ADVERTISEMENT

ECONOMY

Finance exec’s viral LinkedIn post exposes fatal flaw in Democrats’ millionaire tax math

A WA finance exec went viral on LinkedIn warning: if just 1 in 6 millionaires leave, Democrats' new income tax loses money fast. The math doesn't lie.

Washington state Democrats in legislative session during SB 6346 millionaire tax debate in Olympia...

Washington Democrats scaled back their estate tax while advancing SB 6346, a 9.9% income tax on millionaires, as high earners across the state weigh relocating. (TVW)

(TVW)

A Washington finance executive with deep roots in the state is going viral on LinkedIn for laying out exactly why Democrats in Olympia may have just made a catastrophic budget miscalculation with their new “millionaire tax.”

Adam Wright, Vice President of Finance and Accounting at Pacific Rim Land, Inc., posted an extensive breakdown of Senate Bill 6346, Democrats’ unconstitutional 9.9% income tax on income over $1 million, last week that has been circulating widely in Washington business and finance circles. His argument is not ideological chest-thumping. It is straight math, and the numbers do not flatter the Democrats and their talking points.

The entire revenue projection for SB 6346 rests on one assumption that Wright says is already falling apart in real time.

The 1-in-6 tipping point that blows up Washington’s millionaire tax math

Wright identified a structural flaw at the core of the legislation in plain terms.

“This ‘millionaire tax’ (SB 6346) is a huge mistake. It relies on a very small group (about 20-30K households who already pay roughly a third of all state taxes) staying put. That’s the assumption everything hinges on. If roughly 1 in 6 affected households leave, the tax goes underwater. If more than that leave, the state starts losing money, fast,” he said on LinkedIn.

Even stripping away the most pessimistic projections, the upside case is unimpressive.

“Even in the best-case scenario, if no one leaves, which just isn’t realistic, the upside is only a small percentage of the state spending, which has more than doubled in just 10 years,” Wright wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

Washington’s overall spending trajectory makes that caveat even more damning. The state has been on a fiscal bender for a decade, and the revenue this tax is supposed to generate barely puts a dent in the gap.

Wright says the exodus is already underway

Wright is not running abstract projections. He is reporting what he is hearing firsthand from the people most likely to trigger that 1-in-6 threshold.

“I’ve talked with a lot of friends and colleagues recently and I’m feeling quite confident that the rate of people leaving, or who have already left, is going to be larger than 1 in 6,” Wright explained.

The CEO of Moment, a camera equipment store based in Seattle, left the state and is bringing the company with him. The CIO and principal of Bulwark Capital Management announced the same. Even a former Washington state lawmaker is calling it quits on the state, while Starbucks founder Howard Schultz packed up for Florida.

ADVERTISEMENT

“When high earners leave, they don’t just take tax revenue, they take businesses, jobs, and investment with them,” Wright wrote. “That affects everyone.”

A generational wound dressed up as fiscal policy

Wright saved his most significant warning for the long-term consequences, particularly if Washington’s courts let the law stand despite serious constitutional questions.

“This tax violates the state constitution, but if upheld by an activist court, it will hurt Washington’s competitiveness for generations,” Wright wrote. “This risks becoming an ultimate policy ‘own goal’.”

The logic is one Washington Democrats have refused to seriously engage with. High earners are mobile. Nevada, Texas, and Florida have no income tax and are actively marketing themselves to exactly the people Olympia is trying to squeeze.

“I feel that we’re not fully grappling with how permanently damaging this could be,” Wright wrote. “Policies like this don’t just create short-term impacts — they shape where people choose to live and build for decades.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Governor Bob Ferguson is signing the income tax on Monday morning.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

4 Comments

W
WP Taylor 8 months ago

The whole reason for the "millionaire tax" bill was to get the bill on the books, get the Washington Supremes to weasel word around the state constitution and declare it constitutional. Most people earning less won't pay attention - until after the legislature drops the lower limit entirely as a last-second rider on some future bill in the next legislative session. There are a lot of people who can't move out, they become the serfs.

B
Big Dog 8 months ago

You might be right, George. We may not be giving the Democrats the credit for “saying” it’s only on millionaires. The court might say “spread it equally on all taxpayers” and it is finished, done, we’ll all get to pay it just for 2026, then we’ll all leave.

G
George Payne 8 months ago

Could it be the Democrats knew this all along and are using the Millionaire Ruse to justify inclusion of all taxpayers?