ADVERTISEMENT

GUN RIGHTS

Judge says homemade guns are protected arms, putting Washington’s strict ghost gun bans on the legal hot seat

A federal judge struck down Delaware's bans on owning and building ghost guns. Washington enforces nearly identical rules. What the ruling means for WA.

a ghost gun...

A federal judge struck down Delaware's bans on possessing and building ghost guns on September 10. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)

(Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)

A federal judge ruled Delaware cannot stop law-abiding residents from owning or building their own unserialized firearms. Washington bans both.

U.S. District Judge Maryellen Noreika issued the decision September 10 in Rigby v. Jennings, a lawsuit brought by two Delaware gun owners and the Firearms Policy Coalition (FPC). Her order permanently blocks Delaware from enforcing its ban on possessing untraceable firearms and unserialized unfinished frames and receivers, along with its ban on manufacturing or assembling untraceable guns.

The ruling does not touch Washington law since Delaware is in the Third Circuit, while Washington answers to the Ninth Circuit. But a Seattle Red review of the opinion shows Washington enforces nearly every provision Noreika threw out, and the judge flagged the legal hurdle a challenge here would face.

Washington bans what Delaware no longer can

Under RCW 9.41.326, no one in Washington may manufacture or assemble an untraceable firearm. Since March 10, 2023, the law has also barred knowingly or recklessly possessing, transporting or receiving one, with exceptions for law enforcement and federally licensed firearms businesses. A companion statute applies the same possession ban to unserialized unfinished frames and receivers.

Washington first went after homemade guns in 2019, when lawmakers took up then-Attorney General Bob Ferguson’s bill banning the manufacture of untraceable and undetectable firearms. Today, a first violation is a civil infraction with a $500 penalty. Repeat violations become misdemeanors and then gross misdemeanors.

ADVERTISEMENT

Delaware defended similar rules and lost. Noreika concluded an unserialized gun is still an arm protected by the Second Amendment, and she found the state offered nothing showing homemade firearms are more dangerous than factory-made ones.

“Indeed, there is no record evidence here that untraceable or self-manufactured guns pose any danger that serialized or traditionally manufactured guns do not,” Noreika wrote.

She also held that the right to keep a firearm includes the right to acquire one, and building it yourself counts. Delaware’s assembly ban could even stop owners from putting a lawful gun back together after cleaning it. Washington’s statute bars assembling an untraceable firearm, too.

Delaware’s 3D-print file ban survived

Gun owners did not win everything.

Noreika upheld Delaware’s limits on selling and transferring untraceable guns and unfinished frames, treating them as ordinary conditions on commercial sales. She also upheld the state’s ban on distributing computer files used to 3D print guns, relying on a 2026 Third Circuit decision that computer code is not automatically protected speech.

ADVERTISEMENT

That portion of the opinion is relevant to House Bill 2320, which Governor Bob Ferguson signed in March. The law bans using 3D printers and CNC mills to make guns and adds digital firearm manufacturing code to state law. Opponents told lawmakers the files are free speech, and the Ninth Circuit is not bound by the Third Circuit’s view.

The Ninth Circuit hurdle

Noreika’s opinion points to Washington’s biggest obstacle. In a footnote, she cited B & L Productions v. Newsom, a 2024 Ninth Circuit ruling that asks whether a gun law places a meaningful restriction on acquiring firearms.

“Had this case arisen in another circuit, there may have been a nontrivial argument that prohibiting self-manufacturing passes Bruen’s first step because it does not place a ‘meaningful’ restriction on acquiring and keeping firearms,” she wrote.

Noreika added that the Supreme Court’s 2026 decision in Wolford v. Lopez appears to make that standard irrelevant, because the test now asks whether a law restricts keeping or bearing arms at all.

ADVERTISEMENT

She also suggested a state serialization requirement for homemade guns might pass constitutional muster. Washington’s possession ban already exempts firearms imprinted with a serial number by a federally licensed dealer. According to the opinion, Delaware’s bans had no exceptions.

Bellevue-based Second Amendment Foundation, which ended a three-year dispute with the Washington Attorney General’s Office last year, won a ghost gun case in August. A federal judge in Texas ruled the Biden-era ATF frame or receiver rule unconstitutional, though the injunction covers only Defense Distributed, SAF members and specific products.

For now, Washington’s bans remain fully enforceable.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments