ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ

Sheriff Keith Swank: Should reckless adventurers pay for their own rescues?

Pierce County Sheriff Keith Swank raises tough questions about who should pay when reckless behavior triggers costly Search and Rescue operations.

The Pierce County Sheriff’s Office conducts enforcement and rescue operations across both urban and rural areas. One of my responsibilities is overseeing Search and Rescue (SAR) operations in the county.

In our state, we’ve seen a range of incidents: two women floating down a river—without life jackets—had to be rescued twice in the same day. A man refused to be rescued after teams hiked seven hours to reach him. A woman suffered a head injury while glissading (intentionally sliding) down a mountain, requiring a six-hour rescue.

These incidents raise questions: Should people be charged when their intentional recklessness forces a rescue? Should they bear some of the cost of Search and Rescue operations? Or should all the costs be absorbed by you, the taxpayers?

Reckless vs. accidents

Half of our calls involve operations in easily accessible urban areas. But we also face tragedies in the wilderness. A woman recently fell into a river while trying to rescue her dog and was swept away. That was a tragic accident—not reckless behavior. Our deputies and technical experts spent hours in rugged terrain near Mount Rainier searching for her. Twenty deputies, at an estimated $150 per hour including salary and equipment, were on scene for five to ten hours. Quick math shows taxpayer costs can add up fast.

Charging people for rescues due to recklessness is a sensitive topic. To be clear, I am not suggesting reimbursement in the case of accidents. My goal is simply to illustrate the cost to taxpayers when rescues involve risky, avoidable behavior—like rafters refusing to wear life jackets.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’ve discussed this issue with our SAR leaders. They caution that introducing fees could discourage people from calling 911 until it’s too late. I understand that concern, and I do not want anyone to hesitate to seek help in an emergency. But there must be some measure of personal responsibility.

Who decides what qualifies as reckless?

I don’t have all the answers. In an era of budget cuts, defunding debates, and political uncertainty, we must consider how we fund vital life-saving operations like Search and Rescue teams. One possibility is a “reckless behavior” fee—but who decides what qualifies as reckless? These are complex questions that deserve careful conversation with other sheriffs and emergency service leaders.

Our goal is to keep people safe, but we must also be mindful of the massive resources it takes to save lives. Personal responsibility and public safety are not mutually exclusive; they should work hand in hand.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pierce County Sheriff Keith Swank is a 35-year law enforcement officer and U.S. Army veteran. He gained national attention for supervising the clearance of Seattle’s “CHOP/CHAZ” protest zone and negotiating the peaceful surrender of the Seattle Jewish Federation mass shooter.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

N
Nate Wallace 1 year ago

Are you going to pay the hundreds of volunteer Search and Rescue people that show up at a drop of a hat at all hours of the day. Spend long hours helping people and more hours training. Many in the search and rescue community believe that emergency services, much like police and fire departments, should be available to everyone without a fee. The mission is to save lives, not to turn a profit or punish people for making mistakes. The focus should be on prevention and education, not on financial retribution.
​While some jurisdictions do have laws that allow for charging in cases of gross negligence, the consensus among major search and rescue organizations like the National Association for Search and Rescue (NASAR) is that the practice should be avoided. The potential for loss of life far outweighs the financial benefit.

N
Nick E. 1 year ago

I agree that taxpayers should not be on the hook for when people do really dumb things in the wilderness and end up needing to be rescued. Unfortunately there is so much 'grey area' with this topic that lawyers could have a field day with it. A few feet here and there can mean the difference between 'mostly safe' and 'really unsafe', so who decides where that line is? Sure, going in the river with no PFD is super dumb, but is there a law against it? There's so many issues and variables here that the time and resources needed to recoup rescue costs may not be worth it. P.S. - Thanks for all you do, Sheriff!