ADVERTISEMENT

EDUCATION

Far-left faculty group demands UW defend academic freedom while censoring its own listserv: Cliff Mass

UW's AAUP demanded answers over Aria Fani's firing. Cliff Mass says the same group censors faculty who don't share its far-left politics on its own listserv.

Students cross the street near the University of Washington's iconic W sign on the Seattle campus...

The University of Washington campus in Seattle, where the AAUP chapter is demanding answers after Professor Aria Fani lost his Middle East Center directorship in March. (Photo: Karen Ducey, Getty Images)

(Photo: Karen Ducey, Getty Images)

The organization demanding the University of Washington (UW) answer for removing a professor who used an official listserv to spread pro-Iran regime propaganda runs its own listserv. Yet a professor who sits on it says the group operates as a censorship tool against anyone who doesn’t share the far left’s politics.

The UW chapter of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) sent a letter last week calling the March 27 removal of Professor Aria Fani from the Middle East Center directorship a “cut-and-dried violation” of academic freedom and demanding a response from university leadership. UW atmospheric sciences professor Cliff Mass, who is on the AAUP listserv himself, said the framing is rich.

“It’s kind of ironic that the AAUP, the American Association of University Professors, was supposedly formed to protect academic freedom and freedom of speech, but they are the worst in preventing folks that had different viewpoints from speaking,” Mass said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

AAUP claims academic freedom — while blocking it?

The AAUP’s letter to President Robert Jones, Provost Tricia Serio, and Jackson School of International Studies Director Katharine Hoffman cited the principle that faculty have the right to “examine and communicate ideas by any lawful means even should such activities generate hostility.” Mass said that principle does not apply equally on the group’s own platform.

“There’s a great irony here that they only want to hear one viewpoint, and they may talk about freedom of speech, but they don’t practice it themselves. They will censor people that have different viewpoints than their own,” Mass explained.

ADVERTISEMENT

The AAUP faculty listserv reaches scores of UW faculty members and administrators. Mass said the scale makes the selective moderation worse, not better.

“There’s this listserv, and you can submit something to them, but they have some of their higher ups in the AAUP, they censor them,” Mass said. “Before something goes out, they have to read it and approve it. This will basically distribute to all the people who are on that listserv. Here at the University of Washington, we’re talking about thousands. Thousands of people, from faculty to administrators, are on this listserv. So the idea is, you send a message to them and you want to provide this viewpoint and you’d like to see it distributed. Well, they won’t [always] distribute messages that are different from their own viewpoint. So people get this skewed view, and it’s skewed extremely left — very much anti-Israel and anti-Trump. If you’re on this listserv, you may think you’re getting a variety of viewpoints, but you’re not, because they’re censoring it.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Mass says it happened to him personally

Mass has firsthand experience with the process, he said. After submitting a critical piece on DEI hiring requirements, a moderator blocked it, then offered a conditional path to publication that made the ideological gatekeeping explicit.

“They’ve done this to me,” Mass said. “I sent them a message and they said, ‘Well, if you make this change and this change, take this out, we might approve it.’ It’s pretty strange that something like this is happening at a university. We’re supposed to hear a variety of viewpoints.”

He is not the only faculty member who has faced it. Mass documented on his blog that a moderator rejected one of his submissions with a frank explanation of why. “Our concerns remain about giving so much air time to those who seem to be hostile to the university’s attempts to amplify diversity, equity, and inclusion,” the moderator wrote. Mass confirmed the exchange on the show, adding that the censorship goes well beyond any single topic.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s not just about Israel,” Mass noted. “They’ll censor things that are against their viewpoints that are tending to skew pretty far left.”

What Fani actually wrote — and why UW pulled his listserv access

As previously reported, Fani sent two mass emails to the Middle East Center listserv in March — the first on March 9 titled “US-Israeli War on Iran” and a follow-up on March 18 he called “More Notes on Iran War.”

In those messages, Fani dismissed Iran’s nuclear threat as “always BS,” described Zionism as “cancerous, a potentially fatal outgrowth in our planetary body,” and accused national security experts of lying “with discipline and conviction for years.” He warned readers in the opening of his second email that “given that this war shows no signs of stopping, you will continue to hear from me.”

ADVERTISEMENT

After that message went out, the listserv was placed under moderation and Fani lost the ability to send through it.

UW confirmed the removal. AAUP wants answers. Neither has responded publicly.

UW confirmed the removal but declined to discuss personnel specifics. President Jones was described in a university statement as having had “no role in, or knowledge of, the end of this administrative appointment.” Fani told KIRO Newsradio that he was fired for “improper use of the listserv” after sending “two memos about this atrocious war on Iran in which I offered historical analysis that’s lacking in the media.” He retains his position as an associate professor.

The nine-member AAUP executive board’s letter asked UW what specific policies Fani’s emails allegedly violated, whether faculty are barred from sharing their own views on controversial topics, and what steps the university intends to take to remedy what the board characterized as a violation.

ADVERTISEMENT

UW has not publicly responded. And the AAUP, which had no trouble demanding answers on behalf of a professor who used a university platform to circulate Iranian regime talking points, apparently had no trouble quietly blocking a respected scientist from distributing an opposing view on its own.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

0 Comments