Ninth Circuit restores sanity, blocks lower court on biological men in women’s prisons in Oregon
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has stepped into block a lower court ruling mandating Oregon to not rely on men's prisons to hold trans women.
(Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
(Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
A court order that forced Oregon corrections officials to ensure they aren’t relying on men’s prisons to detain incarcerated transgender women has been put on ice, according to the Oregon Capital Chronicle. In September, two incarcerated trans women (biological men) filed a class-action lawsuit against the state’s Department of Corrections after they alleged they faced sexual harassment and violence when they were held with other men.
They won a preliminary injunction in April but now the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has stepped in to temporarily block the injection granted by U.S. Magistrate Judge Mark D. Clarke.
“We appreciate the Ninth Circuit’s swift action in granting an administrative stay while it considers our motion and look forward to continuing with the appeal,” said Jenny Hansson, a spokesperson for the Oregon Department of Justice in a statement.
Even Oregon has reservations about biological men in women’s prisons
Upon granting the initial injunction, Judge Clark admonished the Department of Corrections for data showing over 90% of inmates that identify as trans women being held in male prisons. The state justified this decision by claiming not everyone was ready to come out or even wanted to be placed in a women’s prison.
Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield called Clarke’s decision “vague and overbroad” and also raised privacy concerns as it would have required the state to hand over data pertaining to transgender inmates’ health, disciplinary records and grievances, “without their consent.”
State officials warn about security risks
Even a blue state like Oregon also felt compelled to raise some very obvious safety concerns about housing biological men in a women’s prison. State attorneys highlighted instances where trans women posed a security risk to other incarcerated women.
“The court issued a mandatory preliminary injunction under the Eighth Amendment that micromanages the state’s administration of its prison system for transgender women (adults in custody) under terms both vague and overbroad,” Oregon attorneys wrote in an appeal filing. “The court also provisionally certified a class of all transgender women in ODOC custody and then ordered the disclosure of their personal information otherwise protected by Oregon law — including their names and gender identities — without their consent to the individual named plaintiffs’ counsel.”
The Ninth Circuit’s ruling puts a halt on Clark’s injunction until it makes its ruling. Oral arguments are slated to begin on August 27 in Pasadena, California.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.





Comments
0 Comments