ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE RED OPINION

Jim Walsh: WA law is full of bad faith and the income tax is no exception

WA Democrats often use bad faith to achieve their legislative aims and they're doing it again with the income tax, writes state Rep. and GOP Chair Jim Walsh.

Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson after a press conference about state tax policy....

Washington faces a projected $4 billion shortfall in the first year of the next budget after the November 16 revenue forecast. (Governor Bob Ferguson/Facebook)

(Governor Bob Ferguson/Facebook)

Bad faith.

In business and legal contexts, “bad faith” means entering an agreement intending not to honor its terms. This is more than just lying. Here’s a textbook legal definition of bad faith: “the fraudulent deception of another person or the intentional or malicious refusal to perform some duty or contractual obligation.”

“Bad faith” has become a big issue in Olympia right now. It’s worth the attention of every Washington taxpayer and voter. Bad faith doesn’t apply to an honest mistake about rights or duties in an agreement. It applies when someone’s rights are maliciously undermined. In other words, it occurs when someone enters into an agreement with the intention of not fulfilling its terms or knowingly misrepresents the quality of goods or services provided.

Bad faith is a tool of WA Democrats

In Washington state, contract law handles bad faith primarily through an “implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing,” which is presumed automatically to be part of every valid contract or agreement. RCW 48.01.030 describes certain contracts in Washington as: “requiring that all persons…abstain from deception, and practice honesty and equity….”

State officials in Washington—and, especially, current governor Bob Ferguson—have long relied on liberal use of “bad faith” law.

Early in his tenure as Attorney General, Ferguson championed the state’s Patent Troll Prevention Act which targeted “lawsuit mill” firms that made bad faith patent infringement claims against Washington companies.

In 2019, during his long-running campaign finance litigation against conservative activist Tim Eyman, AG Ferguson successfully argued to a bankruptcy judge that Eyman was using a bankruptcy filing as a “bad faith effort to delay our case” and avoid public accountability.

ADVERTISEMENT

Bob Ferguson has frequently been the subject of bad faith

But, when he became governor, Ferguson ended up on the other side of several high-profile bad faith lawsuits.

In 2025, Gov. Ferguson was forced to suspend an automated public records deletion policy at state agencies. This followed a lawsuit that the state lost involving the Department of Children, Youth, and Families (DCYF). The state agency had been accused of acting with “bad faith and gross incompetence” by deleting emails relevant to ongoing litigation.

In 2026, Ferguson faced allegations of bad faith from several state-employee labor unions. During contract negotiations and statewide walkouts over low wages and proposed employee furloughs, union representatives and state workers accused Ferguson of bad faith bargaining.

Having been on both sides of bad faith lawsuits, the current governor has no excuse to expose the state to the risk of more bad faith court judgments or damages. But some of his closest political allies seem oblivious to risks.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jamie Pedersen’s “pie crust promise”

In an infamous 2024 interview with KUOW Radio, State Senate Majority Leader (and close Ferguson ally) Jamie Pedersen called his fickle support for an initiative banning a state income tax “a pie-crust promise. Easily made, easily broken.”

While Pedersen may have been trying to sound clever and literary (he attributed his “pie crust promise” quote to the children’s book “Mary Poppins”), his words struck many reasonable Washingtonians as hypocritical and—to the point of this discussion—his disingenuous support of the initiative banning a state income tax as an example of bad faith legislation.

Pedersen had been accused of bad faith legislation before. In 2019, he sponsored a bill (SB 5784) that would have excluded legislative correspondence and documents from the state’s Public Records Act. The Spokane Spokesman-Review newspaper criticized the bill and Pedersen, writing: “The most significant part of this bad faith proposal is the many exceptions that lawmakers want to grant themselves.”

ADVERTISEMENT

That bill ultimately died in the legislature. Deservedly.

But Pedersen’s more recent state income tax scheme (SB 6346) did not die, even though it broke Pedersen’s “pie crust promise” and invited new allegations of bad faith. The income tax scheme passed the state legislature narrowly and was signed eagerly into law by Ferguson.

The income tax is full of bad faith

Although Ferguson and Pedersen both should know better, bad faith hangs over their state income tax scheme like a dark cloud.

Despite the “pie crust promise” Pedersen had made earlier about not supporting a state income tax, he worked closely—some say “colluded”—with the State AG’s office while Ferguson was still there on the language of the income tax scheme. Later, after Ferguson had been elected governor, Pedersen was still taking instructions from the AG’s office. Notoriously, the AG’s office staff told Pedersen to add a “necessity clause” to the scheme to prevent a people’s referendum to repeal it. And he did.

ADVERTISEMENT

The dark cloud of bad faith around the Ferguson-Pedersen state income tax scheme has gotten even darker recently.

A major talking point for Ferguson, Pedersen and the other shills for the scheme has been that it would only ever apply to “millionaires” and would never impact middle-class families or most Washingtonians. Those bad faith claims are already proving to be another “pie crust promise.”

Democrats are already trying to lower the income tax threshold

Democrat State Rep. Cindy Ryu, running for a State Senate seat, recently told KUOW Radio (maybe “pie crust” progressives should avoid interviews with that station) that WA Democrats plan to expand the state income tax scheme to households with an income of $250,000 a year. Her opponent, incumbent Democrat State Sen. Jesse Salomon, agrees that the threshold should be lower; he just disagrees on how much. In any event, both are contradicting the flimsy Party line that the tax will only be on “millionaires.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Separately, Democrat State Rep. April Berg, who chairs the House Finance Committee in Olympia, recently said on camera during a hearing that the Ferguson-Pedersen state income tax scheme is a “tax on everyone”—something Ferguson and Pedersen had been trying to deny. And Democrat lobbyist April Sims, a designated spokeswoman for the state income tax scheme, has echoed Berg’s statements. It is a tax on all Washington households.

These recent statements from Ryu, Salomon, Berg and Sims all make the Ferguson-Pedersen state income tax scheme appear to be bad faith legislation. That’s not good.

Vote YES on initiative IP26-645 to repeal the bad faith state income tax scheme.

Jim Walsh is a Republican state representative from Aberdeen who serves as chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, where he has focused on rebuilding party infrastructure, candidate recruitment, and grassroots engagement.

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

5 Comments

B
Blip Ferguson 1 month ago

"Bad Faith" could be another title for sideshow bobs autobiography

J
Johnny Ruger 1 month ago

TThe CcA is another bad faith law. Remember when Jay said it would only add 5 to 10 cents to a gallon of gas? When his own advisors were telling him more like 50 cents? It appears the voters didn't.

G
George Payne 1 month ago

The famous phrase “government of the people, by the people, for the people” comes from U.S. President Abraham Lincoln in his Gettysburg Address on November 19, 1863.

Washington State's government is becoming more and more at odds, outright conflict and defaulting to embattlement with the people. Our state's government has lost it's direction, blinded by individual and political greed for power.

It's past time for a reset. God help us.