Rantz: Literally every claim in Pramila Jayapal’s argument for a Washington income tax is a lie
Pramila Jayapal says I-645 gives the rich a $300 billion tax break. The state's own estimate is $11.4 billion. Jason Rantz fact-checks every lie in her post.
Representative Pramila Jayapal claimed Initiative 645 would give millionaires and billionaires a $300 billion tax break. (Photo: Pramila Jayapal/X)
(Photo: Pramila Jayapal/X)
Rep. Pramila Jayapal told Washington voters that repealing the state’s new income tax would hand the rich a $300 billion tax break. It’s a lie, and not even a competent one.
The Seattle congresswoman posted the claim to X on Saturday morning as a way to bring attention to a new ad paid for by far-left unions. She claimed that, “Working families already pay 3 times more than the top 1% in Washington. Now, millionaires and billionaires are trying to pass I-645, a ballot initiative that would give them a $300 billion tax break by cutting social programs in K-12 schools. Make it make sense.”
Every factual claim in that post is garbage. Since she won’t correct it, I will.
$300 billion? The state says $11.4 billion
The $300 billion tax break claim is entirely made-up. It’s not even close to what the state disingenuously claims. The real number doesn’t come from some right-wing think tank. It comes from the state’s own Office of Financial Management, which works for Democratic Governor Bob Ferguson.
OFM estimates I-645 would reduce revenue, after it’s collected, by $11.4 billion over five fiscal years. That figure is in the official fiscal impact statement going into every voters’ pamphlet, though it doesn’t take into account the wealth that has already left and won’t be collected. Jayapal’s number is 26 times higher. She didn’t round up. She added a zero and kept going.
Her $300 billion is nearly four times Washington’s entire $77.8 billion two-year operating budget. By her claim, repealing one tax on about 25,000 households would erase almost eight years of total state spending. Schools, prisons, health care, all of it gone because Brian Heywood gathered signatures. It’s laughable and if it was a mistake, Jayapal refuses to correct it. But it wasn’t a mistake. It was a lie.
Literally everything in this tweet is false. https://t.co/hAV8LzcX2D
— Jason Rantz on Seattle Red (@jasonrantz) September 26, 2026
Jayapal isn’t mistaken; she’s flat-out lying
The Department of Revenue says those households would pay about $3.5 billion a year, according to the Spokesman-Review. At that pace, the state would have to collect for 86 years to reach Jayapal’s figure. Spread her number across every household that would owe the tax, and each one pockets $12 million. I’d love to meet the Medina family waiting on that check.
Even her own side won’t go there. The union-funded No on 645 campaign tells voters repeal would blow a $13 billion hole in the budget (which is also a lie since the budget isn’t built on a single penny collected from this tax). Jayapal looked at the scariest number her allies could come up with and decided it needed to be 23 times bigger.
So which is it? Either a member of Congress with a paid communications staff can’t tell $11 billion from $300 billion. Or she knew, and posted it anyway because it would rack up views before anyone checked. Neither option is flattering. My money is on the second.
Washington State Republican Party Chairman Jim Walsh responded. His party joined the court fight over Attorney General Nick Brown’s I-645 ballot warning.
“Dr. Evil called. He wants his unhinged ransom demand back,” Walsh wrote.
You can’t cut money you don’t have
Jayapal claims I-645 pays for this imaginary break by cutting social programs in K-12 schools. The initiative doesn’t cut a single program. It repeals a tax that hasn’t collected a penny and won’t until April 2029. Every school program in Washington today is funded without it.
You can’t cut money that doesn’t exist. Unless, of course, you’re a Washington Democrat who already spent it. According to the Washington Policy Center, Senate Democrats’ budget proposal this year only climbed out of the red in its four-year outlook because it assumed income tax money would start flowing in 2029. They wrote checks against a tax voters never approved. Now they want you to feel guilty for canceling it. And that was all by design; so that they can claim a repeal impacts the budget. Again, they’re lying and deceiving knowing that their allies at Seattle outlets like KING 5 and the Seattle Times wouldn’t dare call them out.
OFM’s statement also leaves out any impact that depends on what a future Legislature decides. So if a school program ever loses money, it’s because Democrats chose to cut it. They’ll go after schools first, since holding kids hostage is the whole tired strategy. Former Governor Jay Inslee tried the same tax-break line in August and got laughed at. Jayapal borrowed it and bolted on a fantasy number.
The tax cuts for working families survive, too. A legal memo written for the pro-tax campaign concedes that I-645 keeps most of the tax cuts, credits and spending commitments Democrats packaged with the income tax. That includes the expanded Working Families Tax Credit. Her own allies put it in writing. She either didn’t read it or hoped you wouldn’t. Probably both.
Her ‘3 times more’ line is a con
Her opening line claims working families pay three times more than the top 1%. It matches data from the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy’s Who Pays? report. ITEP says the lowest-income fifth of Washington households pays 13.8% of its income in state and local taxes, compared to 4.1% for the top 1%.
That’s a percentage. Jayapal wrote that working families pay three times more, knowing most people will think she’s talking about the dollar burden. So I did the dollar comparison using ITEP’s own averages. The average bottom-fifth household pays about $2,570 a year. The average top-1% household pays about $85,200. The rich pay roughly 33 times more, and Jayapal told you the opposite.
Her working-families talk falls apart too. The three-to-one gap only exists for households earning under $33,500. The middle class pays 10.9%, which isn’t triple anything. And ITEP’s numbers reflect 2024 tax law. That’s before Democrats jacked the capital gains rate to 9.9% on gains over $1 million and pushed the estate tax to 35% in 2025.
ITEP also has a dog in this fight. Its own donation page brags that its research backs taxing millionaires and billionaires. Jayapal took an advocacy group’s outdated spreadsheet and still managed to misread it.
Follow the actual money
Jayapal blames millionaires and billionaires for I-645. Heywood and Bellevue developer Kemper Freeman are big donors, sure. But more than 511,000 Washingtonians signed to put it on the ballot.
The real money is on her side. The No on 645 campaign has raised $7.8 million to the repeal campaign’s $1.3 million, according to the Spokesman-Review. The Washington Education Association gave $3 million. The Service Employees International Union gave nearly $2 million. The Washington Federation of State Employees gave more than $1 million.
Public-sector unions are outraising the repeal six to one, and their members are paid out of the budget this tax feeds. That’s the special interest in this fight. Jayapal just forgot to mention it.
She ended her post demanding that someone make it make sense. Happy to. The Squad grandmother invented a number 26 times too big, misread her own source and blamed the rich for a campaign the unions are paying for. It makes perfect sense. She’s betting you’re too dumb to realize she’s lying to you.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
4 Comments
I am starting to wonder if they are pushing this stuff so they can use the money to keep the bankrupt Democrat Party afloat.
The “no on 645” tv ads are also VERY misleading. Saying it gives millionaires a HUGE tax break and the rest of us will pay more. Pay more how?
"The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money." ~ Anon.
"No one will really understand politics until they understand that politicians are not trying to solve our problems. They are trying to solve their own problems—of which getting elected and re-elected are number one and number two. Whatever is number three is far behind." ~ Thomas Sowell