ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Washington wants a Christian homeless shelter to hire people who don’t share its faith, and 11 federal judges will decide

Washington Attorney General Nick Brown asked 11 Ninth Circuit judges Tuesday to revive the state's fight over who a Yakima Christian ministry may hire.

Yakima Union Gospel Mission worker...

The full Ninth Circuit heard arguments Tuesday in Washington's case against the Yakima Union Gospel Mission's faith-based hiring. (Yakima Union Gospel Mission via ADF)

(Yakima Union Gospel Mission via ADF)

Washington Attorney General Nick Brown’s office went back before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday, asking 11 judges in San Francisco to revive the state’s fight over who a Yakima Christian homeless ministry can hire. A unanimous three-judge panel already sided with the ministry in January.

The Yakima Union Gospel Mission requires every employee to share and live out its Christian faith. The state says the Washington Law Against Discrimination only lets religious nonprofits apply that standard to ministerial roles, and it has pointed to positions like IT support to make its case. When the mission sued in 2023, it had frozen hiring with about 50 jobs open. The January panel ruled in a unanimous rebuke of Brown’s office that the First Amendment protects its right to hire fellow believers. Brown’s office pushed anyway, and in June the full court vacated that decision and agreed to rehear the case, as Seattle Red previously reported.

Ryan Tucker directs the Center for Christian Ministries at Alliance Defending Freedom, which represents the mission. He said both sides took tough questions and is unclear how it will be decided.

Judges focus on who counts as a minister

Much of the lengthy hearing turned on the legal line between ministers and everyone else.

“They focused a lot on who are ministers. The mission itself hires like-minded folks, and so the court wanted to know if everyone we hire is indeed a minister because that matters under the law,” Tucker said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “The law makes a distinction between ministers and non-ministers, and here, even though all have been called, all have been required to sign a statement of faith, the law makes a distinction that not everyone is.”

Tucker rejected the state’s argument that a shelter’s computer technician has nothing to do with its religious mission.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Under the First Amendment, the government doesn’t get to decide who is qualified to share the mission’s Christian message or spread the gospel or disciple one another. You know, there’s more to a mission than simply the outward-facing role. It matters what’s happening on the inside,” he argued. “And as the U.S. Supreme Court, some of the justices have opined in years past, if a religious organization doesn’t have the right to hire like-minded people, well, then it’ll be destroyed from the inside out.”

A ruling that reaches beyond Yakima

The case follows years of pressure on Christian employers in Washington.

In 2021, the Washington Supreme Court narrowed the religious hiring exemption in Woods v. Seattle’s Union Gospel Mission, and then-Attorney General Bob Ferguson, now governor, went after Seattle Pacific University over its hiring policies.

ADVERTISEMENT

An en banc decision would bind federal courts across the Ninth Circuit. Tucker signaled a loss would head quickly to the U.S. Supreme Court.

“A victory would mean protection for not just religious organizations in the state of Washington, but in all of the Ninth Circuit. So that would be folks in California and Oregon and elsewhere. So tremendous protection there,” Tucker noted. “If, on the other hand, the court goes the other direction, then it leaves these religious organizations exposed. And rest assured, we’d be going to the court very quickly.”

The court did not indicate when it will rule.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

0 Comments