Idaho moves to block criminals like Bryan Kohberger from profiting off notoriety
Idaho lawmakers advance a bill updating the Son of Sam law to stop criminals profiting from notoriety.
Idaho bill aims to block criminal profit from notoriety. (Photo: Kai Eiselein-Pool, Getty Images)
(Photo: Kai Eiselein-Pool, Getty Images)
High profile inmates in Idaho, like Bryan Kohberger or Lori Vallow Daybell, might eventually find a market for their stories, but a new legislative proposal aims to make sure they never see a dime of the profits. State Senator Tammy Nichols (R-Middleton) introduced a bill this week to update Idaho’s decades-old “Son of Sam” law, ensuring that criminals cannot profit from their notoriety.
The current law which is nearly 50 years old, was designed to compensate victims if a criminal makes a deal to tell their story. However, Nichols argues the law is outdated and fails to address how people make money through modern media today.
Major cases prompt overhaul
The proposed update is a direct response to several massive murder cases that have put Idaho in the national spotlight.
Nichols specifically mentioned the 2022 University of Idaho student murders and the trials of Chad and Lori Vallow Daybell as primary reasons for the change.
“It updates our current law to prevent money from being made off of criminal notoriety,” Nichols told a Senate committee, according to Idaho Statesman. She explained that the bill aims to close loopholes regarding modern monetization while still protecting the First Amendment by regulating the money earned, rather than the speech itself.
Putting victims first
The goals of the legislation is to seize any earnings from book deals, movie rights, or interviews, and use that money to pay off court ordered restitution and damages to victims’ families. Co-sponsor Rep. Elaine Price (R-Coeur d’Alene) emphasized that for families who have already lost so much, seeing a killer profit from their pain is a form of “revictimization” that the state needs to stop.
Similar laws in other states have been overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court for violating free speech. To avoid this, Nichols says she revised the bill so it focuses only on the economic side of the issue.
There are also specific exceptions in the bill. Inmates could still earn regular wages for work unrelated to their crimes, and they wouldn’t be penalized for appearing in news documentaries meant to educate the public, or for works of art that only briefly mention their crimes.
The Senate committee voted unanimously on Monday to move the bill forward for a public hearing.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments