ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: UW’s Aria Fani mass-emails students calling Iran nuclear threat ‘always BS’ and blaming Israel for the war

Jason Rantz reports UW professor Aria Fani mass-emailed students dismissing Iran's nuclear threat as 'always BS' and blaming Israel for the war.

UW professor Aria Fani shown in headshot inset over a crowd of anti-war protesters holding "No New ...

Demonstrators with the Party for Socialism and Liberation rally against U.S. military action in the Middle East. Inset: UW professor Aria Fani, stripped of his directorship at the university's Middle East Center after sending pro-Iran regime analysis to students through the official JSIS listserv. (Photo: Mario Tama/Getty Images; Fani photo: UW)

(Photo: Mario Tama/Getty Images; Fani photo: UW)

Weeks after The Jason Rantz Show exposed University of Washington professor Aria Fani’s indefensible claim that the Iranian regime poses no threat to the United States or Israel, he has returned for a second act. This time, Fani fired off a mass email to UW listservs, distributing more of the same regime-friendly revisionism to a captive audience of students and faculty.

The email obtained by The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM, sent March 18 via the UW Mec-1 listserv and titled “More Notes on Iran War,” opens with something close to a warning: “Given that this war shows no signs of stopping, you will continue to hear from me.”

He is correct that the war continues. He is not correct about most of what follows.

Fani claims Iran’s nuclear program was never a real threat — the IAEA record says otherwise

The most aggressive claim in Fani’s email is his insistence that Iran’s nuclear program was never a real threat. He called the entire premise fabricated.

“That the Islamic Republic was either pursuing a nuclear bomb or that they were perpetually two weeks away from a bomb (Iranians do procrastinate after all) was always BS,” Fani argued in the email.

The International Atomic Energy Agency, United Nations Security Council resolutions, years of multilateral sanctions, and a global diplomatic effort that produced the 2015 Iran nuclear deal all suggest otherwise. Nations do not construct elaborate international frameworks in response to fabricated dangers. Iran’s enrichment activities were documented, debated, and condemned by world bodies with far more credibility than a fringe UW Middle East studies professor.

ADVERTISEMENT

Fani also took aim at the broader national security community, accusing it of coordinated deception.

“A cadre of voices ranging from so-called pundits to national security experts to politicians, most of whom had never set foot in Iran, lied to the world about Iran’s threat to the US with discipline and conviction for years,” he added in the email.

Blaming the entire national security establishment for manufacturing Iran’s threat is a bold posture for someone who told KOMO News, without evidence, that the Iranian regime “does not pose a threat to the United States, does not pose a threat to Israel.” Fani is not offering a corrective to deception. He is deepening it.

Fani reframes Israel as the aggressor against Iranian civilians, not the Islamic Republic

Fani also used the email to argue that the current conflict isn’t really against the Islamic Republic at all. He reframed Israel as the true aggressor targeting ordinary Iranians rather than a regime that has bankrolled terrorism across the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

“That the current war is against the Islamic Republic is not supported by facts on the ground,” Fani noted in the email.

He went further: “Israeli actions tell us that they seek the destruction of the state, not just its ruling class.”

That framing is less analysis than it is a talking point. The Islamic Republic is not an incidental feature of the Iranian state — it is the state. It is the state that has funded Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Houthi movement, armed proxy militias across multiple countries, and orchestrated attacks targeting American personnel throughout the region. The argument that striking the regime’s military apparatus constitutes an assault on Iranian culture and ecology is the kind of logic that survives only inside a university listserv.

Fani inverts the Islamic terrorism label, pointing it at the US and Israel instead

Fani then turned the terrorism framing entirely on its head, challenging the very premise of labeling Iranian behavior as extremism.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We label Iran’s behavior and actions in the region as ‘Islamic terrorism’ without any thought,” he wrote in the email.

His implied alternative was that the United States and Israel are the real religious extremists, pointing to evangelical prayer in the Oval Office, American officials allegedly framing the conflict in crusade language, and what he characterized as messianic messaging within the U.S. military.

UW stays silent while Fani uses official listservs as a regime propaganda platform

As I previously reported, Fani compared the U.S. strikes on Iran to Hitler’s 1939 invasion of Poland and told The Seattle Times that the conflict made George W. Bush look like “the Nobel laureate for peace.” KOMO, KING 5, and The Seattle Times all amplified his framing without meaningful pushback. Now he is routing the same arguments directly to students on university listservs.

ADVERTISEMENT

The UW Jewish Alumni account on X identified the accountability gap after Fani’s earlier KOMO appearance drew attention, noting that “an expert who is paid to educate others ought to be able to explain the arguments when it counts. Otherwise, why have a MEC at all?”

That is exactly the question UW has refused to engage. Fani is using institutional university infrastructure to mass-distribute a political document dressed up as scholarship, and the university administration has said nothing.

What UW is permitting is not an expression of academic freedom. Academic freedom protects the right to hold and publish heterodox views. It does not obligate a university to stay silent while a department head uses official listservs to push regime-friendly propaganda to students who enrolled to be educated, not recruited.

Fani told his readers he will keep going. The University of Washington should decide, before the next email arrives, whether that is a policy it is willing to own.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 8 months ago

Because when I think insightful Middle East policy, I think professors of literature, said no one ever.