Idaho bill would require daily moment of silence in public schools
Idaho lawmakers advance a bill requiring public schools to begin each day with a moment of silence.
Washington slipped to 31st nationally for education even as per-pupil spending hit a record high. (Photo by Beata Zawrzel/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
(Photo by Beata Zawrzel/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
House Bill 623 requiring Idaho public schools to start every day with a moment of silence is officially headed to the House floor. The proposal, introduced by Representative Bruce Skaug (R-Nampa), would give students 60 seconds of quiet time at the beginning of each school day.
During this time, students can choose to pray, meditate, or simply sit in silence. Skaug explained that the goal is to give kids a break from screens and outside influences so they can focus before starting their classes.
Supporters say quiet time could improve student behavior
Several religious leaders and organizations, including a local Rabbi and a representative from PragerU, spoke in favor of the bill during a committee hearing.
They argued that a moment of silence has a “proven track record” in other states for helping lower juvenile crime rates, according to Boise State Public Radio. Because traditional school prayer was ruled unconstitutional years ago, supporters see this as a legal way to bring thoughtful reflection back into the classroom.
The bill is modeled after similar laws already in place in nearly 36 other states across the country.
Opponents worry about government overreach in the classroom
While the bill passed the committee with a 10-4 vote, it did face some pushback from both Democrats and a few Republicans. Critics, including Representative Soñia Galaviz, who is a teacher, argued that the state shouldn’t force this requirement on every school, as reported by Boise State Public Radio.
She believes that teachers should have the freedom to decide when their specific students need mindfulness or quiet time rather than being told what to do by the government. Other opponents questioned if there is a real link between 60 seconds of silence and better behavior.
To stay within the law, the bill makes it clear that teachers cannot lead or organize any religious activity during the 60 seconds. Students are free to use the time however they want as long as they stay quiet and don’t disrupt their classmates.
This ensures that the moment remains a personal choice for every child, whether they want to pray or just sit still. Now that it has cleared the committee, the full House will vote on whether to make this a permanent part of the Idaho school day.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments