ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

After the state reversed its denial, Rep. Penner says pamphlet text favoring income tax defenders was likely intentional

State Representative Josh Penner says Washington's voter pamphlet favored the anti-repeal side on three measures and wants Steve Hobbs' office reviewed.

voter turnout washington...

State Representative Josh Penner is calling for an independent review after the Secretary of State's Office admitted a font-size variance in the online voters' pamphlet. (Photo: James Lynch/KIRO Newsradio)

(Photo: James Lynch/KIRO Newsradio)

Republican state Representative Josh Penner says Washington’s online voters’ pamphlet gave bigger text to the anti-repeal side on three separate ballot measures, and he now believes the discrepancy was likely intentional. He wants Secretary of State Steve Hobbs to personally direct an investigation and an independent third party to review how the pamphlet is produced.

Penner, who represents the 31st Legislative District, flagged the problem September 15 in the pamphlet files for Initiative 645, the November measure to repeal Washington’s new 9.9% income tax on income above $1 million. A yes vote repeals the tax. Hobbs’ office first told Seattle Red there was no discrepancy, then reversed itself two days later, as Seattle Red first reported.

Penner has since filed a public records request to learn how the office handled his complaint, and he wants legislative oversight when lawmakers return to Olympia.

A denial, then a reversal

Penner spotted the difference while working on his own analysis of the initiative.

“I opened up the Secretary of State’s files on their website, and I realized one side looked bigger than the other and started digging into it. And sure enough, you know, something that hadn’t happened in the past was that font size had not been differentiated in past elections, but in each initiative this year, it’s very clear that there was a font size difference, and to me, it gave a preference to the anti perspective of the initiatives, you know, the progressive keep the law as-is perspective,” Penner told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

On September 16, Secretary of State spokesperson Helen Smith told Seattle Red the office’s vendor confirmed both I-645 arguments were set in 9.5-point type. Penner answered with a screen-recorded demonstration, measuring the state’s own PDF with a ruler tool to show the text opposing repeal was taller.

ADVERTISEMENT

Two days later, Smith reached back out with a correction.

“We’ve learned that there was a slight variance between the font sizes in the ‘for’ and ‘against’ sections of an initiative in the voter pamphlet PDF previously provided online,” Smith said.

How did the error occur?

Smith attributed the problem to argument language inserted from another file format that nobody caught before the file was finalized. The office replaced the PDF and said the printed pamphlet mailed to voters showed no visible variance.

Penner blames the initial denial on entrenched staff surrounding Hobbs.

“I think this is a weird situation, cuz I know, you know, Secretary of State Hobbs, he’s part of the former Roadkill Caucus, and you know, some would describe him as somewhat of a moderate, but he’s certainly surrounded by entrenched folks who have been there a very long time. And so, I put in a records request to hopefully track it on how the conversation came together. But the issue here, I think, is that when you’re surrounded by people that have an incentive to tell you one thing, they don’t have an incentive to question that,” he argued.

ADVERTISEMENT

Three files, one direction

The state’s correction mentioned only one initiative. Penner contends the same enlargement appeared across three separate measure files, each tilted toward the side defending current law.

“I want to believe in the good efforts of people, and I think most of the time people are doing the right thing. But here’s the part that makes me question that is it’s three separate initiatives across three different PDFs with the same exact inflation of text size in one place that would only benefit one side. So, I agree that most people are doing their work faithfully. I think that here, there’s got to be proof that people aren’t trying to slip something in at this point because you can see it across multiple files, all destined for the voters books that people are going to be using,” Penner said.

Asked directly whether he believes it was intentional, Penner said he sees a strong link because the same discrepancy showed up in multiple documents and had not surfaced in prior elections.

ADVERTISEMENT

“They already have a process for printing these things correctly, and if they have that process, you would have seen these errors pop up before, if the process was in error. And so, if the process is not in error, then, yeah, this shouldn’t be manifesting this year at this time across three different documents. If this was just a simple copy-paste error with no check against it, it would have occurred in the past,” Penner insisted.

Penner has said he reviewed 30 past ballot measure pages without finding the same distortion.

Calls for outside review

It is the second fight over how I-645 is presented to voters. The Washington Supreme Court deadlocked 4-4 this month on a challenge to the ballot’s disclosure warning that repeal would cut school and human services funding, so that language stays on November ballots.

Penner said accountability starts at the top, though he does not want the office grading its own work.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Secretary Hobbs, I think, when people say the buck stops here, I think he’s got to have kind of personal direction on how to investigate this for sure. I think that as we go into legislative session, this is something that requires scrutiny and oversight from us, maybe a little bit further,” Penner said.

“I think that asking the people who produced the document to verify that the document is accurate and safe is not an effective way to work through something so important. I think there should probably be an independent third-party review of such things,” he added.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

6 Comments

J
Johnny Ruger 2 months ago

Election interference, think it doesn't happen? Not just at the ballot box. This is a prime example. We're all being lied to

G
Gear Jammer 2 months ago

This Washington State Government is connivingly vile, and if anyone thinks democracy is under attack your right! It is right here in the not so Evergreen State....It is slowly dying.
Started back in 2004 with the Governors race. Rossi won, let's recount. Rossi won again, let's recount. Aah, we found 129 votes sitting on the floor next to the Xerox machine. Gregoire wins.
Then overturning the the will of the voters on the $30 car tabs, Natural gas inititive, and the Millionaires tax. Inslee and Ferguson are everything that Democracy isn't.........

T
The Watosh 2 months ago

Does anyone actually think that the den of foxes are going to "investigate" the fox in the henhouse?