‘This would include fellow councilmembers’: lawsuit warns Amendment 53 hands Pierce County a way to erase any elected office it dislikes
Three Pierce County voters, including a former Democrat state auditor, sued to void Charter Amendment 53 and stop the early removal of Sheriff Keith Swank.
Three Pierce County voters filed suit in Thurston County Superior Court seeking to void Charter Amendment 53 and keep it off the November ballot. (Pierce County Sheriff's Office/X)
(Pierce County Sheriff's Office/X)
Three Pierce County voters have asked a judge to void Charter Amendment 53 and bar the county from putting it on the November ballot, arguing Pierce County has no authority to abolish the elected office of sheriff or to end the term voters handed Keith Swank in 2024.
The petition was filed August 21 in Thurston County Superior Court as Sonntag v. Pierce County. The petitioners are former Washington State Auditor Brian Sonntag, a Democrat who previously served as Pierce County clerk and auditor; Jeff Joseph, a Republican precinct committeeperson; and Hollie Rogge, an immediate past Charter Review Commissioner who voted against the measure in June. They are represented by Joan K. Mell of III Branches Law in Fircrest. A hearing is currently set for September 4, though the date could move.
Amendment 53 would strip the sheriff of elective status effective January 1, 2027, terminate the current term, and let Executive Ryan Mello appoint a replacement subject to council confirmation. Swank was elected to serve until January 1, 2029, and he has spent months running a full campaign against the measure. The lawsuit is the first attempt in state history to test whether a charter county can do this at all.
The constitutional argument nobody has tested
The petition contends the sheriff is a constitutional office under Article 11 of the Washington Constitution and that state law leaves no room for appointment.
RCW 36.16.030 requires that a county sheriff be elected in every county, and the statute carves out exceptions for other offices without carving one out for the sheriff. Petitioners point to the state Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Snaza v. State, which recognized the sheriff as a constitutional officer whose core functions cannot be handed to someone the voters did not choose.
King County is currently the only Washington county with an appointed sheriff, and the petition notes that arrangement has never been challenged in court. It also points out that when King County switched back to appointment in 2020, the sitting elected sheriff was allowed to finish her term. Amendment 53 contains no such transition language.
A recall without any of the safeguards
Rogge’s declaration takes aim at what the amendment skips. Washington law requires a recall charge to allege malfeasance, misfeasance, or a violation of the oath of office, backed by a verified factual statement and a signature drive equal to 25 percent of votes cast in the last election for that office.
“Recall provides due process, including judicial review, and established checks and balances for both the electorate and the officeholder,” Rogge wrote in her declaration. “Amendment 53 instead proposes to remove the Sheriff automatically, without cause, justification, or judicial review.”
She warned the precedent would not stop at the sheriff’s office.
“If an elected officer may be removed by Charter Amendment, the Council would have the power to recommend Pierce County voters amend Pierce County Charter to eliminate any office, and its office holder whose speech does not align with majority rule without a recall process,” Rogge stated. “This would include fellow councilmembers.”
Swank has not been recalled and has not been charged with any crime. He has, however, been at open war with county leadership and with Democrats in Olympia, including over Senate Bill 5974, which he attacked in the debut episode of his new podcast. He is also facing a state training commission complaint over his legislative testimony.
The Democrat in the room
Sonntag brings a résumé that complicates the standard partisan reading of this fight. He was elected Pierce County clerk in 1978, testified against converting that office to an appointive position when the county went to home rule, later served as county auditor, and held the state auditor’s office from 1992 to 2012.
“Appointment is not an appropriate substitute for elective office,” Sonntag wrote. “There are distinct mind sets and duties of loyalty. As an elected officer you serve the people and are accountable to them directly.”
He also argued the commission used the wrong tool for the job.
“Charter review and amendment are processes for considering prospective changes to the structure of county government, not alternative procedures for removing a particular elected officer before the expiration of the term the voters affirmed,” Sonntag declared.
Joseph, who voted for Swank, framed his objection around what the office is supposed to be.
“I want Pierce County Sheriff to be independent from all other County offices,” he wrote. “I value such independence because I want a Sheriff whose priority is public safety, not adhering to the political whims or oversight of the Executive or any other policy makers.”
What the commission said out loud
The petition leans heavily on the commission’s own record. Commissioner Jake Hunter’s original proposal was pitched as a professional qualifications measure. Commissioner Justin Leighton later moved to make it effective before Swank’s term ended, and the commission rejected a delay to the end of that term by a single vote, 11 to 10. The final measure passed 12 to 9.
During deliberations, Commissioner Devin Rydel Kelly said he did not trust that leaving the office in place for two more years would produce effective governance, citing what he described as bad faith behavior by the current sheriff. Commissioner Billy Jo Hetherington worried aloud about a lame duck sheriff serving two full years and compared the choice to ripping off a bandage.
The petition uses that record to advance its most aggressive claim, that Amendment 53 is an unconstitutional bill of attainder aimed at one identifiable man. It also quotes the county executive’s own posture.
“Mello has publicly stated he is ready to appoint and it will not be Swank,” the petition states. “Mello is seeking to convert elected offices to appointed offices to centralize control of County government in his office.”
Swank’s crime numbers have not been the argument against him. Violent crime in Pierce County dropped 17 percent under his watch, a figure he delivered to a crowd of 50 protesters at a Key Peninsula library in March.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
1 Comments
The corruption of officials trying to over ride the will of the people is insane.