UW scientist Cliff Mass shreds Seattle Times Skagit flood story, says it skipped the one dataset that mattered
UW’s Cliff Mass says the Seattle Times Climate Lab’s Skagit River flood warning ignored the federal gauge data showing peak flows trending slightly down.
UW professor Cliff Mass says a Seattle Times Climate Lab story on Skagit River flooding ignored federal flow data. (Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
(Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
University of Washington atmospheric sciences professor Cliff Mass says a new Seattle Times Climate Lab story warning of worsening Skagit River floods skipped the river’s actual flow records and relied on a climate scenario most researchers have abandoned. He says the data actually shows yearly peak flows on the Skagit trending slightly down.
The October 6 story, written by Isabella Breda and Fiona Martin, covered new flood maps from a project led by the Swinomish Indian Tribal Community with partners including the University of Washington Climate Impacts Group. Its headline projection held that today’s 100-year flood could hit four to five times as often by the 2040s because of climate change. The Climate Lab is bankrolled in part by the Bullitt Foundation and a roster of private donors, though the paper insists it keeps editorial control.
Mass, who picked the story apart on his blog, says the trouble starts with the data.
The gauges tell a different story
Mass said any serious look at flood risk should begin with how the river has actually behaved.
“Well, the first thing you would do is check observations. I mean, they keep on claiming we’ve had all this climate change going on, so certainly we’d expect the rivers to be going up, the peak flows to be going up precipitously because of climate change. Well, I took a look at the numbers, and if you look at the peak flows each year on the Skagit River, Newhalem or Concrete, it’s actually going slightly down,” Mass said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.
“And actually, it’s much less than it was earlier in the century. So there’s no indication, with all the global warming they’re talking about, that there’s been some big increase in peak flows. It’s just not observed,” he added.
The projections fare no better in his view.
“Well, the study that they’re basing everything on made a very central mistake. They used this aggressive scenario, 8.5, which everybody’s thrown away. So they use that and plus a more moderate one, and they averaged them,” Mass argued.
He said the 8.5 scenario has been dropped by virtually every major climate research group as unrealistic, and that his high-resolution regional modeling, using more realistic assumptions, shows no comparable surge in precipitation over the next 40 years. He also faulted the story for ignoring levees, construction, and logging.
Donor money, one-way coverage
Mass questioned how a donor-funded climate desk can claim its backers have no influence.
“It’s really problematic to have journalism that are supported by special interests, and you know they may claim that it has no impact, but anybody who knows the science can see that there is a substantial skewing of their reporting and their angles of attack on these stories that are very biased towards this excessive view that global warming from greenhouse gasses is causing a profound change in the climate around here, and it’s simply not true,” he said.
He noted the Climate Lab has never responded to his past critiques or corrected the stories he flagged.
Mass pointed to a recent Seattle Times story on one of the region’s coldest Septembers on record. Written by a business reporter, it never mentioned climate change.
“It’s only bias when it’s hot. If it’s above normal, then it’s climate change. Below normal, it’s not mentioned. I mean, that’s really problematic,” Mass said.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
3 Comments
Mr. Cliff Mass is the only truth speaker on the weather, past, present and future!
far lefties are gullible. Their hero is Neville Chamberlain
So...how is this rationalized with the report that warns of higher water costs due to lack of same?