ADVERTISEMENT

IDAHO

Federal judge carves out new exceptions for Idaho abortion law in appalling display of judicial overreach

A federal judge has decided to legislate from the bench and add new exceptions to Idaho's abortion law, which was already on the ballot this November.

A federal judge has intervened to overhaul Idaho's abortion law  (Photo: Anna Moneymaker, Getty Ima...

A federal judge has intervened to overhaul Idaho's abortion law (Photo: Anna Moneymaker, Getty Images)

(Photo: Anna Moneymaker, Getty Images)

The federal judiciary is once again legislating from the bench, this time in Idaho where a federal judge has stepped in to amend the state’s abortion law. U.S. District Court of Idaho Judge B. Lynn Winmill has ruled that the 14th Amendment establishes a right for a woman to procure an abortion if there’s a risk to her health or if there’s a high risk of self-harm.

Winmill, a Bill Clinton appointee, wrote in his decision that the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection and Due Process clauses “establish a narrow but fundamental right to abortion when a pregnancy threatens the woman’s life or health.”

The ‘health’ standard is intentionally vague

Many Democrat-run states have passed similar abortion laws that allow women to seek an abortion, even up to the moment of birth, if a pregnancy is deemed to be detrimental to the woman’s health. These often include exceptions for a woman’s “mental health,” which is intentionally vague language intended to make abortion restrictions as lax as possible. A Massachusetts law signed by Governor Maura Healey would be the most recent example.

“By banning health-preserving abortion, Idaho attempts to deny this fundamental right on the basis that the threat of harm comes from a fetus, which depends on the woman for survival,” Winmill wrote. “But a pregnant woman’s health is not a state resource to be allocated at the legislature’s whim. The Fourteenth Amendment exists precisely to prevent subjugation like this.”

Judicial overreach at its worst

Local leaders and pro-life groups in Idaho blasted Wimill’s ruling as yet another tragic example of judicial overreach.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Judge Winmill did exactly what the Supreme Court rejected in Dobbs: he legislated from the bench and manufactured a new constitutional right to abortion,” Idaho Attorney General Raul Labrador said in a statment. “The Supreme Court made clear that abortion policy belongs to the people and their elected representatives, not a single federal judge. Not only did he ignore Dobbs, he compounded that mistake by ignoring clear precedent stating that district judges lack authority to issue universal injunctions. We will appeal immediately, and we are confident this decision will be overturned.”

The pro-life Idaho Family Policy Center was also disheartened by the decision but remains optimistic that it will be overturned.

“It’s important to recognize that the civil cause of action in the Heartbeat law still remains in effect — meaning that any physician who performs an abortion that is prohibited by the Heartbeat law can still be liable for breaking the law,” IFPC President Blaine Conzatti said in a press release. “And doctors should take note: The IFPC Legal Center stands ready to hold doctors accountable who illegally perform abortions.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The abortion issue is already being decided at the ballot box

Winmill’s decision is even more egregious considering Idaho has an abortion initiative on the ballot this November, but the judge decided to try and take the issue out of the voters’ hands.

When Idahoans receive their ballots this fall they will see the “Reproductive Freedom and Privacy Act,” which would establish “a right to make private reproductive health care decisions.” The measure would bar the state from infringing on this so-called right to “reproductive freedom” up to the point of fetal viability, which is often considered to be around 24 weeks. The initiative needs at least 51% of the vote on the November 3 ballot to become law.

The state’s Defense of Life Act is one of the most stringent abortion bans in the country. The law prohibits abortion from the moment of conception, but does have exceptions for rape, incest, and the life of the mother.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jackson Meyer Producer, The Jason Rantz Show

Born and raised in Issaquah, Jackson is a lifelong Washingtonian. He is an avid sports fan, particularly of baseball, which he played at the varsity level in High School. He worked at the Seattle-based conservative think tank Discovery Institute for… Read more

Comments

1 Comments

S
Shawn m 3 months ago

Idaho needs to buckle up their seatbelts. In the midterms, eight incumbent conservative lawmakers were dethroned by RINOs. Funded by out-of-state big money, the state is dishonorably sliding towards blue.