundreds protested. Three were convicted.
Hundreds of people answered Stuckart’s Facebook call to surround the bus that day. The overwhelming majority went home without so much as a citation. If protesting ICE were itself the crime, as the martyr narrative implies, the indictment would have run to hundreds of names rather than nine.
It did not, because the government built its case on specific acts, sabotaging the bus, blocking exits with benches and scooters, and working to keep detainees from leaving. Ishisaka skips that filter entirely, which is consistent with a pattern at her paper, where Seattle media has repeatedly framed activists obstructing ICE as heroes while ignoring what those activists actually did. Stripping away the lawbreaking is the only way the hero story holds together.
The hero narrative, in her own words
Ishisaka has been overly dramatic and explicit about how she views the moment.
“What we are experiencing right now feels like another catalyzing historic moment. The abductions and brutality of rampaging ICE agents, the arrest of journalists, the FBI raid of a reporter’s home, the attack on Rep. Ilhan Omar, the killings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti and so many other outrages have galvanized ordinary people to take extraordinary actions to support their communities and their values,” she wrote in her Seattle Times column.
Those extraordinary actions are the same actions a federal jury just called crimes. A columnist is free to admire people who break the law for a cause she supports. She is not free to pretend the law was never broken, and that is exactly what this column does.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
7 Comments
No wonder my parakeets love the Seattle Times!
this is typical for this 'journalist'
When will Renee Good's and Alex Pretti's killers be tried by a jury of their peers?