ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Washington wins court fight allowing state abortion law to override Kirkland church’s religious objections

The Ninth Circuit ruled 2-1 that Washington's abortion coverage mandate is constitutional, rejecting Kirkland's Cedar Park Assembly of God after six years.

pro-life activists...

The Ninth Circuit ruled 2-1 Monday against Cedar Park Assembly of God in Kirkland, upholding Washington's abortion coverage mandate. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

(Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Monday that Washington can keep requiring health plans covering maternity care to also cover abortion, ending, for now, a six-year constitutional challenge brought by Cedar Park Assembly of God in Kirkland.

At issue are two state laws. The Reproductive Parity Act of 2018, better known as Senate Bill 6219, requires insurance carriers to include abortion coverage in any health plan that covers maternity care. Washington’s three-decade-old conscience statute lets an employer refuse to purchase coverage for a service it objects to on religious or moral grounds, while requiring the employee’s carrier to separately tell workers how to obtain the excluded service anyway. Cedar Park, which insures roughly 140 people and teaches that abortion is sinful, argued that combination leaves it facilitating abortion no matter what it does.

The panel disagreed. It also did something the state spent years trying to prevent.

The church won the fight it was not having

Washington’s fallback position through most of this litigation was that Cedar Park had no business in federal court at all. A previous version of this same panel agreed in March 2025, holding the church lacked standing and ordering the case dismissed. That opinion was withdrawn in July 2025, and attorneys argued the case again before the Ninth Circuit in January.

This time the panel held that Cedar Park does have Article III standing, citing the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in Diamond Alternative Energy v. EPA. The court accepted the commonsense proposition that cheaper abortion services make it likelier someone will use them, which is enough of an injury to sue over.

But then it took the merits away.

Judge Graber’s answer was that Cedar Park had options

Writing for the majority, Judge Susan Graber concluded the two laws are religiously neutral and generally applicable, which means they face only rational basis review, a standard the church conceded it could not beat.

ADVERTISEMENT

Graber wrote that the church’s problem was largely of its own making.

“Since 2019, Plaintiff has chosen to purchase a health plan that provides coverage for abortion directly, although it has had opportunities to purchase a plan that excludes abortion coverage, and nothing in the challenged laws prevents it from obtaining such a plan today,” the opinion states. “Second, if Plaintiff asks Kaiser Washington to accommodate its religious objections, or if Plaintiff chooses to purchase an abortion-excluding health plan from a different carrier, Plaintiff will not pay for the services to which it objects, even indirectly.”

A Seattle Red review of the opinion found the specifics behind that finding, which have gone largely unreported. Cedar Park’s own insurance broker presented the church with a Cigna bid for the 2019/2020 plan year that excluded elective abortions and cost roughly $26,000 less than the Kaiser Washington plan the church renewed instead. Cigna made a similar offer the following year, also cheaper. The record shows no evidence the church ever went back to any carrier after November 2019, when the insurance commissioner’s office formally clarified that conscience-based exclusions were still legal.

ADVERTISEMENT

Callahan says the majority is grading on a curve

Judge Consuelo Callahan, the panel’s only Republican appointee, agreed the church could sue and split sharply on everything else.

The court’s summary of her partial dissent states, “In her view, Washington’s law burdens Cedar Park’s religious exercise, is neither neutral nor generally applicable, and cannot satisfy the high bar of strict scrutiny. The law thus runs afoul of the First Amendment.”

Callahan also argued that carriers can shift the cost of covering excluded abortions back onto objecting employers through premiums and administrative fees. The majority called that speculation unsupported by anything in the record.

What happens next in Washington?

Cedar Park is represented by Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), which has pushed the case for more than six years and can now petition the full Ninth Circuit or the Supreme Court. Eighteen Republican attorneys general, the Becket Fund, the Christian Legal Society and Notre Dame’s religious liberty clinic all filed briefs backing the church. The American Civil Liberties Union of Washington, Planned Parenthood and Legal Voice filed on the state’s side.

ADVERTISEMENT

The defendants are Insurance Commissioner Patty Kuderer and Governor Bob Ferguson, who built much of his statewide profile as attorney general on expanding abortion access.

Monday’s outcome also stands apart from the direction the Ninth Circuit took earlier this year, when it ruled that Washington violated the First Amendment by targeting Yakima Union Gospel Mission over faith-based hiring. The difference, the panel said, is that insurance purchasing is not internal church governance. Religious institutions in this state keep testing where that line sits, including a Kirkland father now suing the Lake Washington School District over an opt-out denial.

For Cedar Park, the fight is now about whether a higher court thinks an accommodation the church cannot actually use still counts as an accommodation. This fight appears far from over.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments