ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Oregon wants to ban corporate political cash, but Montana already tried it and the Supreme Court laughed

Oregon's 2028 amendment to ban corporate political spending copies a Montana law the Supreme Court killed in 2012. Jason Rantz on why it loses again.

activists at supreme court...

A proposed 2028 amendment to the Oregon Constitution would bar corporations, unions, and nonprofits from spending money to influence elections. (Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images)

(Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images)

Oregon progressives think they have finally found the loophole that kills Citizens United. What they have actually found is the obstable Montana already drove into.

A proposed 2028 amendment to the Oregon Constitution would declare that corporations, unions, nonprofits, and trade associations simply do not possess the power to spend money influencing elections, according to the Oregon Capital Chronicle. The theory is that states create corporations, so states get to define what a corporation may do, and political speech will not be on the approved list. It is a chartering argument, not a speech argument, which is exactly the point they hope they can make to get this to past legal muster. Backers think they can regulate the entity and pretend they are not regulating the speech.

“The concept here is we are going to put into the Oregon Constitution a thing saying you, as a corporation, do not have the power to spend on politics,” Chief petitioner Jason Kafoury, a Portland attorney, told the Oregon Capital Chronicle.

How cute. This will, of course, fail.

Montana already ran this experiment and lost

Montana banned corporate political spending in 1912 with the Corrupt Practices Act, passed by voters who were sick of the copper barons buying the Legislature outright. It stayed on the books for a century. After Citizens United, the Montana Supreme Court upheld the ban anyway, reasoning that Montana’s documented history of corporate corruption made it special.

The U.S. Supreme Court disagreed on June 25, 2012, in American Tradition Partnership v. Bullock. The justices did not schedule oral argument, or ask for a briefing. They issued an unsigned reversal that treated the question as already answered, writing that Montana’s arguments had either been rejected in Citizens United or failed to distinguish it at all.

ADVERTISEMENT

“There can be no serious doubt that it does,” the Court wrote of whether Citizens United applied to Montana’s statute, per the Federal Election Commission’s summary of the ruling.

Montana voters tried again that same year with I-166, declaring that corporations have no constitutional rights. It passed with 75 percent. A state court threw it out. Montana is now back for a third swing with I-194 on the November 3 ballot, which would bar “artificial persons” from contributing to campaigns. Hawaii passed its version, Act 11, in May 2026. The Institute for Free Speech sued on behalf of the Grassroot Institute of Hawaii within a month. Hawaii’s own attorney general warned legislators during the debate that the bill would likely collide with Supreme Court precedent and stick taxpayers with the legal bills. They passed it anyway.

The press exemption gives away the con

Hawaii’s law carves out newspapers, broadcasters, and periodicals. Montana’s constitutional version carves out bona fide news, commentary, and editorial content. The Oregon push follows the same design.

ADVERTISEMENT

If money is not speech, why does one category of corporation get to keep spending it? Bonneville International, the parent company of Seattle Red, is a corporation. The New York Times Company is a corporation. Under these schemes, both keep their megaphones while the local trade association, the taxpayer group, and the labor union get theirs confiscated. Government deciding which corporations are permitted to speak about elections is speaker-based discrimination, and courts apply strict scrutiny to that.

There is also the small matter of unconstitutional conditions. A state cannot hand you a business license and demand you surrender a constitutional right as the price of keeping it.

Washington will try this next, so pay attention now

Even Oregon Democrats know the odds. A spokesperson for Oregon House Speaker Julie Fahey told the Oregon Capital Chronicle that she considers the Hawaii and Montana approaches intriguing while waiting on the litigation.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Speaker Fahey has long said that meaningful campaign finance reform is not possible while Citizens United is the law of the land,” the spokesperson wrote.

Translation? We know this loses, but we like the fundraising emails.

Washington is next, and the same people cheering this would howl the second it applied to them. Nike co-founder Phil Knight dropped a record $3 million into an Oregon Republican PAC and that is what lit this fuse. Meanwhile Senate Republican Leader John Braun has been hammering Marie Gluesenkamp Perez over out-of-state donations in WA-03. Nobody in this fight has clean hands, which is why I never buy the reform pitch. I said the same thing when Seattle sold voters on Initiative 122 as a cure for big money back in 2015, funded by a $200,000 out-of-state donor.

Washington Democrats will copy the Oregon measure the moment a court gives them the slightest opening, and they will aim it squarely at Let’s Go Washington while the public-sector unions keep writing checks through their PACs. The unions are exempt in practice because PACs stay legal under every version of this. Funny how that works.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

F
Frank Coluccio 2 months ago

Want to end corporate political donations?
Then you need to end union contributions also.
BTW...I agree that BOTH union and corporate donations should be banned. The ONLY donations should come from individual PEOPLE.
Throw PACs and so-called bundlers in the ban "bucket" also.