Washington Supreme Court candidate Ian Birk demands his rival disavow Republican support, and 62 judges fire back
Sixty-two Washington judges say Supreme Court candidate Ian Birk falsely cast rival Sean O'Donnell as partisan for accepting Republican Party support.
Sixty-two current and former Washington judges signed a letter defending Supreme Court candidate Sean O'Donnell against accusations from opponent Ian Birk. (Judge Sean O'Donnell campaign/Facebook)
(Judge Sean O'Donnell campaign/Facebook)
Washington Court of Appeals Judge Ian Birk is attacking his Washington Supreme Court opponent for having Republican supporters, and 62 current and former judges say the attack is false.
The judges signed a September letter to voters, posted on King County Superior Court Judge Sean O’Donnell’s campaign website and reviewed by Seattle Red. It rebukes Birk over a fundraising email in which he accused O’Donnell of three things: joining a slate of candidates recommended by the Washington State Republican Party, being affiliated with the state GOP while on the bench, and pushing a partisan agenda in the Position 4 race.
Former Governor Jay Inslee appointed Birk to the appeals court in 2022, and Birk now wants voters to treat the GOP nod as disqualifying. Position 4 is one of five Supreme Court seats on the November 3 ballot. The winner replaces retiring Justice Charles W. Johnson on a court that has already blocked a public vote on the millionaires tax.
Judges accuse Birk of breaking the honesty standard
Rule 4.1 of Washington’s Code of Judicial Conduct requires judicial candidates to be scrupulously honest in campaign statements. The signers argue Birk’s claims violate that rule.
“Many of us have known Judge O’Donnell for years. Some of us consult with him on cases. Some of us work with him on policy issues affecting the judiciary. Some of us do both. None of us have ever heard him suggest or inject partisan politics into any of his decisions or work he has done for the judicial branch,” the letter states.
A Seattle Red review of the signature list found that 34 of the 62 signers sit or once sat on the King County Superior or District Court bench.
According to the Spokesman-Review, O’Donnell’s endorsements include the state GOP alongside Democratic Representatives Adam Smith and Marilyn Strickland. Birk counts Inslee and far-left Representative Pramila Jayapal among his backers, the paper reported.
“Democratic elected officials and many Democratic Party organizations have endorsed Judge O’Donnell. State and local Republicans have endorsed him too. In judicial races, bipartisan support is something to be celebrated rather than demonized,” the signers wrote.
Birk campaign refuses to back off
Birk’s campaign dug in when the Center Square asked about the letter.
“Sean O’Donnell needs to make a decision: Either he is fine with his support from the Washington State Republican Party, and it’s not a big deal, or it is a big deal, and he should disavow that support and ask to be removed from their materials,” the campaign said.
The campaign also cited a $500 donation from former Republican Attorney General Rob McKenna. McKenna’s Full Court Press website once listed O’Donnell as a rising star. O’Donnell says he has no tie to the site and asked to be removed.
Earlier this year, O’Donnell proposed that both campaigns stick to their records, and he says Birk never answered. He argues that disavowing the GOP’s Supreme Court recommendations could clash with his obligations as a judicial candidate.
“Impartiality is the northstar of being a judge,” O’Donnell posted on Facebook.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
2 Comments
Sounds like Ian Birk is another gift from Jay Inslee. Probably pales in comparison to the CCA but who knows what kind of damage he could do as a supreme court judge.
Ian Birk demands O'Donnell disavow and distance himself from any endorsements by anyone, while touting his own endorsements by Inslee and Jayapal (D- Hamas). Only in a liberal circus world does this make sense- oh, wait, WA is a liberal circus world...