Idaho judge blasts Boise loitering ordinance; city forced to repeal law after drug-arrest lawsuit
Boise has agreed to repeal its private-property loitering ban after a federal judge ruled the ordinance unconstitutionally vague.
Boise police must stop loitering arrests; city repealed law ruled vague. (Photo: Boise Police Department Facebook)
(Photo: Boise Police Department Facebook)
The city of Boise has settled a federal lawsuit that will prohibit police from detaining someone for loitering, according to the Idaho Statesman.
As a result of the settlement, the city will also repeal its ordinance banning loitering on private property.
A man named Luke Schuchardt sued the city on Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment grounds after officers arrested him for loitering in March 2022.
They suspected a drug deal was taking place when Schuchardt was parked at a 24-hour car wash. After searching his vehicle, the officers found methamphetamine and marijuana.
In August of this year, U.S. District Judge B. Lynn Winmill ruled the city’s ordinance was “unconstitutionally vague.”
“The ordinance fails to coherently define unlawful loitering and instead vests police with tremendous discretion to determine when an individual’s presence on private property becomes a crime,” Winmill wrote in his decision.
“The vast sweep of the law contradicts basic principles of due process.”
Boise’s ordinance prohibits “loitering, prowling or wandering” on private property without permission.
What does SCOTUS say?
The Supreme Court has not said loitering laws writ large are unconstitutional, only if they are vague and overly broad.
In 1999, the court struck down a Chicago loitering law aimed at cracking down on gang activity in Chicago v. Morales.
The court’s three conservative justices, Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, and Chief Justice William Rehnquist all dissented.
Justice Thomas noted in his dissenting opinion that “Vagrancy laws were common in the decades preceding the ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment, and remained on the books long after.”
Furthermore, while the Fourth Amendment does protect against “unreasonable searches and seizures,” there are exceptions for officers to search without a warrant if they have probable cause.
Boise would do well to amend the ordinance in a way that passes constitutional muster rather than repealing it altogether.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.
Comments
0 Comments