Cle Elum passed a data center ban that may not stop the data center
Cle Elum's City Council unanimously banned new data centers three days after a $200 million project was pitched, then admitted the ban may not stop it at all.
Cle Elum's City Council passed a six-month moratorium on new data centers days after a $200 million project was proposed. (City of Cle Elum/Facebook)
(City of Cle Elum/Facebook)
Cle Elum’s City Council voted unanimously Friday to block new data centers for six months, but then acknowledged the ban probably won’t stop the $200 million project that prompted it.
The emergency moratorium came three days after Blue Fern Development presented plans for a 100,000-square-foot facility inside a residential and commercial development already under construction near I-90, according to The Seattle Times. Council members said they need time to study how large computing facilities affect electricity, water, fire protection, noise and the local economy, and to write regulations before anything else gets proposed.
There is one complication, however. The site sits under a preexisting development agreement, which means the 20-megawatt proposal may be reviewed under the older rules. The city still has to decide whether a data center qualifies as a commercial or industrial use that was already permitted.
The council admits the moratorium may be theater
Councilmember Steven Harper warned residents that the vote would not necessarily override the development agreement.
“I don’t want to create an illusion that this addresses the concerns that I’m hearing many from the public,” Harper said.
Blue Fern representative Ben Paulus put the facility at about 20 megawatts of electricity, 20 to 40 full-time jobs and roughly $200 million in cost, with the property tax revenue that follows. He described it as a research sized data center rather than the sprawling campuses proposed elsewhere. Microsoft’s projects in Chelan County could be more than ten times bigger in both land and power use.
The water figure is the one worth remembering the next time an activist claims these facilities drain a town dry. Paulus said the cooling system runs on a closed loop that would use about 80,000 gallons in its first year and far less afterward, because the same liquid recirculates.
Puget Sound Energy, which serves Cle Elum, reviewed the request and concluded the load could be served reliably, with Blue Fern funding the infrastructure upgrades so existing ratepayers are protected from cost increases. The utility answered the ratepayer objection before the council ever voted on it.
Washington keeps saying no
Seattle became the largest city in the country to pause large data centers when its council approved a one-year moratorium in June, brushing off a federal warning that pushing the facilities overseas creates a national security problem. Spokane and Federal Way followed. State Democrats passed a convention resolution opposing new construction. Seattle has since shed roughly 1,700 construction jobs while data center work drove building elsewhere in the country.
Quincy, meanwhile, threw a party in May for the twentieth anniversary of Microsoft’s first facility there. The town of 8,673 built its modern economy on the servers everyone else is now voting to keep out.
Cle Elum will form an advisory committee to study power capacity, water, wastewater, taxes and jobs. A public hearing is set for Sept. 8. Whether any of it applies to Blue Fern is a separate question the city has not answered.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments