Washington cracks religious liberty top 10, but only scores 60%
Washington placed 10th in the Religious Liberty in the States 2026 report, yet its 60% score shows the ranking flatters a state still short on protections.
Washington placed 10th in Religious Liberty in the States 2026 with a 60 percent score, ahead of a weak national field but behind eighth-place Idaho, while Oregon ranked 39th. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
(Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Washington cracked the top 10 in a new national ranking of religious liberty protections, and that is about the most flattering thing anyone can say about it. The state placed 10th in Religious Liberty in the States 2026, the annual index published by First Liberty Institute’s Center for Religion, Culture & Democracy, with a score of 60 percent. Tenth sounds respectable until you look at what the number measures.
The report, written by scholars Mark David Hall and Paul D. Mueller, grades all 50 states on 20 safeguards drawn from 50 specific legal protections covering health care, education, economic life, and worship. A state’s score is the share of those possible protections it has adopted. Washington’s 60 percent means the state has left roughly 40 percent of the protections the study measures unadopted. Idaho finished two spots higher at 64.2 percent. Oregon came in near the bottom at 34.2 percent, 39th out of 50.
The rankings reward states relative to one another, and the national bar is low. Washington’s own recent run-ins with religious objectors, from the Christian flight attendants Alaska Airlines fired after they questioned the Equality Act to the religious foster family the state stripped of its license over a pronoun mandate, suggest the ranking outpaces the record. A top 10 finish here deserves an asterisk.
Washington’s top 10 finish comes on a curve
The report concedes that placement flatters states more than their raw numbers do.
“Although we focus primarily on how the states rank relative to each other, that’s a measure that by definition very few states can win. So, we also think states should be recognized for their absolute score and not just their relative one. But as you can see in figure 1 (page 4), in absolute terms there is significant room for improvement, with half the states having less than 40 percent of the religious liberty safeguards we measure,” the authors write.
Only two states, Arkansas and Tennessee, cleared 80 percent to earn the report’s “excellent” rating. Washington sits in the “competent” band, which runs from 55 to 79 percent. It ranks 10th mainly because 34 states are doing less than half of what they could be doing, which makes 60 percent look strong in a weak field.
That distance between reputation and reality is why the absolute score matters more than the ranking. The state even tried to force priests to break the seal of confession under a law Gov. Bob Ferguson signed, a fight that earned a lawsuit from the Archdiocese of Seattle. Clergy-penitent privilege is one of the safeguards the report measures, and it is exactly the kind of protection the score is meant to capture.
Idaho climbs on a medical conscience law
Idaho’s rise to eighth shows how one statute can move a state.
The report ranks a general medical conscience law as one of the most substantive protections it measures, second only to a Religious Freedom Restoration Act, because it shields a wide range of people and institutions from being forced into procedures they object to. Idaho passed that kind of law, and the authors credit it for the state’s improvement. Tennessee ran the same play with even bigger results.
“By adopting an excellent medical conscience law, Tennessee has catapulted from tenth to second place in our rankings, and it now protects 85 percent of the items we consider,” the report notes.
Oregon sits near the bottom
Oregon’s numbers are near the bottom.
At 34.2 percent it ranks 39th and falls into the “poor” category the report assigns to any state under 40 percent. The study uses the Sweet Cakes by Melissa case to show what a thin legal shield looks like in practice.
“Aaron and Melissa Klein, owners of the Sweet Cakes by Melissa bakery, would sell baked goods to anyone, but because of their Christian convictions they declined to design and create a custom cake to celebrate a same-sex wedding. The State of Oregon responded by punishing them with a $135,000 penalty and issuing a gag order against them,” the report recounts. The authors argue the outcome would look different under stronger law. “If Oregon had a law like the Arkansas statute discussed above, the Kleins would be protected from such litigation,” they write.
The full data is available at religiouslibertyinthestates.com.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments