Rantz: Seattle Times reporters say trans athletes have no edge, but studies on grip strength, muscle and speed say otherwise
The Seattle Times claimed there’s ‘no serious scientific evidence’ trans women have an athletic edge. Jason Rantz walks through the studies the paper ignored.
The Seattle Times claimed there is no serious scientific evidence that transgender women have an athletic advantage. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
The Seattle Times told readers that there is “no serious scientific evidence” that transgender girls or women are better athletes than girls or women. The claim is verifiably, and very obviously, false.
Reporters Daniel Beekman and Ryan Nguyen made the declaration in a November 8 analysis of how Washington voted on girls’ sports. The goal was to help console their far-left readers and play into their white knight attitudes. Last week, more than 1.25 million Washingtonians passed Initiative 638 with 56.6% of the vote. Midway through a discussion of parents’ fairness concerns, the two reporters added this laughable claim.
“There is no serious scientific evidence that trans girls or women are better athletes than cisgender girls or women. A few transgender girls have won at the high school level, but across the U.S., just a few trans women have competed at elite college or professional levels, and none have dominated their sport,” they wrote.
Nobody is quoted there; that’s Beekman and Nguyen talking. The passage names no study and offers no definition of “serious.” It never separates athletes who went through male puberty from those who didn’t, or athletes taking hormones from athletes taking nothing. Those distinctions drive this entire body of research. So does the difference between an advantage and a guaranteed win. Erase them and you get a campaign talking point dressed up as fact.
The paper has done this before. In October, the Seattle Times quoted three left-wing physicians critical of I-638, including one who falsely claimed no research shows a male athletic edge. Now the reporters skipped the doctor and said it themselves.
The gap starts with male puberty
The American College of Sports Medicine’s 2023 consensus statement says males typically outperform females by 10% to 30% in events relying on endurance, strength, speed and power, depending on the event. It ties the major differences to puberty and the rise in male testosterone.
That figure compares men and women generally. It is not an estimate of what a transgender woman keeps after treatment, and reporters should say so. They should also explain why the starting point matters.
A 2018 paper in Endocrine Reviews lays out testosterone’s link to muscle mass, strength and circulating hemoglobin, the protein that carries oxygen in the blood. Those mechanisms are a big part of why separate male and female categories exist in the first place.
Suppressing testosterone changes some of that. The real questions are how much changes, how fast, and whether the change erases differences that matter in a given event.
A year of hormones barely moved grip strength
In a 2019 multicenter prospective study, Miranda Scharff and colleagues measured grip strength in 249 transgender women and 278 transgender men, once before hormone treatment and again after a year.
Grip strength in the transgender women fell by an average of 1.8 kilograms. The 95% confidence interval put the drop between 1 and 2.6 kilograms, and from a baseline of about 41.8 kilograms, that’s a decline of roughly 4.3%. That’s measurable, and modest. The authors found no difference in strength change by age group, BMI group, how hormones were administered or hormone concentrations.
This was a clinical group, not elite competitors, and it measured change over time instead of comparing participants with female athletes. It can’t tell you what a particular tennis player retains.
Muscle shrank, and strength mostly held
A 2020 study led by Anna Wiik followed 11 untrained transgender women and 12 untrained transgender men. Researchers tested knee extension and knee flexion strength and used MRI and CT scans to measure muscle size and composition, before treatment, after initial hormone suppression and through the following year.
In the transgender women, thigh muscle volume dropped about 5%. Quadriceps cross-sectional area fell about 4%. Strength was generally maintained.
Muscle size and force production are related, but they aren’t interchangeable. Losing 5% of thigh volume doesn’t mean losing 5% of strength, and it certainly doesn’t prove equality with female athletes.
A longer follow-up in the Journal of Internal Medicine, first released online in November 2024, tracked 16 transgender women and 17 transgender men at baseline, one year and roughly five to six years. Among the transgender women, thigh fat-free muscle volume fell about 7% after five years. Mean knee extension strength was 238 newton-meters at baseline, 247 after one year and 220 at five years. The statistical model found no significant treatment-related change in strength.
Blood changed in months, muscle took years
A 2021 systematic review by Joanna Harper and colleagues, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, examined 24 studies on hormone treatment, lean body mass, muscle area, strength and blood measures.
Hemoglobin and hematocrit reached female reference levels after about four months. Muscle changed far more slowly. Strength, lean body mass and muscle area all declined with treatment but remained above female comparisons even after 36 months.
Blood oxygen capacity and muscle don’t change on the same schedule, either. Treating testosterone suppression as one switch that settles every sporting question is scientifically crude, but it’s exactly what the Seattle Times did.
The Air Force measured actual performance
A study by Timothy Roberts and colleagues, published in 2020, pulled U.S. Air Force fitness records for 46 transgender women and 29 transgender men before and after hormone treatment.
