Chris Cargill: Fact Check—Washington’s income tax initiative doesn’t “cut” government programs
Democrats and their media allies claim that voting for I-645 would make cuts to education and health care, but you can't cut money that hasn't been collected.
Washington faces a projected $4 billion shortfall in the first year of the next budget after the November 16 revenue forecast. (Governor Bob Ferguson/Facebook)
(Governor Bob Ferguson/Facebook)
Washington voters will decide this November whether to keep the state’s new 9.9% income tax.
Politicians and the media are claiming approval of Initiative 645 will “cut funding” for public schools, higher education and health care. There’s only one problem – it’s not true.
Why? Because there’s nothing to cut. Washington doesn’t collect a dime of income tax revenue until 2029. It’s not possible to cut something that doesn’t exist.
Despite this, Washington officials put their thumbs on the scale and included a ballot impact statement that misleads voters into thinking “cuts” are imminent. By doing so, they changed the potential outcome of the ballot measure by a whopping 18 points according to recent polling.
The media is pushing the Democrats’ narrative
Politicians and political activists working for or against ballot measures is not a surprise.
The media, however, is a different story. Too many are simply repeating the talking point.
The Spokesman-Review, for example, recently told readers that repealing Washington’s new income tax “would cut funding for K-12 education and healthcare, among other state services.”
Other media outlets are repeating the same thing. But you can’t cut money the government isn’t collecting.
What I-645 would do is eliminate a future tax and therefore reduce projected future revenue compared with the state’s current forecast. The Washington Research Council estimates the initiative would shave forecasted revenues by $3.108 billion in 2027–29 and $8.324 billion in 2029–31.
A forecast, however, is not a cut. And even if it were, I-645 doesn’t tell lawmakers to reduce K-12 spending, or health care spending, or any other spending.
Revenue from the income tax hasn’t even been allocated yet
Likewise, there’s no guarantee future income tax revenues would actually be spent on the programs activists now say are at risk. Journalists routinely scrutinize political claims, and this should be no different.
Rather than explaining that the state is talking about future projected revenue from a tax that hasn’t taken effect, news stories can leave readers with the impression that I-645 removes money already being spent. It doesn’t.
And the distinction is especially important because the state’s disclosure itself has been challenged in court. The Washington Supreme Court ultimately split 4-4 on an emergency request to keep the statement off the ballot, meaning the request failed and the disclosure remained. In other words, this isn’t some obscure semantic complaint that reporters have no reason to know about.
The bottom line is this: Washington is not currently collecting this income tax. No current programs depend on its revenue. And the initiative does not direct the legislature to cut spending. Voters deserve to know the truth.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
2 Comments
sideshow fergknob, sewer brown and limp as a noodle peterson never let facts get in the way
Now they're calling to lower the million to 200k
Our only choice is to move! Go-to-go is already another $300 to $400 a month. Property tax is at 9k up from 3k 12 years ago. Gas is astronomical with the taxes.