ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

24 states fight ruling that could make taxpayer-funded sex change surgery a constitutional right for prisoners

Idaho AG Labrador leads a 24-state amicus brief at the Ninth Circuit arguing the Eighth Amendment doesn't require states to pay for prisoner sex change surgeries.

Protester holding transgender pride flag outside the Supreme Court during legal fight over taxpayer...

Mayor Katie Wilson has signaled openness to the LGBTQ Commission's push for a formal civil emergency declaration, despite no verified data establishing a crisis exists. (Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)

(Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)

Idaho is not waiting for the rest of the country to catch up. Attorney General Raúl Labrador is helping to lead a 24-state coalition fighting to block a federal court ruling that could turn taxpayer-funded sex reassignment surgery into a constitutional right for convicted criminals housed in state prisons.

Labrador joined Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita and 22 other states in filing a 32-page amicus brief at the Ninth Circuit backing Alaska’s appeal of that lower-court decision. At stake is whether a single federal magistrate’s ruling out of Alaska can be used to force prison systems nationwide to provide experimental gender transition surgeries at taxpayer expense — a concern conservatives note is no longer hypothetical.

The inmate at the center of the case, Emalee Wagoner, is currently serving a 40-year sentence for sexual abuse of minors. Magistrate Judge Matthew Scoble nevertheless ruled that Alaska acted with “deliberate indifference” when it declined to refer Wagoner for surgery, finding the state in violation of the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment. Alaska is appealing that finding, and Idaho has stepped in to help make sure it doesn’t survive.

Idaho and Indiana make the constitutional case

Labrador did not mince words about what the lower court’s ruling actually threatens.

“A federal court ordered Alaska to refer a prisoner for sex-change surgery consultation, which threatens to set a precedent that forces other states to provide these procedures using taxpayer dollars,” Labrador said. “Idaho supports Alaska in defending state medical decisions against judicial overreach. The Eighth Amendment ensures basic medical care for prisoners, but it doesn’t require states to provide experimental gender transition surgeries.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The 32-page brief argues that sex reassignment surgery does not qualify as a “minimal civilized measure of life’s necessities” under Eighth Amendment doctrine. It also points out that the procedure is unavailable to free citizens in roughly half the country, a fact that directly undermines the argument that denying it amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.
Rokita framed the constitutional question with equal clarity.

“The Eighth Amendment stops cruel and unusual punishment. It doesn’t give prisoners the right to demand risky, optional surgeries when doctors and scientists still strongly disagree about whether they’re safe or even helpful,” Rokita said

The science isn’t settled and the brief says so

The amicus brief doesn’t limit its argument to constitutional text. Idaho and Indiana’s attorneys general cited a 2016 Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services review of research on the effectiveness of sex reassignment procedures, which found that the reviewed studies did not demonstrate clinically significant changes or differences in psychometric outcomes following surgery.

ADVERTISEMENT

The brief also took direct aim at the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), arguing that the organization has shifted its clinical guidance to reflect external political pressure rather than scientific consensus. The brief stated that “despite WPATH’s insistence on surgeries, nothing in the Eighth Amendment’s text or history allows prisoners to demand whatever medical interventions they desire. Nor does anything in its text or history require States to provide risky, controversial medical procedures of uncertain benefit to prisoners.”

WPATH pushed back in a statement provided to Fox News Digital, saying it has been committed for five decades to guidelines informed by established scientific standards. A spokesperson said those guidelines are grounded in individualized patient care rather than a uniform approach.

What happens at the Ninth Circuit matters nationwide

Twenty-four states signing onto this brief is not a small thing. It signals that a broad coalition of attorneys general is watching this case and is prepared to fight any ruling that transforms a contested surgical procedure into a federally mandated entitlement for convicted criminals. Labrador’s decision to co-lead that effort puts Idaho at the front of one of the most consequential prisoner rights battles in years, with implications for every state corrections system in the country.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Idaho and Indiana amicus brief was first reported by Fox News Digital.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

1 Comments

M
Mark Mad 8 months ago

We do not have serious people in power. The consequences are real.