ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Thurston County politicians want permission slips before you can sell your home

Thurston County may require homeowners to obtain a government energy score before listing, raising concerns about property rights and housing costs.

Thurston County leaders are considering a rule forcing homeowners to secure a government-approved e...

Thurston County leaders are considering a rule forcing homeowners to secure a government-approved energy score before listing, adding new costs and regulatory hurdles to home sales. (Photo: Stephen Brashear, Getty Images)

(Photo: Stephen Brashear, Getty Images)

Thurston County politicians do not trust you to sell your own home without first asking the government for approval, and it’s an outrageous overreach.

County leaders are weighing a proposal that would require homeowners in unincorporated Thurston County to obtain a government-approved Home Energy Score before they can even list their property for sale. According to The Olympian, sellers would be required to pay between $150 and $300 for an assessment conducted by a certified assessor. The home would receive a score from one to ten based on energy efficiency, along with an estimate of annual energy costs. That information would then have to be disclosed to buyers. Olympia, Lacey, and Tumwater are already considering similar measures.

This proposal stems from the Thurston Climate Mitigation Plan, adopted after the county declared a climate emergency in 2021. And while this is being sold as transparency, it is actually about control and manipulation.

Government gatekeepers in the housing market

Buyers already have tools to evaluate a home’s efficiency. They can order inspections, review utility bills, ask about insulation, windows, furnaces, and water heaters. They can negotiate upgrades or price reductions. The market already prices in efficiency. What this ordinance does is insert the county as a gatekeeper before a private transaction can even begin.

Every seller would have to pay a fee and wait for an assessment before entering the market. In a region already struggling with housing shortages and affordability challenges, the county’s solution is to add cost, delay, and bureaucracy.

Dawn Baker of the Thurston County Realtors Association raised measured concerns. She said the association supports energy efficiency and informed consumers but does not support implementing a new requirement at the time of listing without fully understanding the impacts. She is correct to sound the alarm. This is not a minor disclosure tweak.

ADVERTISEMENT

From disclosure to de facto mandate

County officials have acknowledged that the program could lead to hundreds of retrofits each year. That is not an unintended consequence. It is the logical outcome. Today the score is informational, but tomorrow it becomes leverage.

If your home receives a three out of ten and buyers begin demanding steep discounts, the political narrative writes itself. Officials will point to the data and claim too many homes are inefficient. They will argue that the climate emergency requires stronger action, and the next step will be incentives tied to upgrades, then penalties for noncompliance, and then mandates dressed up as public good.

This is how regulatory creep works. Declare an emergency, adopt a sweeping mitigation plan, embed requirements into ordinary transactions (while normalizing them), and then expand them.

What happened to property rights?

Property rights in Washington are already strained by rising taxes, zoning dictates, and endless regulatory layers. Now homeowners may need a government-issued efficiency grade simply to put their house on the market. If buyers value energy efficiency, they will reward it. If sellers want to invest in upgrades, they already can. That is how markets already function.

ADVERTISEMENT

Forcing every homeowner to pay for a government score before listing is not consumer empowerment. It is a presumption that citizens cannot be trusted to transact freely without supervision from the Democrats in charge. And when the government starts grading your home before you can sell it, that is not a small administrative tweak. It is a statement about who they believe is in charge.

And once you accept that premise, do not be surprised when the next requirement goes further.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

12 Comments

T
T B 9 months ago

I’m getting tired of all this nonsense fee stuff, a big NO !

R
Robert Crachett 9 months ago

This policy is absolutely absurd! Home energy audits are available through your utility! The fact that Thurston is now getting involved in this market means some politicians brother-in-law needs a job!
This smells an awful lot like Bobby, which is another reason why Washington needs a complete audit!

G
g jones 9 months ago

Government overreach is a BAD THING. Who owns the property being sold?

In my area, ALL sellers and buyers hire their own inspectors. Whatever the outcome of the inspections is then used as a basis for price negotiation.

Homeowners in WA State are allowed to sell their homes "as is" unless a new law has been passed that homeowners cannot sell their homes "as is." The home seller does fill out a mandatory disclosure form that describes the home's condition but can still sell the home "as is."