ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

Bret Weinstein: Why does Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson believe socialism can succeed? Her father

If you want to know why Katie Wilson thinks they way she does, you should just turn to her father.

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson speaks during the 2025 campaign, which later drew a formal penalty after...

Seattle is still trying to recover $13.1 million it overpaid to about 900 police officers in June. (Photo: Frank Lenzi/KIRO Newsradio)

(Photo: Frank Lenzi/KIRO Newsradio)

Katie Wilson grew up in a household shaped by a specific theory of human nature. Her father, David Sloan Wilson, spent his career trying to rehabilitate group selection, one of evolutionary biology’s most controversial dead ends. The idea never recovered its scientific credibility. But the worldview it generates appears to be running Seattle.

Bret Weinstein, himself an evolutionary biologist and host of the DarkHorse Podcast, connected the dots on his podcast. He walked through how group selection works as a concept.

“If you take two groups of people that are similar but for one characteristic,” Weinstein said on the DarkHorse Podcast, “one of the groups is altruistic within the group with the other members… and you put them in competition. The group that is altruistic, in which everybody collaborates and doesn’t think about their own take, that group out competes the fractious group every time.”

The problem is what you conclude from that.

Where the theory falls apart

The leap that David Sloan Wilson made was that nature should therefore produce altruism at scale; that groups rewarding cooperation should dominate, according to Weinstein.

Biologists dismantled that claim in the mid-to-late 20th century with a simple observation. The most advantaged individual inside a group of altruists is the one who cheats. The person who takes what cooperation produces but doesn’t contribute to it wins.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Every group of altruists is torn apart by basically cheaters,” Weinstein noted.

Weinstein connected it directly to policy: “It is exactly the misunderstanding of socialists who expect this ‘we all pull together and come out ahead’ ideology to work and it doesn’t, because in the end the mistake is always the same. Socialism and communism punish those who are productive and reward those who are lazy.”

“It is fascinating that his daughter has become the mayor of Seattle, and seems to have picked up the same misunderstanding, which is now being manifest in policy,” he added.

Seattle already ran this experiment

Wilson’s policy instincts come from a specific intellectual error her father spent a career promoting. Collective sacrifice produces collective good. The city coordinates, everyone chips in, the outcome is better for all. Except that’s not how systems with cheaters in them work, and cities have plenty of cheaters.

ADVERTISEMENT

Seattle has been running this experiment for years, long before Wilson arrived.

Productive residents pay and follow the rules while watching their neighborhoods degrade. People living on the street camp in parks, skip court dates, and cycle through diversion programs without consequences. The model predicts exactly this outcome. Wilson’s father’s model predicts the opposite.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

2 Comments

C
Clockwork Wyrm 6 months ago

Socialists love to label unpaid, involuntary labor as fluffy things like "collective sacrifice." When I was growing up we had a different word for it: slavery.

S
Shawn m 6 months ago

Seems obvious, but somebody actually spent their career ignoring the freeloaders and scammers in society? That's stunning, absolutely stunning.