Rantz: Weird op-ed says trans bathroom bills are bad because the female author looks like a man
An Idaho op-ed argues bathroom bills threaten women because the author looks like a man. The logic doesn't hold.
Several ballot measures across the country protecting girls' sports passed. (Photo: Jason Rantz/Seattle Red)
(Photo: Jason Rantz/Seattle Red)
The Idaho Legislature is working to do something that most parents, women, and people with functioning common sense consider basic sanity. Two bills currently moving through the Statehouse, HB 607 and HB 752, would restrict bathroom and locker room access in public accommodations based on biological sex.
The goal is simple and defensible: keep biological males out of the private spaces women use every day. Predictably, the activist left is fighting back. But nobody could have predicted the argument the Idaho Statesman decided to publish.
Brace yourself! The argument against gendered-bathroom bills is that a biological woman may look too much like a man.
The op-ed that proves too little
Lora Volkert, a Pride Foundation board member writing in the Statesman, declares herself a “cisgender woman” who has been misgendered before and therefore finds bathroom legislation personally threatening. Her central concern, posed as a rhetorical hammer meant to demolish the entire legislative effort, is this.
“What if someone challenges my right to pee?” she wrote.
That is genuinely the argument. Because she occasionally gets mistaken for a man, Idaho should abandon any effort to protect women’s private spaces from biological males.
Volkert leans on a committee exchange over enforcement mechanics and the testimony of a Boise State student named Rachel Anne Pierce, who claimed she had been repeatedly stopped under a similar existing law covering university facilities. Pierce testified, “I have been stopped several times trying to go to the bathroom at school, sometimes in polite ways and sometimes in rather aggressive ways.”
That is a real concern worth hearing. But it is an argument for crafting smarter enforcement language, not for scrapping the policy entirely.
What this argument actually proves
Nobody serious wants women being interrogated at bathroom doors. If these bills have enforcement gaps, legislators should fix them. Rep. Anne Henderson Haws (D-Boise) raised legitimate procedural questions during committee hearings, and those questions deserve real answers. The conversation about how to implement these protections fairly is worth having.
What is not worth having is the argument that a law protecting women is bad because it might occasionally inconvenience masculine-presenting women. By that standard, no protective legislation could survive. Every law has edge cases. Every enforcement mechanism can be imperfectly applied. The answer to that problem has never been to abandon the protection.
The documented harms driving these bills are real. Voyeurism, harassment, and assault have followed gender-neutral access policies in facilities across the country. Women and girls deserve spaces where their privacy is actually protected, not just symbolically honored. Volkert’s uncomfortable moments at the restroom door are genuinely unfortunate. They do not come close to outweighing that.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
Men don't care if a woman uses the men's restroom (at their own peril). Public men's rooms are pretty disgusting.