ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Rep. Matt Marshall warns I-638 will fail in court like I-2066, I-976 and I-1366 on a $150,000 budget

Nick Brown's I-638 contract caps the defense at $150,000, about 181 hours at the lead lawyer's rate. Matt Marshall says it's a 0% chance that's enough.

Attorney General Nick Brown's contract with Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner caps the Initiative 638 def...

Attorney General Nick Brown's contract with Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner caps the Initiative 638 defense at $150,000. (Photo courtesy of Brandi Kruse)

(Photo courtesy of Brandi Kruse)

Attorney General Nick Brown capped the state’s defense of Initiative 638 at $150,000. If the lead attorney billed every hour, that buys about 181 hours against three legal teams trying to kill Washington’s girls’ sports law.

The Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner contract was signed November 10 and expires June 30, 2027. Four of the firm’s attorneys bill between $610 and $950 an hour, and the lead bills $828. On the other side, Legal Voice, the ACLU of Washington and Pacifica Law Group, where Brown was a partner, represent the Washington Education Association and parents suing to block I-638 before it takes effect December 3.

State Representative Matt Marshall, R-Eatonville, says the money is gone before the case reaches an appeals court.

“Oh, it’s way too little. That might handle the you know initial filings and the and the trial court level, but it’s not going to handle it when it starts climbing through the appellate courts, state supreme court, potentially into federal courts under Title IX, there’s 0% that’s a 0% chance that’s enough money, but you know it’s kind of par for the course. You know they’re going to give a weak defense, and it’ll turn out very much like I-2066 with natural gas, where where you know in the end it fails,” Marshall said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

Three initiatives Washington voters already lost

Marshall named three initiatives voters passed but then lost in the courts.

A King County judge threw out I-2066, the 2024 natural gas initiative, in March 2025, and the state Supreme Court affirmed it 6-3 this September. The court unanimously voided I-976, the $30 car tab measure, in 2020 and I-1366, a 2015 tax initiative, in 2016. All three were struck down under the state constitution’s single-subject rule.

ADVERTISEMENT

Brown has defended the firm to defend the initiative.

“The firm’s attorneys have handled many important cases on behalf of the state previously,” he said in his announcement.

Marshall isn’t buying it.

“So, like many of the other initiatives we’ve seen passed by the people in Washington, if the executive branch has a disagreement with the law that the people have passed, they seem to fumble the football and fail to defend it vigorously, like the law tells them they have to,” he said.

Female Athletes United, represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, has asked a King County Superior Court judge to let it join the defense. A judge has not ruled.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

0 Comments