ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

Rantz: WA elections office walks back denial after Rep. Josh Penner proves voter guide text favored Democrats

Washington’s Secretary of State’s Office acknowledged a font-size variance in an online voter pamphlet after initially insisting Rep. Josh Penner’s claim was wrong.

Voter pamphlet size comparison...

Washington state Rep. Josh Penner demonstrated a measurable difference between opposing arguments in an online voter pamphlet after the Secretary of State’s Office initially said both used the same font size. (Josh Penner/X)

(Josh Penner/X)

Washington’s Secretary of State’s Office is walking back its categorical denial that opposing arguments in an online voter pamphlet appeared in different sizes, acknowledging two days later that there was, in fact, a variance in the document Republican state Rep. Josh Penner flagged.

Penner, who represents the 31st Legislative District, noticed the discrepancy in the state’s voter information for Initiative 645, the November measure dealing with Washington’s newly enacted individual income tax. The initiative has been certified for the ballot, according to the Secretary of State’s Office. The Legislature’s analysis says the measure concerns the 9.9% tax enacted in 2026 on taxable income exceeding $1 million.

Penner posted screenshots Sept. 15 pointing out that the text opposing repeal appeared slightly larger and darker than the argument supporting repeal. He urged people to examine the state document themselves and said he had reviewed 30 historical ballot-measure pages without finding the same apparent stretching pattern.

Secretary of State initially rejects Penner’s observation

On Sept. 16, Secretary of State spokesperson Helen Smith told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red that the office’s vendor had checked the document and found no font-size discrepancy.

“The composition vendor confirmed that both arguments are font size 9.5 in InDesign,” Smith said. “The vendor checked the other committee arguments and Adobe reads them all at font size 9.5 as well.”

Penner rejected that claim, and, privately, the Secretary of State’s Office complained that Penner and some colleagues were questioning their work. On X, he responded by posting a screen-recorded demonstration using the state’s own downloadable PDF and Adobe Acrobat’s ruler function. There was clearly a difference between the text.

ADVERTISEMENT

“What matters is what visually comes across, and what visually comes across is that there is a difference that’s seeable by a discerning eye and measurable by somebody who uses off-the-shelf products,” Penner said.

During the demonstration, Penner aligned rulers against letters in the competing sections, arguing that the anti-repeal text was visibly taller while the rebuttal sections appeared equal.

“You’ll see the margin is significantly more than you think,” Penner said while measuring the text. Later, after comparing the opposing column, he added: “Wouldn’t you know, the con statement is bigger than the pro statement.”

Penner also stressed that his claim was not simply about what font-size setting appeared inside InDesign.

“So, just because you said that one side and the other side’s 9.5 font, it doesn’t matter,” he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Two days later, the office acknowledges a variance

On Friday, Smith proactively followed up with Seattle Red and acknowledged the online PDF did, in fact, contain a discrepancy.

“We’ve learned that there was a slight variance between the font sizes in the ‘for’ and ‘against’ sections of an initiative in the voter pamphlet PDF previously provided online,” Smith said.

She said the variance “likely occurred when the argument language was inserted in the pamphlet file from another file format and wasn’t identified before finalizing the file.”

The office replaced the online PDF and said it would check future publications for similar problems.

Smith emphasized that officials found “no visible variance in the print version” and said no changes would be made to the pamphlet mailed to voters.

State law gives the Secretary of State authority over the pamphlet’s layout and requires it to be printed in “clear, readable type.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The explanation ultimately confirmed the core observation the office had initially rejected outright: the online document Penner examined contained a real visual font-size variance. Penner was right.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

10 Comments

R
R Ice 2 months ago

That is kind of twisted ain't it. So I am running a margin and then that margin is reduced by another TAX BURDEN, when NOTHING has changed. I am to bare the cost of that new TAX BURDEN, NO. Not sure what business the poster thinks is going to NOT pass that on but NO BUSINESS will "just reduce my bottom line" so that other FEEL GOOD.

REALITY CHECK. I run a business and that is to keep my employees EMPLOYED, and that means the BOTTOM LINE must be maintained or I just let employees, like the poster, go. Because without the business, there is NO JOB.

It is that kind of mentality that is driving business away from Washington State.

SOCIALISM DOES NOT WORK KID. I will not bare the cost of you sitting at home playing games. I will simply close up shop, and join in. And so where will that get this great state.

Go back and understand economics kid because the adults already know how to run our businesses and clearly you do not.

R
R Ice 2 months ago

It is the SMALL things that the Democrats are doing that are destroying our nation. We CLEARLY are being attacked by the Socialists. Every single corner or our Republic is under attack. Washington State use to be a state that would rival Silicon valley, Microsoft and Boeing and other companies that would call this home. They are big enough to weather the storm but even the mighty Starbucks is tired of the garbage and bailing on Seattle.

I own a business and they levied a variable tax on my business that is between 9.5 - 11% which ENTIRELY gets passed on to the consumer. So when the consumer wonders why the products cost so much, IT WAS YOU. YOU voted these Democrats Socialists into office, acting like you are so intellectually superior, but then whine about costs.

Seattle has the great honor of being the NUMBER ONE HIGHEST BUSINESS OFFICE SPACE VACANCY IN THE NATION at 37%. Congratulations Democrats, THAT ONE IS 100% on YOU.

With this measure, YOU are telling businesses, GO AWAY AND THEY ARE LISTENING, THEY ARE LEAVING!

T
T Pelican 2 months ago

From today's news:
"Washington voters approved Initiative 2066 to protect access to natural gas. The Washington State Supreme Court threw it out."

Had to chuckle when the lawsuit issue contained the rebuttal included the claim that "the voter always decides".
When they need to emphasize one side over the other (larger bolder-font) you know who will win, again.