Washington forces crab boat captains to fund their own 24/7 government surveillance, and now three of them are suing
Washington tracks commercial crab boats 24/7, makes captains pay for the surveillance, and shares the data with police without a warrant. Now they are suing.
Three Washington crab boat captains are suing the state Department of Fish and Wildlife over a program that tracks their vessels around the clock. (Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images)
(Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images)
Washington state is tracking commercial crab boats around the clock, including on trips that have nothing to do with crabbing, and it is making the boat owners pay for the privilege of being watched. A new lawsuit asks a state judge to shut the program down.
The New Civil Liberties Alliance (NCLA) is representing three crabbers in a challenge to the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife’s Electronic Monitoring Program. The group asked a state Superior Court to grant summary judgment and set the program aside, arguing the department has turned a fishing license into a permanent tracking device.
The plaintiffs are not accused of anything. That is the entire point of the case.
What the state is tracking
Boat captains Sarah Franey, Brent Young and Mark Young hold commercial Dungeness crab licenses. According to NCLA, they also use their boats the way anyone would, for fishing in other waters, for transportation and for sightseeing. The monitoring program follows every voyage regardless of purpose whenever they have crab pots in the water, which covers the nine month season.
The captains buy the monitoring hardware and maintain it themselves. NCLA argues the program has not made the state any better at tracking crab populations or protecting wildlife than it already was.
The department can then hand that location data to law enforcement and other government agencies without a warrant and without any suspicion that a crime occurred.
The constitutional claims
NCLA argues the forced GPS reporting violates the Fourth Amendment and its counterpart in the Washington Constitution, both of which bar unreasonable and warrantless searches. The group also says the state takes property without paying for it by commandeering space on private vessels and seizing the route data those vessels generate. It further argues the Washington Wildlife Code never gave the department authority to threaten criminal penalties over a program NCLA calls arbitrary and capricious.
John Vecchione, the group’s senior litigation counsel, is lead attorney on the case.
“The crabbers of Washington State do not give up their rights against unlawful search and seizure merely because they decide on the lawful pursuit of harvesting crabs,” Vecchione said in a statement.
Why this fight matters beyond crab pots
NCLA is not a fringe outfit. Vecchione was counsel of record in Relentless, Inc. v. Department of Commerce, the companion case to Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, in which the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Chevron deference in 2024.
Washington has spent the past year arguing with itself over exactly this kind of data. Police departments across western Washington canceled contracts with Flock Safety after Washington Democrats raised the possibility that plate reader data might reach federal immigration agents, and the state’s Driver Privacy Act forced agencies to switch off license plate readers. Warrantless tracking was intolerable when police were doing it to drivers. Those same lawmakers have had nothing to say about a wildlife agency doing it to fishermen.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
2 Comments
The short answer is No!
what amazing leadership washington has. can't use cameras to arrest criminals but we're gonna watch fishermen...wow, Does anyone running WA have a brain?