‘Blue Slip’ Showdown: President Trump weighs in as Sen. Murray moves to block Serrano as US Attorney
Senator Patty Murray is invoking the Senate’s “blue slip” rule to block Pete Serrano’s confirmation as U.S. Attorney for Eastern Washington, squaring off against Trump.
President Donald Trump talks with reporters as he meets with members of the Juventus soccer club in the Oval Office of the White House, Wednesday, June 18, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS
(AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
Washington Senator Patty Murray is now deploying the Senate’s archaic “blue slip” tradition in an effort to block President Trump’s nominee, Pete Serrano, from being confirmed as U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Washington. The move has prompted fierce criticism from conservatives, particularly given Murray’s past rhetoric about defending democracy while denying a president the right to make his appointments.
Serrano currently serves as interim U.S. Attorney after being sworn in August 2025, and by law can only hold the post for 120 days pending Senate confirmation. Murray has publicly vowed to “use every legislative tool” to block his confirmation.
In her statement, Murray criticized Serrano’s political and legal record: “Pete Serrano has tried to rewrite the history of the violent January 6th insurrection, thinks the Supreme Court overturning Roe … was ‘the right decision,’ and has fought in court to unleash dangerous assault weapons on our streets,” she said. “His extreme right-wing views are far out of step with the people of Washington state, and I will be using every legislative tool I have to block his confirmation.”
Murray’s office has signaled that she could either simply decline to return the blue slip for Serrano or return it with a negative response — either action would effectively veto his nomination under Senate tradition.
Institutional abuse of power
The blue slip practice, dating back over a century, gives home state senators de facto veto power over federal judicial or U.S. attorney nominations in their states. The Senate Judiciary Committee sends a colored form — the “blue slip” — to each senator in the relevant state; if a senator refuses to return it (or returns it with a negative opinion), the Judiciary Committee traditionally will not advance the nomination.
President Trump has railed against the blue slip, calling the rule “stupid” and “outdated,” and accusing Democratic senators of weaponizing it to thwart his judicial and U.S. Attorney picks. He contends the tradition strips him of his constitutional authority to appoint.
Still, Republican Senate leaders have largely resisted scrapping the rule, arguing it offers home state oversight and may protect GOP interests when Democrats hold the White House. Senate Judiciary Chair Chuck Grassley has defended the tradition, saying a nominee without blue slip support lacks the votes to advance.
Protecting democracy? Hardly
Murray has frequently framed her Senate career in terms of defending democratic institutions and safeguarding checks and balances. Yet by invoking the blue slip to block a President Trump appointee — in direct conflict with the president’s constitutional appointment power — she appears to be wielding obstruction as a political weapon rather than a principle.
From Murray’s perspective, Serrano’s views are extreme enough to justify blocking. But from a conservative viewpoint, her stance is hypocritical: how can one claim to oppose authoritarian overreach while denying a duly elected president his prerogatives? Murray is, effectively, claiming to be a gatekeeper of democracy only when it serves her partisan preferences.
What’s next?
If Murray withholds or submits a negative blue slip when Serrano is officially nominated, the Judiciary Committee is likely to refuse to advance the nomination — effectively ending his confirmation path. Serrano has hinted he will “let the process play out.” But without Senate support, he may be forced to step down when his interim term ends.
Meanwhile, Trump continues to pressure Senate Republicans to ditch the blue slip entirely. Whether Murray succeeds or not, her attempt highlights the tension between senatorial prerogative and presidential appointment power — and the risk of constitutional conflict when norms are twisted into political barricades.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
1 Comments
Pete Serrano received almost 1.7 million votes to Nick Brown’s almost 2.1 million votes. Take the “crazy voters” out of the equation (King, Pierce, and Snohomish Counties) and Serrano wins by a mile. Patty Murray is so far out of step and over her head, she is an embarrassment to the State. It’s time for Patty to lace up her tenny runners and resign to her enclave on Whidbey Island. Trump should force the elimination of the “blue slip”.