GOP candidate Tonya Stadlman says Washington’s housing first model treats the symptom, not the disease
Republican 44th LD candidate Tonya Stadlman says Washington's $1.8 billion homelessness spend is propping up a housing first model that ignores addiction.
A new tiny home village in Seattle's Interbay neighborhood opened up in June. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
Republican state representative candidate Tonya Stadlman says Washington’s homelessness strategy has the diagnosis backwards.
After more than 30 years in multifamily housing watching the same crisis play out in her own buildings, Stadlman argues that Olympia’s roughly $1.8 billion commitment to homelessness for the next biennium is being poured into a model that ignores what’s actually keeping people on the streets.
That model is housing first, the strategy of placing chronically homeless people into subsidized apartments without requiring treatment, sobriety, or accountability. Stadlman, who is running in Washington’s 44th legislative district covering Mill Creek, Lake Stevens, and Snohomish, says the approach treats the symptom and leaves the disease in place. The federal government appears to agree. HUD recently announced it is pulling roughly a third of $4 billion in homelessness funding away from the housing first model, with King County alone facing roughly $26 million at risk.
Her critique tracks closely with what local officials like Snohomish Councilmember Nate Nehring have argued for months. The chronically homeless on Washington streets, Stadlman says, are not suffering from a lack of apartments. They are suffering from active addiction, and an apartment with no requirements attached does nothing to change that.
Speaking to the disease
Asked what a real homelessness pathway should look like, Stadlman pointed directly at the underlying addiction.
“I think first we have to look at the person and what they’re dealing with, which is addiction. When you’re talking to somebody who’s currently in an active addiction under the influence, you’re not speaking to the person, you’re speaking to the disease. So, when you’re asking, hey, do you want some help, of course they don’t. They want their next hit. They want to be left alone. When you’re putting them into housing, thinking that that’s going to solve the problem, that’s not. We have to detox them, stabilize them, educate them, get them nourished, get them fed, get them back to where they can actually think for themselves and make those decisions, but not make it optional when somebody is chronic homeless,” Stadlman said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.
Her argument runs against what Washington Democrats continue to push. House Bill 2266, which would strip local communities of the authority to block permanent supportive housing operating under housing first rules, advanced through both chambers earlier this year. Conservatives warned it would override neighborhood zoning and force low-barrier facilities into residential communities with no treatment requirements attached.
Stadlman, who has managed properties from Lakewood up to Marysville and points in between, including Capitol Hill during the CHOP occupation, says she has watched the cost of the housing first model show up in real time. Tenants come into her office unable to pay rent. Crime keeps rising. Property managers spend down their budgets securing mailboxes, rec rooms, and parked cars from break-ins that often trace back to active addiction nearby.
Enabling is disabling
Stadlman says her message on homelessness is straightforward.
“I always say enabling is disabling, and that’s the kind of actions that we’ve been taking, we’re enabling this disabling behavior, and it needs to stop, because compassion without consequences is not compassion,” Stadlman added.
It’s a message that lines up with where federal policy is now moving and where a growing share of Washington voters have ended up after watching the state spend record sums and produce more tents, not fewer. Stadlman is hoping the 44th has reached the same conclusion.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
3 Comments
This is just another jobs program for those who support the WA state Democrat party, 6 figure jobs, no accountability and definitely no fixing of the problem. Just keep raising taxes to dump the money into their own party. In earlier years of our nation we would call this CORRUPTION!
Washington State and Seattle Housing before Rehab. methodology will perpetuates the Homeless Industrial Complex and ensure the homeless population is not reduced.
Wow breaking news.