‘There really is a crisis’: Foster couple punished for their faith beats Washington state in court
Washington's DCYF dropped its foster pronoun mandate and restored the DeGross family's full license after a Biden-appointed judge let their suit proceed.
Shane and Jennifer DeGross of Port Orchard fostered children in Washington for nine years before DCYF pulled their license in 2022 over a pronoun mandate. The state has now scrapped the rule, restored their full license, and paid $250,000 in attorneys' fees. (Alliance Defending Freedom)
(Alliance Defending Freedom)
Shane and Jennifer DeGross spent nine years fostering children in their home, earning a record that Washington’s Department of Children, Youth, and Families (DCYF) described as exemplary. Then in 2022, the agency pulled their license over a reason that had nothing to do with neglect or abuse. DCYF demanded that the couple use chosen pronouns for children in their care, take them to pride parades, and facilitate gender-related medical appointments.
The DeGrosses, who are devout Christians, refused.
After the refusal, the state offered what it framed as a compromise. The DeGrosses could foster only children five and under, the adoptive component of their license would be stripped out, and they would still have to stay silent about their religious convictions. They refused that, too, sued with help from Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), and won. Last month, the state agreed to a permanent injunction, scrapped the pronoun rule entirely, restored the couple’s full license, and paid $250,000 in attorneys’ fees.
What DCYF asked the DeGrosses to do
Jennifer DeGross described the demands the state placed on the couple during their 2022 relicensing.
“We were in the process of relicensing in 2022 and we were willing to, love and care for any child in our home, but they were asking us to use preferred pronouns of children in our home to take them to pride parades, to be willing to take them to medical appointments regarding their gender, and those were just things that we could not agree to,” Jennifer said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.
Shane DeGross said the message from the state was that Christian families like theirs were no longer welcome in the system in any meaningful capacity. Other foster families with religious objections faced the same exclusion. DCYF, an agency that has drawn fire for an audit revealing $2 million in overpayments out of a $10 million sample, had effectively decided ideology mattered more than its own bed counts.
“It was heart-rending, because there are so many children in the state of Washington that need a stable home to be in. There really is a crisis of families that are, you know, available to care for these children. Then there are so many children in the program, in the foster care system, you know, sometimes they’re sleeping in hotels or on the floor of staff or in cars, and so to see families weeded out of the system because they don’t accept the state’s gender ideology is heart rending,” Shane noted.
The case the state did not want to lose
Hal Frampton, senior counsel at ADF and director of its Center for Conscience Initiatives, said the pronoun rule ran headlong into existing Ninth Circuit precedent. ADF had already won a nearly identical fight in Oregon in Bates v. Pakseresht. The DeGross lawsuit then drew a Biden-appointed federal judge who let the case move forward and signaled in his order that the state’s policy had constitutional problems.
“Well, I think Washington recognized when that ruling came out that they were just plain on the wrong side of the Constitution on this, and that any honest judge in America would see that. And so we were very pleased when the judge allowed the case to go forward, and even more pleased when Washington realized that they ought to come to the table and dispense with their unconstitutional policy, and put the De Grasses back in the position they should have been all along, fully licensed and able to foster and adopt a needy child,” Frampton told Rantz.
Frampton added that Washington’s surrender did not come out of any change of heart. It came after the math stopped working in court.
“There’s already a precedent on the record in the Ninth Circuit, which is very helpful. Bates case, that was one of ours in Oregon, and my sense is that Washington realized between that case, between the judge allowing this case to go forward and saying some very helpful things in his order about the constitutional problems with their policy, that the writing was on the wall here,” he continued.
What the consent order actually protects
Critics have worried that DCYF could rewrite its regulations with friendlier-sounding language and pick another fight. Frampton said the consent order’s text is built to prevent exactly that.
“What helps with that is there is actually a provision in the consent order that Washington agreed to, and that the court entered, that specifically says they are not permitted to deny a license, stop renewal, or attach conditions or restrictions onto a license because of a family’s religious beliefs, including speech and actions pertaining to marriage, gender, or sexuality, and so we, we think that language is broad enough to stop these unconstitutional practices, no matter how they rewrite the regulations,” Frampton said.
A pattern from DCYF
This is the second time DCYF has been forced to settle a federal religious discrimination lawsuit, following the first settlement that Seattle Red previously covered over the same pronoun policy. Gov. Bob Ferguson defended those exact gender identity requirements last year when a federal official challenged them as a likely First Amendment violation.
For the DeGrosses, the fight was always about the kids the state was leaving without homes. Jennifer said the family would treat any child placed with them, including one struggling with gender dysphoria, the same way they would treat any foster child in their care.
“I mean, like any, any child in our home, we would love them, we would care for them, we would have conversations with them that are open and honest, and help them know that they are in a very safe place where they are loved, and that this is their family,” she added.
Their license is now fully restored. They are once again eligible to foster and to adopt children of any age. DCYF’s pronoun rule, under the state’s own settlement terms, is gone.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
Victory for Constitutional rights! I completely disagree with their nonsense religious beliefs, but the state has to make a VERY compelling, narrowly tailored argument to restrict that constitutional right and a mandatory gender affirming environment ain't gonna cut it (obviously).