ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Four Eastern Washington sheriffs sue to block Ferguson’s unelected sheriff removal board

Four Eastern Washington sheriffs filed suit to block SB 5974, a law letting an unelected state commission remove elected sheriffs without a voter recall.

Spokane County Sheriff patrol vehicle with emergency lights activated — four Eastern Washington s...

A Spokane County Sheriff patrol vehicle. Four Eastern Washington sheriffs — including Sheriff John Nowels — sued Gov. Bob Ferguson Thursday to block SB 5974, which lets an unelected state commission remove elected sheriffs without a voter recall. (Photo: Spokane County Sheriff's Department)

(Photo: Spokane County Sheriff's Department)

Four Eastern Washington sheriffs sued the state Thursday, asking a Pend Oreille County court to block a new law they say hands an unelected state commission the power to end their careers without a vote, a recall, or a court order.

Spokane County Sheriff John Nowels, Pend Oreille County Sheriff Glenn Blakeslee, Stevens County Sheriff Brad Manke, and Ferry County Sheriff Ray Maycumber filed the complaint against the State of Washington, the Washington State Legislature, and Governor Bob Ferguson.

A hearing on their motion for a preliminary injunction is scheduled for April 16.

The lawsuit targets Senate Bill 5974, which Ferguson signed on April 1. The law requires elected sheriffs to obtain and maintain peace officer certification through the Washington State Criminal Justice Training Commission, a 21-member body appointed by the governor. If the CJTC denies or revokes that certification, the law creates a vacancy in the sheriff’s office by operation of law. No judge needed o4 recall required. The voters are cut out entirely.

An unelected board with vague power to remove elected sheriffs

The complaint argues the law is unconstitutional on multiple grounds. The CJTC can deny or revoke certification for reasons that include “affiliation” with an “extremist organization,” a term the sheriffs say is so broadly written it could sweep in almost anything. Under the rules implementing the law, attending an event hosted by an organization that the CJTC later deems extremist could count as a disqualifying affiliation, with no knowledge or intent required.

ADVERTISEMENT

The sheriffs also argue that SB 5974 requires candidates to swear under penalty of perjury that they meet all of its requirements, which necessarily includes swearing to remain eligible under a certification standard nobody can fully define. Their motion calls it a modern-day McCarthy loyalty oath and cites a 1974 Washington Supreme Court ruling that threw out a far less sweeping oath as unconstitutional on its face.

The sheriffs’ motion argues the governor and legislature “adopted a modern-day McCarthy loyalty oath in the form of SB 5974,” calling it “not a close constitutional call but rather a flatly prohibited practice from a dark period of our country’s history that must never be resurrected.”

Sheriffs call SB 5974 a voter rights grab

The four sheriffs released a joint statement Thursday calling the law an attack on voter rights disguised as a professional standards upgrade.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Concealed beneath the misleading title that claims to modernize regulations concerning law enforcement leaders, lies a clearly unconstitutional mechanism that centralizes power by stripping it from the people,” the sheriffs wrote, adding that “SB 5974 destroys the people’s inherent political power, guaranteed to them by the Constitution, and purposely shifts that power to an unelected board appointed by the Governor.”

In an interview on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM, before the vote in the state legislature, Thurston County Sheriff Derek Sanders blasted the bill as “voter suppression.”

Ferguson signed SB 5974 despite admitting it may need fixes

The governor offered a muted defense when he put pen to paper.

“It’s a serious step when someone’s being removed from office, speaking as an elected official,” Ferguson said at the signing. “I just want to make sure we’re being as thoughtful as possible on that, and so I just pressed that to the bill sponsors. I don’t make too big a deal out of it.”

ADVERTISEMENT

He acknowledged the law may need work: “I’ll be looking for ways if we can just improve that process a little bit as we go into next session,” Ferguson added, noting it was too early to say what those revisions might be.

The bill passed the Senate 30 to 19 and the House 54 to 42. It takes effect April 30, just days before the May 4 election filing window opens. Sheriffs across the state would need to comply before they can even get on the ballot.

The lawsuit has the backing of all four county prosecuting attorneys. Seattle-based law firm Carney Badley and Spellman is representing the sheriffs.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

8 Comments

T
The Watosh 8 months ago

"He acknowledged the law may need work: “I’ll be looking for ways if we can just improve that process a little bit as we go into next session,” Ferguson added, noting it was too early to say what those revisions might be."
Typical leftist tactics - throw the defecation against the interior and see if it clings or not. Who cares what the effect is in the process....
But it only serves to prove once again that the leftist mantra is and has always been: THE LEFTIST END FULLY JUSTIFIES ANY AND ALL LEFTIST MEANS

C
Candis Gauvin 8 months ago

We the people are very capable of recalling a voted in Sheriff if we disapprove of their job performance. This board bypasses the will of the people and is unconstitutional imho

T
T B 8 months ago

Thank you Sheriff’s for stepping up, to bad the remaining didn’t get on board.