ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ

Millionaires tax sweetener is going to cost WA cities millions they cannot afford

WA cities face millions in lost sales tax revenue from the new millionaires tax, and the state's promise to backfill those losses is far from guaranteed.

Washington State Capitol building in Olympia, site of Democrats' passage of SB 6346, the 9.9% milli...

The Washington State Capitol in Olympia, where Democrats wasted millions in taxpayer dollars yet again. (Photo by David Ryder/Getty Images)

(Photo by David Ryder/Getty Images)

Washington Democrats sold the 9.9% millionaires tax as a way to make the ultra-wealthy pay more while delivering relief to ordinary people through sales tax exemptions on hygiene products, over-the-counter medications, and even diapers. But from Seattle to Sultan and Bellevue to Bellingham, cities across the state are now learning that relief comes at their expense.

Those exemptions, buried inside Senate Bill 6346, don’t just reduce state revenue; they apply to the local sales taxes cities depend on to fund police, fire, roads, and parks. The cuts come in 2029, the same year the income tax kicks in, and city governments are already doing the math on what that means for their budgets.

The Association of Washington Cities (AWC) has been pushing for answers from the legislature, and its government relations director made clear the situation is already precarious.

“Some cities are more reliant on sales tax than others,” Candice Bock told KOMO News. “But right now, what we’re hearing from cities, generally, is budgets are tight. And looking ahead, things are challenging in terms of revenues keeping up with the costs of things in our communities.”

What’s at stake for city budgets

What’s exactly at stake for cities?

“It’s things like streets, sidewalks, those are often mostly funded by general fund dollars, which come in the large part from sales taxes and property taxes, parks,” she noted. “Those kinds of basic services that folks think about when they think about what makes quality of life in their community.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The state legislature has said it intends to backfill what cities lose, though intentions are not guarantees. The AWC is pushing for at least $200 million to cover local governments as the exemptions take effect, and Washington Democrats’ tax-and-spend record going back years gives cities every reason to want something firmer than a verbal commitment.

“We certainly would always like things to be more written in stone,” she said. “But this is a good first step and gives us time to work with the legislature on what does that look like in the future.”

That is a carefully diplomatic way of saying cities are being asked to trust a legislature that just handed them a budget problem they didn’t create.

Seattle silent, Tacoma pushing back

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson has spent weeks waving off warnings about what the millionaires tax would do to the city’s economic climate. KOMO News reached out to her office to ask whether the administration is worried about the sales tax exemption impact on Seattle’s budget and whether it trusts the legislature to fully backfill the losses. Seattle officials did not respond.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tacoma’s mayor was less evasive. Mayor Anders Ibsen pushed back at the idea that the state can reshuffle revenue at the local level without consequence.

“While it’s good that the Legislature is taking steps to fix our broken state tax code, this should not come at the expense of cities,” Ibsen argued. “It is not morally or fiscally responsible for the state to raid money that pays for local law enforcement, street repair, or dealing with homelessness. We will be working to ensure that the Legislature balances the budget without robbing Peter to pay Paul.”

As MyNorthwest reported when Gov. Bob Ferguson signed the law, the sales tax exemptions were added as a political sweetener to secure support for the income tax, not because anyone in Olympia had worked through what it would cost local governments.

A promise with no formula

Bock acknowledged the difficulty of predicting exactly how much will need to flow back to cities each year.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I think it is a little too early to know how it will make the most sense in the long run,” she said. “Many of the funds shared are done on a per capita basis, but others rely on formulas.”

That vagueness is the problem. Documents later uncovered show the millionaires tax was designed less as a revenue tool and more as a legal vehicle to overturn Washington’s 90-year constitutional prohibition on a graduated income tax. The sales tax exemptions were the packaging used to sell it. Now cities are left holding the bill for that gambit, with businesses across Washington having warned from the moment the legislation was introduced that the downstream damage would extend well beyond millionaires.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

1 Comments

M
Mark Mad 6 months ago

The vagueness isn't the problem. The theft of of taxpayer money, then the tax increases to replace is the issue. People are leaving this state. The c is hitting the fan.