ADVERTISEMENT

MEDIA BIAS

Seattle TV station KOMO accused of propaganda after pushing the anti-I-645 talking point in a post about the repeal fight

KOMO News faces backlash after an X post pitched Washington's 9.9% income tax as a budget lifeline, echoing the No on 645 campaign's core talking point.

KOMO Plaza...

KOMO News is facing criticism over a social media post about Initiative 645, the measure to repeal Washington's income tax. (MyNorthwest)

(MyNorthwest)

KOMO News is taking a beating on X after the Seattle station pitched Washington’s new 9.9% income tax to its followers as a budget lifeline. The post repeated the main talking point of the campaign against Initiative 645 as if it were established fact.

The post promoted KOMO’s story on the dueling I-645 campaigns. A yes vote on I-645 repeals the tax Governor Bob Ferguson signed in March. A no vote keeps it. KOMO’s social team picked a side anyway, quoting word-for-word what appears in the Natalie Fahmy report.

“While fewer than 1% of Washingtonians will pay into the tax, it would earn the state an estimated $3.5 billion each year, which would help keep the state budget well-funded as Washington faces major money shortfalls,” KOMO wrote.

Sheriff Keith Swank chimed in with a question. “Have you reported this to the PDC?” he asked.

The tax does not apply until 2028, and the first payments are not due until 2029. The current budget does not depend on a penny of it, as Seattle Red has reported in debunking the No on 645 campaign’s $300 billion claim. Repeal would not pull a single dollar out of any classroom today.

Readers call KOMO tweet and report propaganda

The replies piled up fast and the tweet was ratio’ed.

“Total propaganda against the repeal by KOMO,” Dan Sivertson posted. “At some point KOMO you’re supposed to challenge the government’s lies, not shill for them,” Sivertson added.

ADVERTISEMENT

Kristen Mag noted: “This tax will inevitably apply to people earning less than a million too. It’s just a matter of time. And no, voters will NOT get a say. This tax was specifically written to allow for lowering the threshold with a majority vote from our government, not a vote from we the people.”

I-645 backer Steve Gordon tagged KOMO and Fahmy. He gave the station partial credit for improving its explanation before getting to the problem.

“It’s an income tax on all WA income, full stop. A separate section establishes a $1 million standard deduction. Can be reduced by leg,” Gordon countered.

What the story left out

The law backs Gordon up. Senate Democrats’ FAQ describes the law as a 9.9% tax on Washington taxable income, with the $1 million carved out as a standard deduction that applies per household. Two spouses earning $600,000 each share a single deduction.

ADVERTISEMENT

KOMO’s full web report gave the No on 645 campaign’s Rian Watt room to push the $13 billion figure without challenge.

“The bottom line is that if initiative 645 passes, there will be 13 billion dollars in cuts to K-12 education, childcare and healthcare in this state,” Watt said in KOMO’s story.

KOMO then offered voters a reassurance. “State leaders have said that it is not their intention to ever expand the tax,” the station reported, even as Democrats have gone on record saying they want to see just that.

The story did not mention that Democrats voted down a Republican amendment that would have written the millionaires-only promise into law. Lawmakers had the chance to lock in the $1 million threshold and passed on it. That leaves a future Legislature free to lower it with a simple majority.

Voters decide I-645 in the November 3 general election. A yes vote repeals the income tax.

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

4 Comments

D
D R 2 months ago

All of the Seattle news channels are corrupt and lean to the left. None will admit it of course but when you watch them all and how they carefully present news stories it becomes OBVIOUS fairly easily. It's not always what they say is wrong, it's how it is presented to the viewers with negative spin. They always look to Democrat Reps when asking " the tough questions " and hardly ever challenge anything Patty Murray, Pramilla Jayapal, or Ferguson tell them. They just nod their head and go ok.... It's also so laughable now the King5 has their Truth commercials trying to convince the watchers that they would never give you anything other than hand on the bible truth in reporting. It appears after this long they believe their own BS and feel they always control the narrative and that the people tuned in are gullible rubes that can't see the forest for trees.

N
Nolan Void 2 months ago

Oh come now, the main stream media would never lie to us, right?

Right??

S
Southern Roots 2 months ago

The absolute first issue is that this violates the Constitution and 90 years of court decisions about income being property. If they want to have an income tax, it must be the same for everyone. This bill singles out an income group and so it violates that. It's possible the court could see it that way and invalidate Sec. 314 leaving the income tax in place for all of us.

The second issue is that the people have voted repeatedly against imposition of an income tax with the most recent vote being the passage of I-2111 in 2024.

Democrats in the legislature don't care about representing their constituents

So many people don't ever read the actual bills.

This section is stand-alone. The million dollar exemption is not mentioned anywhere close to this section. It places a 9.9% income tax on EVERYONE.

NEW SECTION. Sec. 201. TAX IMPOSED—RATES. (1) Beginning January 1, 2028, a tax is imposed on the receipt of Washington taxable income. Only individuals are subject to payment of the tax, which equals 9.90 percent multiplied by an individual's Washington taxable income. (2) If an individual's Washington taxable income is less than zero for a taxable year, no tax is due under this section.

All a future legislature needs to do is change Sec. 314 and more people will be liable for the tax.

NEW SECTION. Sec. 314. ONE MILLION DOLLAR STANDARD DEDUCTION. In computing a taxpayer's Washington taxable income, a taxpayer may deduct from the taxpayer's Washington base income a standard deduction of $1,000,000 per individual, or in the case of spouses or state registered domestic partners, their combined standard deduction is $1,000,000, regardless of whether they file joint or separate returns. The amount of the standard deduction must be annually adjusted pursuant to section 316 of this act. The standard deduction must be adjusted for nonresidents as provided in section 315 of this act.

Initiative 2111, passed in 2024 to ban income taxes was nullified by the legislature in this bill.

Sec. 1201. RCW 1.90.100 and 2024 c 5 s 1 (Initiative Measure No. 2111) are each amended to read as follows:


Democrats in the legislature appear to be absolutely unaware of our state Constitution:

PREAMBLE We, the people of the State of Washington, grateful to the Supreme Ruler of the Universe for our liberties, do ordain this constitution.

ARTICLE I
DECLARATION OF RIGHTS

Article I Section 1 SECTION 1 POLITICAL POWER. All political power is inherent in the people, and governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed, and are established
to protect and maintain individual rights.

Article I Section 2 SECTION 2 SUPREME LAW OF THE LAND.
The Constitution of the United States is the supreme law of the land.