ADVERTISEMENT

EDUCATION

Everett school board faces lawsuit threat over rules restricting LifeWise religious program

Everett School Board faces First Amendment lawsuit for imposing burdensome rules targeting a popular off-campus Bible class.

Everett board violates First Amendment religious freedom. (Everett School District)...

Everett board violates First Amendment religious freedom. (Everett School District)

(Everett School District)

The Everett School District is facing a legal threat from two major law firms that claim the school board created new rules designed to shut down a popular, off-campus religious class called LifeWise Academy. The law firms argue these rules illegally violate the First Amendment by unfairly targeting a religious group.

First Liberty Institute and the law firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner LLP sent a formal letter to the school board, calling the rules extremely harsh and warning that they impose unfair standards that will certainly lead to expensive court battles if not fixed.

The firms have set a deadline for the board to change the regulations by December 5.

Unfair rules trigger legal challenge

LifeWise Academy teaches Bible education to students from Emerson Elementary during their lunch and recess breaks, following established “released time” religious laws that the Supreme Court has allowed since 1952 in Zorach v. Clauson. Although 54 families currently participate, the school board passed new rules that apply only to LifeWise.

The new rules include banning LifeWise from taking part in community events or displaying informational flyers, and also forcing students to keep any LifeWise materials hidden in a sealed envelope in their backpacks. Additionally, the regulations require parents to submit a complicated permission slip every single week for their child to attend.

The law firms argue these onerous rules prove the board was motivated by hostility toward the religious program.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The Constitution does not permit this sort of targeted animus toward religion,” the attorneys stated, warning that the district’s actions could lead to “costly and protracted litigation.”

Targeting religious families

The legal letter highlighted hostile comments made by a board director as evidence of this bias.

Board Director Charles Adkins falsely and offensively accused LifeWise of trying to “bring white supremacy and Christian nationalism to our schools” and stated that the program “cannot be allowed to have access to our kids.”

Barbara Smith Tyson, Partner at Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner LLP, said, “The school’s targeting of LifeWise for offering off-campus religious instruction to families who want it hurts those students and their families and offends our most basic constitutional freedoms.”

Jeremy Dys, Senior Counsel at First Liberty Institute, added, “Purposefully hindering the operation of an out-of-school program just because it’s religious is a direct violation of the First Amendment.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Deadline to avoid a lawsuit

The school board’s attempt to regulate LifeWise goes against Supreme Court precedent. The 1952 case Zorach v. Clauson ruled that teaching the Bible during the public school day is legal in all 50 states, as long as the program is held off campus, uses no government funds, and requires parental permission. LifeWise Academy meets all these conditions.

Joel Penton, CEO of LifeWise Academy, noted how valuable the program is.

“We’re excited about the opportunity to welcome new families to LifeWise so that their children may experience the benefits of Bible-based character education.”

The district must change the challenged rules by December 5 to avoid facing a lawsuit.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jasneet Gill Content Editor

Jasneet Gill is a content editor and writer for Seattle Red. She is a Washington native, born and raised in the state, and a graduate of the University of Washington with a bachelor's degree in Communications. Her passion for soccer led her to play… Read more

Comments

2 Comments

E
Eris Cross 12 months ago

Before school. This is "During School Hours". It is off property, with badly background checked individuals on unregulated equipment and parents are duped on what they teach which is Christian Nationalist orthodox and inerrant beliefs that contradict science and often teach racism and antisemitism. Parents should be fully aware of this growing cancer stealing resources and money from this area and sending it back to Ohio to be used for fancy SUVs and 8 million dollar buildings.

B
Big Dog 12 months ago

When I taught high school back in the early 70's, there was a lovely older teacher that had Bible Study before school on certain days and anyone was invited. What's wrong with that? Using too much of the heathen's electricity? This is ridiculous and the School Board should keep their eye on "educating" the students. Wonder how Everett's scores compare to the rest of the State. If they are good, keep your eye on that function. If they are bad, get focused on teaching the kids. Director Adkins is spouting the WOKE line about "White Supremacy and Christian Nationalism". I would suggest a primary challenge for this fellow, let's get him out. A little God in the schools might just help save this nation. The WOKE business certainly won't.