ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

Robert Sutherland reverses Idaho exit, wants 39th District seat back after Eslick’s retirement

Former Rep. Robert Sutherland reversed his Idaho exit. Eslick's retirement sparked Republican calls urging Sutherland to reclaim his 39th District seat.

Former 39th District Rep. Robert Sutherland speaks at a microphone during a Washington state House ...

Former 39th District Rep. Robert Sutherland at the Washington state legislature. He made headlines announcing a move to North Idaho over the state's rising tax burden, then reversed course after Rep. Carolyn Eslick announced her retirement. (Office of Rep. Sutherland)

(Office of Rep. Sutherland)

Former 39th District Rep. Robert Sutherland made headlines when he posted on Facebook that he was done with Washington, had bought a house in Idaho and was getting out. Now comes the plot twist. He’s staying, and he wants his old seat back.

Sutherland says his retirement move was never as final as it looked from the outside. He and his wife bought a home in North Idaho last summer after falling for the area during a road trip. His wife still works in Seattle. They never fully relocated. The Idaho property was a retirement plan with a loose two-year timeline, not a completed departure.

“I certainly hope I didn’t lead anyone to believe that we’ve already moved to Idaho,” Sutherland said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “If I did, I did not mean that. We still live here in Washington. My wife still works in Seattle, and our plan was to take the next year or two and slowly move over there, take our time, you know, because buying and selling homes and moving is a pain. It’s a very stressful ordeal.”

As Seattle Red reported, Sutherland’s original announcement lit up conservative social media, with his frustrations over taxes and property rights resonating widely across the state.

An open seat changes everything

The calculus shifted almost immediately after his interview on this program.

Republican 39th District Rep. Carolyn Eslick announced she would not seek re-election and immediately endorsed former Lake Stevens Councilman Steve Ewing. State Rep. Sam Low and Sen. Keith Wagner added their backing for Ewing. Before long, Sutherland’s phone was ringing with senior Washington Republicans urging him to get in the race.

ADVERTISEMENT

“As soon as after you and I talked on the radio, Eslick announced her retirement, and immediately after that, I started getting calls from high-level Republican members within the Republican Party in Washington State, informing me of that and encouraging me to run for the open seat,” Sutherland told Rantz. “I’ve been elected twice in that position. I was very popular in the 39th. It was through a bunch of backdoor deals, changing district lines and the typical political bull crap, excuse me, that goes on, that they were able to get me unelected a couple years ago.”

MyNorthwest covered Sutherland’s last contested primary as redistricting reshuffled the district and set up the race that eventually pushed him out.

Sutherland previously held Position 1 in the 39th District before losing to Snohomish County Councilmember Sam Low in the 2022 general election following redistricting. The seat Eslick is vacating — Position 2 — would be an open seat, not a rematch.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘We’re being forced out’: Sutherland on Washington’s tax burden

Sutherland pushed back hard on any suggestion that running again contradicts his stated reasons for wanting to leave. The Idaho plan, he argued, was never about hating Washington. It was math. Washington’s accelerating tax-driven exodus has made exactly the same calculation for thousands of other families.

“It’s not that I don’t want to stay in Washington,” he argued. “Our property taxes keep going up, our gas taxes, sales tax, our auto insurance. We will save $20,000 a year moving to Idaho. It was an economic decision. We don’t want to move. But the fact that the Democrats are running this state into the ground and taking more and more of our property in the form of our taxes, that made the decision that we’re not sure we can sustain ourselves here in Washington if we stayed.”

ADVERTISEMENT

His reasons for running also came down to family.

“I have four kids. We raised four kids here in Washington. Two of them are here on the west side, two are over in the Spokane area,” Sutherland added. “I got into this 17 years ago for one reason, their future. I’ve been fighting this for 17 years, and I do it because my kids live here and their future is being stolen from them by the Democrat majority in Olympia. That’s why I plan to do this one more time.”

One more term, then done

If he wins, Sutherland says he would push to eliminate the income and capital gains taxes and revisit legislation he introduced during his previous tenure to zero out the state-level property tax on homes. He was also upfront about what this campaign would be: his last.

“I will not seek re-election after this term. If I’m reelected this time in two years, I will not seek re-election. That will be three terms,” Sutherland noted. “I’m a scientist. I’m not a career politician. I don’t want to spend the remaining years of my life as a politician in any state. So one more term, two more years, I’ll fight the fight again.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

0 Comments