‘No Excuse’: Audit blisters Washington Department of Commerce for ‘pervasive’ accountability failures
A State Auditor report details widespread failures at Washington’s Department of Commerce, including poor oversight, ignored rules, and millions in unverifiable spending.
Watch: Audit Exposes A Rot Culture Inside Washington’s Department Of Commerce | 8 mins
Washington’s Department of Commerce is facing scrutiny after a blistering State Auditor report detailed sweeping failures in how the agency handled tens of millions of taxpayer dollars, exposing problems that go far beyond a single program.
The audit examined Commerce’s management of the now-defunct Digital Navigator Program, which distributed more than $92 million in public funds between 2021 and 2025. Auditors uncovered a pattern of disregard for basic accountability that mirrors longstanding concerns about the agency’s culture and leadership.
The State Auditor said the findings were a warning about systemic breakdowns, not isolated mistakes.
“In my view, this report details failures in the management of this program so pervasive they go beyond a lack of basic internal controls. There is no excuse for the myriad actions taken at the time by management at the Department of Commerce, who were tasked with overseeing $92.5 million in public funds for the Digital Navigator program alone,” Auditor Pat McCarthy wrote in the report.
Constant, consistent failures
Auditors found Commerce failed at nearly every stage of grant oversight, from awarding contracts to verifying whether work was actually performed.
“As this report details, the department used a questionable process to award program grants,” the audit states. “The contracts the agency completed with grantees lacked clear responsibilities. The agency did not vet grantees or their subgrantees properly.”
The breakdown continued after contracts were signed. According to the audit, Commerce failed to monitor performance, ignored documentation requirements, and approved payments despite internal objections.
“As this report details, the department used a questionable process to award program grants,” the report states. “The contracts the agency completed with grantees lacked clear responsibilities. The agency did not vet grantees or their subgrantees properly. It did not track their performance. It did not hold grantees to basic requirements for payments. When department staff raised concerns about reimbursing grantees without evidence of services provided, they were overruled by leadership in place at the time. In addition, a program staff member took employment with a grantee, a potential violation of state rules that requires us to forward this report to the State Ethics Board.”
Shocking details
In one of the most serious findings, auditors said the lack of documentation was so severe that nearly $11 million in payments could not be verified.
“The most significant consequence of the unspecific guidance is that the State Auditor’s Office could not verify as allowable almost all the $10.7 million Commerce paid to one primary grantee: the documentation the grantee provided was insufficient to support the payments. Our work found that most of the expenses that had sufficient documentation were also unallowable,” according to the report.
Auditors warned the damage extends beyond one failed program.
“Government accountability, including accountability for grantees, improves results and maintains public trust,” the report concludes. “Trust that I am afraid will be undermined by the severity of the findings we must report here.”
The response
According to KING 5, the Department of Commerce acknowledged the audit’s findings and said new leadership has already begun making changes.
“When I arrived at commerce and was notified of the seriousness of the issues in the program, we acted immediately,” Sarah Clifthorne, the agency’s interim director, explained.
The agency told the station it agrees with the auditor’s recommendations and is reviewing internal controls, grant oversight practices, and reimbursement procedures. Commerce also emphasized that leadership has turned over since much of the misconduct occurred and said it is working to determine whether improperly documented payments can be recovered, according to the KING 5 report.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
4 Comments
The government being irresponsible with the free money they take from us under the threat of prison. No one is surprised. Remember the Boston tea party? Yeah that was over tea. Now no one cares as they make you a part time slave to fund their projects that cost too much and do nothing.
unfortunately we live in a state where the majority of people don't seem to care about any of this and happily pay ever increasing taxes. The leadership that allowed this has moved on. Where did they go? To another government job where they can squander millions again?
Appears that we're due for another round of whales beaching themselves.