Lone Spokane Republican councilmember raises concerns about new tenant protection ordinance
The City of Spokane passed new renter protections in the wake of the devastating wildfires, but two councilmembers have concerns about the measure.
The Spokane City Council's lone conservative is urging caution over another potential tax increase. (Screengrab: Spokane City Council)
(Screengrab: Spokane City Council)
The Spokane City Council approved emergency protections for tenants as many struggle to make rent in the aftermath of the devastating wildfires. However, two councilmembers are raising concerns about the possibility of fraud, as well as the long-term implications of putting the policy into effect during future emergencies.
The measure passed by a 5-2 vote with opposition from councilmember Michael Cathcart and Council President Betsy Wilkerson. The ordinance took immediate effect upon its approval Wednesday.
What the ordinance does
The ordinance implements a temporary eviction moratorium for tenants who lose at least 10 percent of their average monthly income as a direct result of the fires. This will also automatically apply to any future natural disasters or health emergencies.
Eligible causes of lost income include a business being destroyed and layoffs or reduction of hours or pay due to an emergency. The ordinance also encourages renters and landlords to come to an agreement on how to reimburse missed payments. Following an emergency, renters have 12 months to pay off missed payments. Landlords are barred from charging late fees or any other penalties.
A tenant has to apply for either the disaster assistance program, unemployment benefits, or other income assistance to qualify. The moratorium goes into effect after the mayor issues an emergency declaration and it applies during the length of the declared emergency.
The council’s lone Republican has concerns
The council’s lone Republican Michael Cathcart said the ordinance is well intentioned, but voiced a number of concerns.
“There’s a number of aspects to the proposed ordinance that really give me a lot of heartburn,” Cathcart told The Center Square. “A lot of that has to do with the self-certification and that whole process that goes along with it, trying to make sure that we don’t basically get into a situation where landlords are having to deal with fraud.”
Cathcart took issue with the provision of the ordinance that automatically triggers a moratorium for future disasters.
“I really think that we should be focused on the Spokane Complex fires,” he said. “How do we address the issues there? And we can come back and work on perhaps a longer-term policy that might have impacts down into the future.”
Cathcart said the ordinance could also put a mayor in a precarious position by having to worry about unintended consequences when declaring an emergency.
“I don’t want to ever see a mayor debating whether or not the impacts of this policy might be greater than the need for a declaration of emergency,” Cathcart added.
Council president Betsy Wilkerson said the financial concerns of landlords also have to be taken into account.
“I also worry about the landlords, too,” Wilkerson said at Wednesday’s meeting. “We talked about extreme conditions. Well, they experienced extreme conditions as well, and how do we expect them to hold on during extreme conditions? I know it says 12 months, but that can be a lot.”
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
1 Comments
Hard to imagine that Spokane is a blue city. WTH? I thought that was the normal side of the mountains.