Idaho Republicans split as bill to curb ‘broad’ child neglect laws fails
Idaho House committee almost rejects a bill to redefine child neglect after Republican split.
Idaho Republicans split on child neglect bill. (Photo courtesy of Idaho Legislature)
(Photo courtesy of Idaho Legislature)
A proposal to change how Idaho defines “child neglect” failed to move forward after a close vote in a House committee.
Republicans on the committee were split over the plan, with some arguing it would protect families from government overreach and others concerned it would leave children in dangerous homes.
Representative Barbara Ehardt (R-Idaho Falls) introduced the bill to narrow the definition of neglect to cases where a child has already been harmed or is in “imminent” danger. She argued that the current law is “too broad” and allows the state to interfere in families for minor issues like skipping a meal.
Debate over parental rights and medical care
Representative Dale Hawkins (R-Fernwood) supported the bill, sharing that his own family had dealt with unnecessary reports to social workers for simple things like his children jumping into hay bales, per Idaho Capital Sun. He argued that the current definitions are too easy to use against good parents and that it is time for a change to protect parental rights.
The bill also aimed to protect parents who seek a second medical opinion. Ehardt argued that a parent should not be accused of neglect just because they want to explore different treatment options for a sick child.
However, Representative John Gannon (D-Boise) questioned this part of the bill, suggesting it could create an exception for those who choose to avoid medical care for their children entirely.
Republicans divided on safety standards
According to Idaho Capital Sun, not all Republicans agreed with narrowing the law.
Representative John Shirts (R-Weiser) voted against the bill, noting that the proposal would drop Idaho’s safety standards down to the “minimum” requirements set by federal law. Shirts argued that Idaho should not have a lower threshold for what counts as child neglect.
The bill ultimately failed in a tight 7-8 vote. Both Democrats and several Republicans on the committee joined together to block the measure from moving forward.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.





Comments
0 Comments