Rantz: Trump DOJ brilliantly outmaneuvers Patty Murray, handing the president exactly what he wants in Seattle
A Ninth Circuit ruling left Trump one path to keep Neil Floyd leading Western Washington's U.S. Attorney's Office, and Pete Serrano's nomination opens it.
President Trump nominated Pete Serrano for U.S. Attorney in Western Washington as Charles Neil Floyd continues to lead the office.. (Photo: Seattle Red)
(Photo: Seattle Red)
Pete Serrano’s nomination to lead federal prosecutors in Western Washington looks doomed from the start. It also seems a bit confusing. But when you read it in the context of last month’s Ninth Circuit ruling on Nevada’s top prosecutor, it starts to look like the move that keeps Charles Neil Floyd in the job Senator Patty Murray has spent a year trying to take from him. It’s a brilliant move.
President Donald Trump nominated Serrano on Monday to be U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Washington. Serrano already leads the Eastern District office as first assistant. Murray opposed him for that job last year and vowed the same day to block this nomination too, all while pretending that President Trump is a tyrant. Confirmation through a blue-slip Senate is a long shot, and the White House knows it.
So why send Serrano’s name up? The answer comes out of a 36-page Ninth Circuit opinion reviewed by Seattle Red.
What the Ninth Circuit ruled in Nevada
On August 17, a unanimous three-judge panel upheld the disqualification of Sigal Chattah from supervising federal prosecutions in Nevada. Chattah resigned as interim U.S. Attorney two days before her 120-day term expired. The Attorney General immediately named her first assistant, betting the Federal Vacancies Reform Act (FVRA) would elevate her to acting U.S. Attorney automatically.
Judge Eric Miller, a Trump appointee, wrote the opinion and shut that door.
“Nor can the Attorney General create a de facto Acting U.S. Attorney by delegating all of the functions and duties of the U.S. Attorney to someone else. The FVRA is ‘the exclusive means for temporarily authorizing an acting official to perform the functions and duties of any office,’ so it prohibits a complete delegation of all of the U.S. Attorney’s powers to a single person,” Miller wrote.
Floyd is in Chattah’s shoes. Then-Attorney General Pam Bondi appointed him interim U.S. Attorney last fall. When his 120 days expired in February, the Justice Department made him first assistant so he could keep leading the office. Federal judges then picked Roger Rogoff for the job, and Trump fired him 54 minutes later.
Washington sits inside the Ninth Circuit, so Miller’s ruling binds courts here. The Justice Department told KUOW it plans to appeal to the Supreme Court. Until then, Floyd’s first-assistant arrangement is on borrowed time.
The door Judge Miller left open
Miller never said the President is stuck. The opinion describes two alternatives in the FVRA, and both belong to the President alone.
“Those subsections, which include precise eligibility requirements, offer the only ‘two ways the President may override the automatic operation of (a)(1),'” the court explained.
One of them lets the President name a senior employee of the same agency as acting officer. The employee must have worked there at least 90 days in the year before the vacancy, at a salary no lower than the GS-15 minimum. Miller even walked through why Congress wrote it.
“To address that problem, Congress added subsection (a)(3), which allows the President to appoint senior career staff as acting officers,” the opinion reads.
Floyd was an immigration judge inside the Justice Department’s Executive Office for Immigration Review starting in 2018, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, then became special counsel in the FBI’s Office of General Counsel in March 2025. Both are Justice Department jobs. He’s a senior employee. He clears the 90-day requirement whether the vacancy dates to Tessa Gorman’s removal in early 2025 or to Rogoff’s firing in July. The salary floor is the one detail the White House would need to confirm.
Why Serrano’s nomination helps Floyd
Acting service under the FVRA normally expires 210 days after the vacancy, which in Seattle passed long ago. But the law also lets an acting official serve while a nomination for the office is pending in the Senate, and the Government Accountability Office has read that provision to allow service to resume even after the 210 days lapse.
Serrano’s nomination is that pending nomination. Serrano himself can’t serve as acting U.S. Attorney in Seattle, since the FVRA bars a nominee from acting unless he was that office’s first assistant for 90 days in the year before the vacancy. Floyd faces no such bar because he isn’t the nominee.
If the nomination is returned, the FVRA grants a fresh 210 days, and a second nomination restarts the process.
What if Murray blinks?
Murray’s blockade only controls how long this lasts. Floyd’s position comes from the pending nomination, and that window stays open whether Serrano waits three weeks or three years for a vote.
Suppose Murray returns her blue slip, however unlikely. Floyd then keeps leading the office through the hearing and the confirmation vote. A confirmed Serrano would give Washington the permanent U.S. Attorney Murray has fought since last year, and Floyd could stay on as his first assistant. That would make Floyd exactly what Chattah never was, a first assistant serving under a validly appointed boss and first in line to take over automatically if Serrano ever leaves.
A Senate rejection wouldn’t help her either. The clock resets for another 210 days, and Trump can send a second name.
Murray can confirm Serrano, keep Floyd, or keep fighting and buy the White House more time. Every choice leaves a Trump pick in charge.
The White House hasn’t announced any such designation, and Rogoff’s lawsuit over his firing is still pending before Judge Stanley Bastian. The play is still theory for now, and a brilliant chess move by the Trump DOJ to ensure he retains his constitutional authority to appoint the position that Murray is hellbent on dismantling. But the Ninth Circuit told Trump exactly which door is still open, and Murray has seemingly no move that closes it.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
5 Comments
not difficult to outmaneuver old yella teeth murray...time to put the old bag out to pasture
Liberals are ripe for another dose of reality. JD Vance OR Mark Rubio
Patty Murray has always been a mealy tater tot.