ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Cantwell claims noncitizen voter fraud is impossible in Washington — the Medina-Medina murder case shows not-so-sound logic

Sen. Maria Cantwell told the Senate that penalties make noncitizen voter fraud impossible in Washington. That same week, federal authorities charged Jose Medina-Medina — caught and released twice — with the murder of Sheridan Gorman. Jason Rantz explains why Cantwell's logic doesn't survive reality.

Maria Cantwell...

Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.) spoke on the Senate floor about noncitizen voter fraud and Washington state election integrity. (Getty Images)

(Getty Images)

Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.) took to the Senate floor on Tuesday to explain why non-citizen voter fraud is basically impossible in Washington state. The reason, she said, is that the penalties are too steep. Nobody who is afraid to go grocery shopping would risk five years in prison or a $10,000 fine just to sign a ballot, she claimed.

“No, they’re not doing that,” Cantwell told her colleagues, “because this system is checked. It’s validated. It’s verified.”

Case closed. Trust the system!

Except that same week, federal authorities charged Jose Medina-Medina, a Venezuelan national who entered this country illegally in May 2023 under the Biden administration’s catch-and-release program, with the first-degree murder of 18-year-old Sheridan Gorman. Gorman was a freshman at Loyola University Chicago, walking with friends near the Rogers Park lakefront hoping to catch a glimpse of the Northern Lights, when a masked gunman emerged from the shadows and shot her in the back, according to federal officials. She was somebody’s daughter, somebody’s future, and now she’s a case number courtesy of the Radical Left’s open-border policies.

Crossing the U.S. border illegally is a federal crime with serious consequences. Medina-Medina knew that before he did it.

Cantwell’s penalty-deterrent argument ignores how crime actually works

Cantwell’s penalty-deterrent argument doesn’t make much sense. People commit murder despite facing life sentences. People drink and drive despite felony charges. People enter this country illegally despite federal deportation consequences. The existence of a penalty has never, in the entire history of civilization, guaranteed that a crime won’t happen. It means we punish the ones we catch (unless you’re a Democrats who has actively released criminals who commit crimes, which has been policy in left-wing cities like Seattle for years).

ADVERTISEMENT

And that is the part Cantwell doesn’t want to discuss.

Medina-Medina was apprehended by U.S. Border Patrol in May 2023. The system caught him, then released him into the country. Chicago police arrested him again in June 2023 for shoplifting at a State Street Macy’s. The system caught him again, then released him again. He missed his court date. A warrant sat untouched.

The system caught Medina-Medina twice and let him walk both times. This is the system Maria Cantwell is asking Washington voters to trust with the integrity of their elections.

Medina-Medina was caught twice — and released twice — before the murder

Cantwell’s floor speech included a line that ought to haunt every voter paying attention to the noncitizen voting debate.

“We have very, very, very, very, very, very little fraud, and when we do, we catch it,” she said.

The whole argument balances on that “when we do.” She is not claiming fraud never happens. She is claiming the system catches it when it does. But the only fraud we catch is the fraud the system is equipped and motivated to detect. Washington state ballot declarations are not cross-checked in real time against federal immigration databases. Voter rolls are audited after votes are cast and counted, not before. The question was never whether the current election integrity system catches every fraudulent vote. It doesn’t. The question is how many fraudulent votes it misses, and by design, we cannot know. We don’t know what we don’t know.

ADVERTISEMENT

That is the entire problem Cantwell is waving away with six “verys.” A system that catches voter fraud “when we do” is not a failsafe. It is a guess.

Cantwell’s real argument: any election integrity measure is voter suppression

Cantwell closed her remarks by revealing what this debate is really about for Democrats: “It is about disenfranchising millions of people and making it very hard for them to vote.”

Think about that silly framing. Non-citizens are not “millions of people” voting in Washington elections. Citizens are. By conflating the two, Cantwell transforms any election integrity measure into an attack on legitimate voters. It is a deliberate rhetorical trick and she knows it.

ADVERTISEMENT

The SAVE Act — which Cantwell and other Democrats have framed as voter suppression — merely requires proof of citizenship to register.

Sheridan Gorman’s mother, Jessica, stood at a vigil after her daughter was killed and said what every parent in that situation deserves to say. “I really hate saying this, but Chicago, we trusted you with our hearts and you betrayed us,” Jessica Gorman said.

Washington voters deserve the same honesty that family demanded of Chicago. The system Maria Cantwell is defending doesn’t verify. It attests. It hopes. It catches some of what it is lucky enough to find and doesn’t seem eager to charge. That is not election security. That is a prayer.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

8 Comments

C
Cosmo Pendragon 8 months ago

Voting is one of the most important responsibilities of the citizens of this country. Ensuring that elections are fair and legitimate is one of the most important responsibilities of government. The people have the right to know - not think, but know, elections are legitimate. The government has an obligation to prove that to the people every voting cycle. If the people cannot trust the election process, they should not trust the government.

75% of the people across ethnicities and ideologies support voter ID. Why do elected democrats fear legitimate elections so?

D
Dan Mak 8 months ago

I laugh at the usual TV news report every voting season showing the “integrity” of the ballot processing. “See, we’re showing you the ballots and these processing machines - all good here!” OK! The question never asked in these reports, chain of custody? How many came back from the same address? Signatures - verification process? Ballots received count vs number of registered voters? A bit late in that chain of custody/verification at the point of being fed into a machine. Once removed from the envelope it’s all over.

J
JOHN SPENCER 8 months ago

Other than a life of incarceration, or a death sentence the penalty's under Democrat leadership do not stop crime. It may keep an honest person honest for a bit longer, but sooner or later he will commit the crime. Why not, most people get away with it with a slap on the wrist! Being easy on crime, non-support of law enforcement, lousy judges in some cases and Democrats like Cantwell and Murray and many others just encourage crime. What a better way to destroy this country, than when you create the scenario for us to destroy ourselves. Do the lies you tell make you proud of yourself?