Before treatment, the transgender women did 31% more push-ups and 15% more sit-ups than the female average and finished the 1.5-mile test 21% faster. After one year, the suppression window World Athletics recommended at the time, they were still 9% faster. After two years, the push-up and sit-up gaps disappeared, but a 12% speed advantage remained.
The later evidence complicates things, and it’s worth reporting honestly. A review in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism describes an expanded Air Force analysis of 228 transgender women. A push-up advantage persisted at four years, while sit-up differences were gone by then.
Same testosterone, stronger grip
A 2024 study by Blair Hamilton and colleagues tested athletes who participate in sport, including 23 transgender women, 21 women, 19 men and 12 transgender men.
The transgender women averaged 0.7 nanomoles per liter of testosterone, compared with 0.9 for the women. Their absolute grip strength still averaged 40.7 kilograms against 34.2, about 19% higher, and the difference was statistically significant.
Other results went the opposite direction. The transgender women had lower oxygen consumption relative to body mass, 45.1 versus 54.1 milliliters per kilogram per minute, and performed worse on relative jump height. The grip gap disappeared after adjusting for hand size or fat-free mass. The authors concluded their results should caution against “precautionary bans” not based on sport-specific research.
Fair enough. The study also has limits. But what it shows is that matching testosterone levels and matching physical performance are two separate claims.
The studies that cut the other way
Not all of the research points one direction. I won’t pretend otherwise. A 2025 study of nine transgender athletes competing in footraces, plus one swimmer, used verified race results and an additional year of follow-up.
Their race times slowed 14.6% on average after a mean of 31 months on hormones. Their age-graded standing didn’t change significantly when they moved from male comparisons before treatment to female comparisons afterward, even after adjusting for changes in training. The swimmer slowed about 5.2% but became more competitive under the female scoring system. One swimmer proves nothing about a population. And in Washington state, we’re talking about teen athletes who haven’t undergone 31 months on hormones. They’re biological boys competing against girls.
An October 2026 meta-analysis of laboratory performance included 14 studies and 259 transgender women who had been on hormones for at least 12 months. It found significantly higher absolute peak oxygen consumption and absolute handgrip strength than in female comparison groups, but lower oxygen consumption relative to body mass. Knee extension torque and several power measures showed no significant difference. The authors read the limited evidence as suggesting performance is closer to women’s than men’s, while calling for better data.
Closer to women than to men is still not the same as no advantage inside the girls’ category.
Trophy counts are not a lab test
After dismissing the evidence, Beekman and Nguyen pivot to the fact that transgender women haven’t dominated their sports. They offer no definition of dominance and no participation data.
Penn’s official biography of Lia Thomas records her 2022 NCAA Division I title in the women’s 500-yard freestyle, a fifth-place finish in the 200 freestyle and an eighth in the 100 freestyle. That’s elite success without a sweep. Losing two events doesn’t show she had no advantage in any of them. And every spot Thompson took was a spot a biological female athlete did not.
An advantage shifts the odds; it doesn’t erase talent, training, technique or the competition. Without knowing how many athletes compete, who is eligible and how they actually perform, a medal count can’t answer a biological question.
And high school sports aren’t the NCAA. The stakes are roster spots, qualifying places and medals far below the professional level. When Holly Burns and 12 of her Camas High School teammates walked off a cross-country course in October, nobody was competing for an Olympic team. A varsity spot matters to the girl trying to earn it.
What readers were owed
Adult treatment studies don’t automatically apply to children. A kid whose male puberty was blocked isn’t interchangeable with someone who completed it. Timing, duration, training, age and event all matter. And research on years of testosterone suppression can’t be used to claim that identifying as female, with no treatment at all, removes a performance difference. That’s relevant to I-638, which covers K-12 sports and doesn’t hinge on anyone’s hormone regimen.
Science can’t settle every legal or ethical question about eligibility. It can inform those decisions. It can’t do that when journalists delete the inconvenient findings before readers ever see them. The fuller picture is that treatment reduces some characteristics, and studies find retained differences in others.
Beekman and Nguyen could have explained that. They could have discussed study quality, separated adults from children and shown where the evidence is still unresolved. Instead, they pretended it just doesn’t exist.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
5 Comments
the really sad part in all this is that those girls will never get this back they worked so hard go to one high school cross country practice some of the hardest work being done and will never get that back with there team life long memories stolen hard hours training stolen. I hate they had to throw away such hard work but learned something even more important stand up for yourself and fight for what you believe in the courage these young ladies will help fuel their next fight. hope they keep running! Keep FIGHTING
If gender is fluid, and it is transphobic to deny or dispute anyone their claim of gender, then why are far left zealots against ex-NBA players claiming to be transgender, become eligible for the WNBA draft?
Then the Seattle Times reporter is VERY BIASED in reporting and should not be writing any more for the Seattle Times and proof is provided over and over. It is well documented the physiology of a true male is superior, period. This does not create a negative for females, it just states a FACT and no matter what a BIASED reporter writes, it CANNOT CHANGE BIOLOGY.