ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

Biden-era FTC lawsuit could unravel what makes Costco worth the membership fee

A Biden-era FTC lawsuit against Southern Glazer's under the Robinson-Patman Act could threaten Costco's bulk-buying model and raise your membership cost.

Costco employee in red vest checks member cards at warehouse entrance with digital scanner...

A Costco employee scans membership cards at the warehouse door. A Biden-era FTC lawsuit targeting the distributor behind Costco's bulk-pricing deals could make that annual membership harder to justify. (Photo: Lindsey Nicholson/UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images)

(Photo: Lindsey Nicholson/UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images)

A Biden-era Federal Trade Commission (FTC) lawsuit that has yet to identify a single victim is still working its way through federal court, and if it succeeds, it could unravel the business model that makes Issaquah-based Costco worth the annual membership fee.

The FTC under Biden sued Southern Glazer’s Wine and Spirits, the country’s largest alcohol distributor, under the Robinson-Patman Act, a 1936 anti-price-discrimination law that has been largely dormant for four decades. The FTC’s theory is that Southern Glazer’s broke the law by offering bulk-purchase discounts to large retailers like Costco, a practice the agency argued harms smaller competitors who can’t buy in the same volumes.

A new op-ed in National Review explained the free market case against the enforcement push: “The free market works best for all businesses, large and small, when suppliers and retailers are free to negotiate deals that will result in the most attractive pricing for consumers.”

Costco’s entire value proposition runs on bulk buying. Suppliers give it lower per-unit prices because its orders are massive, predictable, and cheap to fulfill. Costco passes those savings on to members. That’s not a scam. That’s just how it works. If the government can classify that as illegal price discrimination, the whole model gets expensive, and membership fees, already a cornerstone of Costco’s revenue, become harder to justify.

The FTC still can’t name a single victim

Southern Glazer’s has not exactly been sitting quietly.

The company told regulators that “after years of investigation, the FTC still cannot identify a single unlawful transaction,” and a March 17 discovery filing backed that up in embarrassing fashion. When asked directly whether the agency could point to a specific customer it claims was harmed, an FTC witness told the court: “The FTC cannot identify any diverted customer.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Years of investigation, and no victim. That would get most legal theories laughed out of a room.

The economics of the case are just as shaky. Suppliers charge less per unit to a buyer who orders a truckload at once versus a buyer who needs small batches delivered across a metro area. The logistics alone justify the price difference, and the Robinson-Patman Act has always included a cost-justification defense for exactly that reason. Congress put it in the statute.

FTC chair Andrew Ferguson already dropped a similar case

Current FTC chair Andrew Ferguson has already shown he’s not interested in weaponizing Depression-era law against consumer savings. He dropped a similar Biden-era case against PepsiCo, which alleged that Pepsi violated Robinson-Patman by giving volume discounts to Walmart and big-box retailers, according to the National Review. With that precedent in place, the Southern Glazer’s case may not survive long under Ferguson’s watch either.

ADVERTISEMENT

That said, the threat isn’t limited to federal enforcement. Earlier this year the Ninth Circuit upheld a verdict against an eye-drop manufacturer for giving favorable pricing and rebates to Costco and Sam’s Club over smaller competitors. Private plaintiffs are paying attention, and with Robinson-Patman back in the news, more suits are possible.

Costco already has enough legal trouble on its plate in Washington, where a federal class action accuses it of double-billing members on tariff costs. Piling antitrust exposure onto a company headquartered right outside Seattle, one that employs thousands of Washingtonians and saves its members real money, is not a policy outcome anyone around here should want.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments